Global Long-Term Care Research: A Scientometric Review

Liping Fu, Zhaohui Sun, Lanping He, Feng Liu, Xiaoli JingInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper provides a comprehensive scientometric review of global long-term care (LTC) research from 1963 to 2018, analyzing over 14,000 publications to map its evolution, key players, and emerging trends. The findings reveal a rapidly growing field with a shift towards practical applications and highlight "frailty in elderly people" and "dementia care" as key future research frontiers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global population is aging rapidly, leading to an escalating demand for long-term care (LTC) services. While LTC has become a significant public health issue, research in this area is fragmented across various disciplines, making it challenging to grasp the overall landscape, identify key contributors, and understand the field's trajectory. Previous reviews have often focused on specific subfields, leading to a lack of a holistic, quantitative overview. This study aims to address this gap by providing a comprehensive, quantitative scientometric analysis of global LTC research to map its status, trends, and frontiers.

Methods

The researchers employed a scientometric approach using CiteSpace software (version 5.1.R8 SE) to analyze a dataset of 14,019 LTC articles. The methodology involved three main types of analysis:

  • Collaboration Analysis: This examined co-authorship networks, country affiliations, and institutional affiliations to identify major contributors and their academic influence.
  • Document Co-citation Analysis: This technique mapped the intellectual structure of the field by analyzing which references are cited together, revealing knowledge clusters, influential works, and research roots.
  • Keyword Co-occurrence Analysis: This method tracked research hotspots and frontiers by analyzing the frequency and co-occurrence of keywords in articles, identifying emerging themes and trends.

The analysis incorporated visualization techniques to represent complex relationships and temporal patterns within the research domain.

Datasets

The primary dataset for this study comprised 14,019 long-term care (LTC) articles retrieved from the Science Citation Index Expanded (SCI-E) and Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI) within the Thomson Reuters Web of Science Core Collection database. The search was conducted using the term "long-term care" and covered the period from 1963 to 2018.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Explosive Growth and Shifting Focus: LTC research has seen a dramatic increase in publications, indicating growing global attention. Interestingly, citation trends show an inverted U-shaped curve, peaking and then gradually declining, possibly reflecting the time lag for new research to be fully recognized.
  • Geographic Dominance: North America and Europe, particularly the US, Canada, and England, are the leading contributors to LTC research, both in terms of publication volume and influence. However, collaboration among these leading nations is surprisingly weak, suggesting potential differences in their LTC systems.
  • From Demand to Supply, Basic to Applied: The evolution of LTC research trends shows a clear shift. Early research focused on the demand side (e.g., care needs of elderly residents), while later research moved towards the supply side (e.g., workforce, quality of care). Similarly, the field has transitioned from basic theoretical studies to more practical applications and interventions.
  • Emerging Frontiers: The study identifies "frailty in elderly people" and "dementia care" as the most significant emerging research frontiers, indicating areas ripe for future investigation and intervention.

Key Results

  • Publication Trends: Annual LTC publications have shown a rapid and steady increase, with an estimated 1217 articles in 2018 and projected 1302 in 2019.
  • Citation Trends: Annual citation counts peaked around 2009 with nearly 14,700 citations and have since shown a gradual decline.
  • Leading Contributors: The US is the most productive country, contributing 45% of the publications, followed by Canada (12.23%) and England (5.81%).
  • Top Institutions: Universities like the University of Toronto (UT), University of North Carolina (UNC), and Harvard University are among the most productive institutions.
  • Prominent Authors: Mor and Zimmerman are identified as the most productive and impactful authors, though they did not directly collaborate.
  • Hot Topics: Key research themes identified include dementia care, quality of care, prevalence and risk factors, mortality, and randomized controlled trials.
  • New Frontiers: Frailty in elderly people, dementia care, the NH culture-change movement, and LTC workforce/financing are highlighted as new research frontiers.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a limitation in their retrieval strategy, which solely used "long-term care" as the search term. They suggest that future research could benefit from using a broader range of search terms, potentially combined with Boolean operations, to capture a more comprehensive literature. They also note that while this review provides a broad overview, researchers seeking to delve deeply into specific aspects of LTC might need to conduct more targeted searches. The study's findings on emerging frontiers and trends provide a clear roadmap for future research directions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since the early 1960s, long-term care (LTC) has attracted a broad range of attention from public health practitioners and researchers worldwide and produced a large volume of literature. We conducted a comprehensive scientometric review based on 14,019 LTC articles retrieved from the Web of Science Core Collection database from 1963 to 2018, to explore the status and trends of global LTC research. Using CiteSpace software, we conducted collaboration analysis, document co-citation analysis, and keyword co-occurrence analysis. The results showed a rapid increase in annual LTC publications, while the annual citation counts exhibited an inverted U-shaped relationship with years. The most productive LTC research institutions and authors are located primarily in North American and European countries. A simultaneous analysis of both references and keywords revealed that common LTC hot topics include dementia care, quality of care, prevalence and risk factors, mortality, and randomized controlled trial. In addition, LTC research trends have shifted from the demand side to the supply side, and from basic studies to practical applications. The new research frontiers are frailty in elderly people and dementia care. This study provides an in-depth understanding of the current state, popular themes, trends, and future directions of LTC research worldwide.
BibTeX
@article{fu2019global,
  author = {Liping Fu and Zhaohui Sun and Lanping He and Feng Liu and Xiaoli Jing},
  title = {{Global Long-Term Care Research: A Scientometric Review}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph16122077},
}
Figure