Genotoxicity of chloroacetamide herbicides and their metabolites in vitro and in vivo

Xinyan Ma, Ying Zhang, Mingyang Guan, Weidong Zhang, Huifang Tian, Caixiao Jiang, Xiaoxin Tan, Weijun KangInternational Journal of Molecular Medicine 2021 · DOI · OpenAlex

Cautionary Note: This paper has been retracted by the publisher. The following summary reflects the original claims and data but should be interpreted with significant caution regarding data integrity and reproducibility.

Introduction

Chloroacetamide herbicides, such as Acetochlor (AC), are used extensively in global agriculture. While their presence in water systems is known, their impact on embryonic development remains poorly understood. Crucially, AC is metabolized in the liver into secondary products like 2-ethyl-6-methyl-2-chloroacetanilide (CMEPA) and 6-ethyl-o-toluidine (MEA). This study investigates whether these metabolites contribute to developmental toxicity and the underlying molecular mechanisms, specifically focusing on oxidative stress and the MAPK/ERK signaling pathway.

Methodology

The study utilized a dual-model approach:

  1. In Vitro: Human HepG2 (liver) cells were exposed to AC, CMEPA, and MEA (10–100 µM).
  2. In Vivo: Zebrafish (Danio rerio) embryos were similarly exposed to assess developmental impacts.

Key metrics included reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation, antioxidant levels (superoxide dismutase [SOD] and glutathione [GSH]), and cell injury markers (lactate dehydrogenase [LDH] leakage). Genotoxicity was assessed via comet assay and flow cytometry, while signaling pathways were analyzed through western blotting. A rescue experiment using N-acetylcysteine (NAC) was conducted to verify the role of oxidative stress.

Key Results

Oxidative Stress and Biochemical Shifts

Exposure to AC and its metabolites triggered a significant dose-dependent increase in ROS generation alongside a depletion of key antioxidants. In HepG2 cells, AC exposure led to a sharp rise in relative ROS levels while simultaneously depressing GSH abundance and SOD activity.

Figure 4: Impact of Acetochlor (AC) on ROS, GSH, and SOD levels in HepG2 cells.

Importantly, the metabolites CMEPA and MEA were not inert. They exhibited similar toxic profiles, particularly in reducing SOD activity, suggesting that the breakdown products of herbicides are as biologically active and potentially harmful as the parent compounds.

Figure 3: Dose-dependent decrease in total SOD activity following exposure to CMEPA and MEA.

Genotoxicity and Apoptosis

The biochemical shifts correlated with physical damage. Comet assays revealed a 4- to 8-fold increase in DNA strand breaks (measured as Olive Tail Moment) in treated cells. This damage, likely mediated by the MAPK pathway (specifically JNK and P38 phosphorylation), ultimately led to increased programmed cell death (apoptosis).

Developmental Impact in Zebrafish

In the zebrafish model, exposure to 100 µM of AC, CMEPA, or MEA reduced larval survival rates at 120 hours post-fertilization to 71%, 64%, and 61%, respectively. These developmental defects were significantly attenuated when embryos were co-treated with the antioxidant NAC, confirming that oxidative stress is a primary driver of the observed toxicity.

Conclusion

The study suggests that Acetochlor and its metabolites induce genotoxicity and embryonic developmental defects through an oxidative stress cascade. While the metabolites CMEPA and MEA show comparable or even heightened toxicity, the retraction of this paper necessitates further peer-reviewed research to validate these specific mechanisms and their environmental relevance at lower, more realistic exposure levels.

Summary updated

Abstract

The toxicity of chloroacetamide herbicide in embryo development remains unclear. Acetochlor (AC) is a chloroacetamide that metabolizes into 2‑ethyl‑6‑methyl-2-chloroacetanilide (CMEPA) and 6‑ethyl‑o‑toluidine (MEA). The present study determined the potential effect of AC and its metabolites on embryo development. Both HepG2 cells and zebrafish embryos were exposed to AC, CMEPA and MEA in the presence or absence of co‑treatment with anti‑reactive oxygen species (ROS) reagent N‑acetylcysteine. The generation of ROS, levels of superoxide dismutase (SOD) and glutathione (GSH) in HepG2 cells and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) leakage from HepG2 cells were investigated. The effects of AC, CMEPA and MEA on DNA breakage, MAPK/ERK pathway activity, viability and apoptosis of HepG2 cells were examined by comet assay, western blotting, MTT assay and flow cytometry, respectively. Levels of LDH, SOD and GSH in zebrafish embryos exposed to AC, CMEPA and MEA were measured. The hatching and survival rates of zebrafish embryos exposed to AC, CMEPA and MEA, were determined, and apoptosis of hatched fish was investigated using acridine orange staining. The present data showed AC, CMEPA and MEA induced generation of ROS and decreased levels of SOD and GSH in HepG2 cells, which in turn promoted DNA breakage and LDH leakage from cells, ultimately inhibiting cell viability and inducing apoptosis, as well as phosphorylation of JNK and P38. However, co‑treatment with N‑acetylcysteine alleviated the pro‑apoptosis effect of AC and its metabolites. Moreover, exposure to AC, CMEPA and MEA lead to toxicity of zebrafish embryos with decreased SOD and GSH and increased LDH levels and cell apoptosis, ultimately decreasing the hatching and survival rates of zebrafish, all of which was attenuated by treatment with N‑acetylcysteine. Therefore, AC and its metabolites (CMEPA and MEA) showed cytotoxicity and embryo development toxicity.
BibTeX
@article{ma2021genotoxicity,
  author = {Xinyan Ma and Ying Zhang and Mingyang Guan and Weidong Zhang and Huifang Tian and Caixiao Jiang and Xiaoxin Tan and Weijun Kang},
  title = {{Genotoxicity of chloroacetamide herbicides and their metabolites <i>in vitro</i> and <i>in vivo</i>}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Medicine},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3892/ijmm.2021.4936},
}
Figure