Global Genetic Cartography of Urban Metagenomes and Anti-Microbial Resistance
David Danko, Daniela Bezdan, Ebrahim Afshinnekoo, Sofia Ahsanuddin, Chandrima Bhattacharya, Daniel Butler, Kern Rei Chng, Daisy Donnellan, Jochen Hecht, Katelyn Jackson, Katerina Kuchin, Mikhail Karasikov, Abigail Lyons, Lauren Mak, Dmitry Meleshko, Harun Mustafa, Beth Mutai, Russell Y. Neches, Amanda Hui Qi Ng, Olga Nikolayeva, Tatyana Nikolayeva, Eileen Png, Krista Ryon, Jorge L. Sanchez, Heba Shaaban, Maria A. Sierra, Dominique Thomas, Ben Young, Omar O. Abudayyeh, Josue Alicea, Malay Bhattacharyya, Ran Blekhman, Eduardo Castro‐Nallar, A Cañas, Aspassia D. Chatziefthimiou, Robert W. Crawford, Francesca De Filippis, Youping Deng, Christelle Desnues, Emmanuel Dias‐Neto, Marius Dybwad, Eran Elhaik, Danilo Ercolini, Alina Frolova, Dennis Gankin, Jonathan S. Gootenberg, Alexandra B. Graf, David C. Green, Iman Hajirasouliha, Mark Hernandez, Gregorio Iraola, Soojin Jang, André Kahles, Frank J. Kelly, Kaymisha Knights, Nikos C. Kyrpides, Paweł P. Łabaj, Patrick K. H. Lee, Marcus H. Y. Leung, Per O. Ljungdahl, Gabriella Mason-Buck, Ken McGrath, Cem Meydan, Emmanuel F. Mongodin, Milton Ozório Moraes, Niranjan Nagarajan, Marina Nieto‐Caballero, Houtan Noushmehr, Manuela Oliveira, Stephan Ossowski, Olayinka Osuolale, Orhan Özcan, David Páez-Espino, Nicolás Rascovan, Hugues Richard, Gunnar Rätsch, Lynn M. Schriml, Torsten Semmler, Osman Uğur Sezerman, Leming Shi, Tieliu Shi, Le Huu Song, Haruo Suzuki, Denise Syndercombe Court, Scott Tighe, Xinzhao Tong, Klas I. Udekwu, Juan A. Ugalde, Brandon Valentine, Dimitar Vassilev, Elena Vayndorf, Thirumalaisamy P. Velavan, Jun Wu, María Mercedes Zambrano, Jifeng Zhu, Sibo Zhu, Christopher E. MasonbioRxiv2019 · DOI
This study presents the first comprehensive global atlas of urban microbiomes, analyzing over 4,700 samples from mass transit systems in 60 cities. It reveals a consistent "core" urban microbiome distinct from human commensals, highlights geographic variations in antimicrobial resistance genes, and discovers thousands of novel viral and bacterial species.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
As urbanization accelerates, understanding the microbial ecosystems within cities becomes increasingly critical for public health. While previous studies have explored urban microbiomes, they were often limited in scope (few cities, limited time points). This paper addresses the need for a large-scale, systematic, and global characterization of urban microbial communities, including their functional capabilities like antimicrobial resistance (AMR), to better understand their impact on human health and identify potential forensic applications.
Methods
The study employed a multi-faceted approach:
Metagenomic Sequencing: High-throughput sequencing of DNA extracted from collected samples.
MetaSUB Core Analysis Pipeline (CAP): An open-source pipeline for taxonomic identification, AMR gene prediction, functional profiling, de novo assembly, and geospatial mapping.
GeoDNA: A web interface for searching raw sequences against the dataset, enabling rapid identification of genetic sequences and their origins.
Random Forest Classifiers (RFCs): Used to predict city of origin from taxonomic profiles and to identify environmental features associated with microbial signatures.
UMAP (Uniform Manifold Approximation and Projection): Applied for dimensionality reduction and visualization of taxonomic and functional profiles.
MAVRIC: A statistical tool to estimate sources of variation in taxonomic composition based on metadata.
MASH and BLASTn: Used for k-mer based comparisons and sequence alignment to identify novel genetic elements and compare samples to existing databases.
CRISPR-Cas spacer analysis: Employed to identify potential host-virus interactions.
Datasets
MetaSUB Dataset: 4,728 metagenomic samples collected from mass transit systems in 60 cities across three years (pilot study in 2015-16, global city sampling days in 2016 and 2017).
Human Microbiome Project (HMP) Data: 50 samples from various human body sites (stool, skin, airway, gastrointestinal tract, urogenital tract) used for comparison.
Soil Microbiome Data: 28 metagenomic soil samples used for comparison.
Reference Databases: NCBI's NT Environmental, RefSeq, JGI IMG/VR, and others were used for taxonomic and viral sequence identification.
Key Insights and Ideas
A Distinct Urban Core: Cities harbor a consistent "core" urban microbiome of 31 species, largely distinct from human commensal microbiomes, suggesting a unique ecological niche.
Geographic Signatures: Microbial communities exhibit geographic variation, allowing for city-specific taxonomic signatures that can be used for forensic applications.
