GLYPHOSATE AND ITS FORMULATIONS - TOXICITY, OCCUPATIONAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL EXPOSURE

Marta Kwiatkowska, Paweł Jarosiewicz, Bożena BukowskaMedycyna 2013 · DOI

Abstract

Glyphosate (N-(phosphonomethyl)glycine) is an active ingredient of the most widely used herbicide formulations in protecting agricultural and horticultural crops. Numerous results (mostly published in the years 2010-2013) concerning the action of glyphosate and its formulations in the recent decade were analyzed. Initial reports about alleged biodegradability of glyphosate in the environment turned out to be wrong. It has been shown that glyphosate remains in the soil and can reach people by spreading along with groundwater. Recent publications have shown that glyphosate is detected at low concentrations in the human blood. Publications cited in this article, which indicate a possible induction of neoplastic changes by glyphosate formulation, have raised great concern and controversy in the scientific world. Presenting adverse effects of glyphosate and its formulations we focused on the role of glyphosate formulations in hormonal disorders by impeding the expression of steroidogenic acute regulatory protein and the inhibition of aromatase activity. The impact of glyphosate on oxygen reactive species formation, changes in redox system and the effect on necrosis and apoptosis in various types of cells was shown. We also revealed that glyphosate as a phosphonate herbicide does not inhibit directly the activity of acetylcholinesterase. Based on numerous studies it was noted that commercial formulations of glyphosate exhibit higher toxicity than that of the active substance itself. The discussed problems clearly show the need to evaluate the toxicity of glyphosate and its formulations and related potential threat to humans.

Introduction: The Glyphosate Paradox

For decades, glyphosate has been marketed as the "ideal" herbicide. Its primary selling point is its specificity: it targets the shikimate pathway—a metabolic route essential for plants and bacteria but entirely absent in mammals. Theoretically, this makes it non-toxic to humans. However, as global usage has skyrocketed alongside the adoption of GMO crops, a significant gap has emerged between this theoretical safety and observed biological effects.

Mechanism of glyphosate action in plants, highlighting the inhibition of the EPSP synthase and photosynthesis.

This review synthesizes a decade of toxicological research to challenge the long-held belief that glyphosate is essentially harmless. The core issue lies in the distinction between pure glyphosate and commercial formulations (like Roundup), which are significantly more toxic and may act as potent endocrine disruptors and potential carcinogens.

Methodology

As a review paper (praca poglądowa), this study performs a comprehensive meta-analysis of literature, focusing on the period between 2010 and 2013. The authors evaluated:

  • Biochemical Mechanisms: Analyzing glyphosate and its primary metabolite, aminomethylphosphonic acid (AMPA).
  • Comparative Toxicology: Comparing pure glyphosate against commercial formulations containing surfactants like polyoxyethylene amine (POEA).
  • Endocrine Disruption: Reviewing in vitro and in vivo data on hormonal markers, specifically aromatase activity and StAR protein expression.
  • Environmental Impact: Synthesizing data on glyphosate levels in groundwater, soil, and human biological samples across various regions including Germany, Argentina, and the USA.

Key Insights: The "Formulation Effect" and Endocrine Disruption

One of the most critical findings is that commercial products can be 17 to 32 times more toxic than pure glyphosate. Adjuvants designed to help the herbicide penetrate plant cuticles also facilitate its entry into human cells, amplifying toxic effects.

Furthermore, glyphosate formulations act as Endocrine Disrupting Compounds (EDCs). They interfere with the synthesis of steroid hormones by inhibiting the StAR protein (steroidogenic acute regulatory protein) and aromatase (the enzyme responsible for converting androgens to estrogens).

Impact of glyphosate formulations on hormonal pathways, leading to decreased testosterone and reproductive issues.

Results and Environmental Persistence

  • Hormonal Impact: Rat studies showed that low doses of glyphosate formulations led to a 35% decrease in testosterone levels and delayed physical maturation.
  • Human Exposure: Monitoring in Canada detected glyphosate in the blood of non-occupationally exposed individuals at average levels of 73.6 ± 28.2 ng/ml.
  • Cytotoxicity: In vitro studies demonstrated that Roundup induces significant DNA damage and cell membrane leakage at concentrations far lower than those required for pure glyphosate.
  • Environmental Stability: Contrary to early industry claims of rapid biodegradability, glyphosate and AMPA are moderately stable, accumulating in soil and groundwater and entering the human food chain.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The authors conclude that the "non-toxic" label for glyphosate is no longer scientifically defensible. There is a dire need for:

  1. Long-term Human Data: Moving beyond animal models to large-scale epidemiological studies.
  2. "Cocktail Effect" Research: Shifting regulatory focus from pure glyphosate to the complex formulations humans actually encounter.
  3. Safety Standard Re-evaluation: Addressing the conflict between independent academic research and industry-funded safety assessments to establish rigorous global standards.

Summary updated

Abstract

Glyphosate (N-(phosphonomethyl)glycine) is an active ingredient of the most widely used herbicide formulations in protecting agricultural and horticultural crops. Numerous results (mostly published in the years 2010-2013) concerning the action of glyphosate and its formulations in the recent decade were analyzed. Initial reports about alleged biodegradability of glyphosate in the environment turned out to be wrong. It has been shown that glyphosate remains in the soil and can reach people by spreading along with groundwater. Recent publications have shown that glyphosate is detected at low concentrations in the human blood. Publications cited in this article, which indicate a possible induction of neoplastic changes by glyphosate formulation, have raised great concern and controversy in the scientific world. Presenting adverse effects of glyphosate and its formulations we focused on the role of glyphosate formulations in hormonal disorders by impeding the expression of steroidogenic acute regulatory protein and the inhibition of aromatase activity. The impact of glyphosate on oxygen reactive species formation, changes in redox system and the effect on necrosis and apoptosis in various types of cells was shown. We also revealed that glyphosate as a phosphonate herbicide does not inhibit directly the activity of acetylcholinesterase. Based on numerous studies it was noted that commercial formulations of glyphosate exhibit higher toxicity than that of the active substance itself. The discussed problems clearly show the need to evaluate the toxicity of glyphosate and its formulations and related potential threat to humans.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kwiatkowska2013glyphosate,
  author = {Marta Kwiatkowska and Paweł Jarosiewicz and Bożena Bukowska},
  title = {{GLYPHOSATE AND ITS FORMULATIONS - TOXICITY, OCCUPATIONAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL EXPOSURE}},
  booktitle = {Medycyna},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.13075/mp.5893.2013.0059},
}
Figure