Novel Biodiversity: A significant portion of the urban microbiome remains uncharacterized, with the discovery of thousands of novel viral and bacterial species.
AMR Landscape: Antimicrobial resistance genes are widespread globally but show geographic variations in type and density, providing a baseline for monitoring AMR.
Environmental Influence: Factors like climate, continent, and surface material significantly influence the taxonomic composition of urban microbiomes.
Key Results
4,728 samples collected from 60 cities across 3 years.
Identification of 4,424 species of urban microorganisms.
Discovery of a consistent "core" microbiome of 31 species.
Identification of 10,928 novel viral species, 1,302 novel bacterial species, and 2 novel archaeal species.
Random Forest Classifier achieved 88% accuracy in predicting a sample's city of origin based on its taxonomic profile.
AMR gene profiles showed geographic variation in type and density.
A significant fraction of reads (~34.6%) did not map to known reference databases, indicating substantial novel DNA.
Limitations and Future Work
DNA-based Sampling: The study primarily used DNA-based sampling, potentially omitting RNA viruses.
Contamination: While efforts were made to control for contamination, the low-biomass nature of some samples presents an ongoing challenge.
Limited Covariate Explanation: While environmental factors were associated with variation, they did not explain a large proportion of the observed variance, suggesting the need for deeper analysis of covariates or consideration of stochastic processes.
Future Work: The authors suggest further research into the clinical impact of identified taxa, exploring seasonal variations in urban microbiomes, and integrating this data with other environmental sources (e.g., agricultural, sewage) for a more complete picture of AMR transmission. The developed tools and datasets are intended to facilitate future research in these areas.
Summary updated
Abstract
Abstract We have created a global atlas of 4,728 metagenomic samples from mass-transit systems in 60 cities across 3 years. This is the first systematic, worldwide study cataloging the urban microbial ecosystem. We identify taxonomically-defined microorganisms collected across three years. This atlas provides an annotated, geospatial profile of microbial strains, functional characteristics AMR markers, and novel genetic elements, including 10,928 viral, 1302 bacteria, and 2 archaea novel species. We identify 4,424 species of urban microorganisms and a consistent “core” of 31 species found in nearly all samples that is largely distinct from any human commensal microbiome. Profiles of AMR genes show geographic variation in type and density. Together, these results constitute a high-resolution, global metagenomic atlas, which enables the discovery of new genetic components, highlights potential forensic applications, and provides an essential first draft of the global AMR burden of the world’s cities.
BibTeX
@misc{danko2019global,
author = {David Danko and Daniela Bezdan and Ebrahim Afshinnekoo and Sofia Ahsanuddin and Chandrima Bhattacharya and Daniel Butler and Kern Rei Chng and Daisy Donnellan and Jochen Hecht and Katelyn Jackson and Katerina Kuchin and Mikhail Karasikov and Abigail Lyons and Lauren Mak and Dmitry Meleshko and Harun Mustafa and Beth Mutai and Russell Y. Neches and Amanda Hui Qi Ng and Olga Nikolayeva and Tatyana Nikolayeva and Eileen Png and Krista Ryon and Jorge L. Sanchez and Heba Shaaban and Maria A. Sierra and Dominique Thomas and Ben Young and Omar O. Abudayyeh and Josue Alicea and Malay Bhattacharyya and Ran Blekhman and Eduardo Castro‐Nallar and A Cañas and Aspassia D. Chatziefthimiou and Robert W. Crawford and Francesca De Filippis and Youping Deng and Christelle Desnues and Emmanuel Dias‐Neto and Marius Dybwad and Eran Elhaik and Danilo Ercolini and Alina Frolova and Dennis Gankin and Jonathan S. Gootenberg and Alexandra B. Graf and David C. Green and Iman Hajirasouliha and Mark Hernandez and Gregorio Iraola and Soojin Jang and André Kahles and Frank J. Kelly and Kaymisha Knights and Nikos C. Kyrpides and Paweł P. Łabaj and Patrick K. H. Lee and Marcus H. Y. Leung and Per O. Ljungdahl and Gabriella Mason-Buck and Ken McGrath and Cem Meydan and Emmanuel F. Mongodin and Milton Ozório Moraes and Niranjan Nagarajan and Marina Nieto‐Caballero and Houtan Noushmehr and Manuela Oliveira and Stephan Ossowski and Olayinka Osuolale and Orhan Özcan and David Páez-Espino and Nicolás Rascovan and Hugues Richard and Gunnar Rätsch and Lynn M. Schriml and Torsten Semmler and Osman Uğur Sezerman and Leming Shi and Tieliu Shi and Le Huu Song and Haruo Suzuki and Denise Syndercombe Court and Scott Tighe and Xinzhao Tong and Klas I. Udekwu and Juan A. Ugalde and Brandon Valentine and Dimitar Vassilev and Elena Vayndorf and Thirumalaisamy P. Velavan and Jun Wu and María Mercedes Zambrano and Jifeng Zhu and Sibo Zhu and Christopher E. Mason},
title = {{Global Genetic Cartography of Urban Metagenomes and Anti-Microbial Resistance}},
year = {2019},
doi = {10.1101/724526},
howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}