Give more data, awareness and control to individual citizens, and they will help COVID-19 containment

Mirco Nanni, Gennady L. Andrienko, Albert-László Barabási, Chiara Boldrini, Francesco Bonchi, Ciro Cattuto, Francesca Chiaromonte, Giovanni Comandé, Marco Conti, Mark Coté, Frank Dignum, Virginia Dignum, Josep Domingo-Ferrer, Paolo Ferragina, Fosca Giannotti, Riccardo Guidotti, Dirk Helbing, Kimmo Kaski, János Kertész, Sune Lehmann, Bruno Lepri, Paul Lukowicz, Stan Matwin, David Megías Jiménez, Anna Monreale, Katharina Morik, Nuria Oliver, Andrea Passarella, Andrea Passerini, Dino Pedreschi, Alex Pentland, Fabio Pianesi, Francesca Pratesi, Salvatore Rinzivillo, Salvatore Ruggieri, Arno Siebes, Vicenç Torra, Roberto Trasarti, Jeroen van den Hoven, Alessandro Vespignani

TL;DR

This paper proposes a decentralized approach to COVID-19 contact tracing and outbreak detection, emphasizing individual control over personal data. By empowering citizens with "Personal Data Stores," the authors argue for a more privacy-preserving and effective system than centralized models, fostering trust and collective responsibility.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of effectively tracking COVID-19 transmission and detecting outbreaks, particularly as lockdown measures are eased. Centralized contact-tracing apps, while potentially effective, raise significant privacy concerns due to extensive digital surveillance and data collection. The authors highlight the need for a solution that balances public health needs with individual privacy rights, especially in the context of potential resurgence of the virus. They also note that a lack of granular knowledge about virus circulation contributes to the necessity of broad, liberty-limiting emergency measures.

Methods

The authors advocate for a two-pronged approach:

  • Short-term: Extending existing decentralized architectures (like PEPP-PT/DP3T) to manage location data locally on devices. This involves a "loose integration" of contact and location data, keeping them logically independent and non-linkable. This allows for voluntary sharing of contextual information by confirmed positive cases, enhancing privacy-preserving global aggregate calculations.
  • Long-term: Pursuing a "Personal Data Store" vision. This involves creating secure environments where individuals can collect, manage, and analyze their own data (including movement, contacts, and other relevant information). Users would have granular control over what data to share, with whom, and at what level of detail, enabling informed decisions about contributing to public health and collective good.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Privacy-by-design is paramount: The paper strongly emphasizes that privacy should not be an afterthought but a fundamental principle in designing public health technologies.
  • Decentralization empowers citizens: Shifting data control to individuals fosters trust and encourages voluntary participation, which is crucial for the success of any public health initiative.
  • Personal Data Stores as a future paradigm: The concept of Personal Data Stores offers a vision for how individuals can actively contribute to societal well-being while maintaining control over their digital footprint.
  • Balancing data utility and privacy: The authors acknowledge the inherent tension between collecting enough data for effective public health interventions and protecting individual privacy, proposing solutions that aim to optimize this trade-off.
  • European approach to privacy: The paper highlights a distinctively European approach that prioritizes co-realizing public health goals with fundamental rights and freedoms, rather than sacrificing one for the other.

Key Results

The paper presents a conceptual framework and a set of recommendations rather than quantitative results from a deployed system. The "key results" are the proposed architectural shifts and the conceptual advantages of the decentralized, user-centric approach:

  • Enhanced privacy: By keeping data local and controlled by the user, the risk of mass surveillance and data misuse is significantly reduced.
  • Improved trust: Empowering users with control is expected to increase their willingness to participate in contact tracing and data sharing.
  • More granular insights: The proposed system allows for the collection of more detailed, context-aware data (e.g., spatio-temporal density maps) that can identify outbreak hotspots more effectively.
  • Scalability: Decentralized approaches are argued to be more scalable to large populations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Critical mass dependency: The effectiveness of proximity-based tracing, even in decentralized models, is dependent on a significant portion of the population adopting the technology.
  • Surface contamination: The paper notes that current proximity-tracing methods primarily detect direct contacts and may not fully account for surface contamination, which can be a vector of diffusion.
  • Technical implementation challenges: Realizing a robust Personal Data Store vision requires significant technical development and standardization.
  • Future Work: The authors explicitly recommend working on two parallel tracks: short-term extension of existing decentralized architectures and long-term investigation into the Personal Data Store approach. They also suggest exploring how to integrate global information from centralized entities with local user data for enhanced self-awareness and improved countermeasures.

Summary updated

Abstract

The rapid dynamics of COVID-19 calls for quick and effective tracking of virus transmission chains and early detection of outbreaks, especially in the “phase 2” of the pandemic, when lockdown and other restriction measures are progressively withdrawn, in order to avoid or minimize contagion resurgence. For this purpose, contact-tracing apps are being proposed for large scale adoption by many countries. A centralized approach, where data sensed by the app are all sent to a nation-wide server, raises concerns about citizens’ privacy and needlessly strong digital surveillance, thus alerting us to the need to minimize personal data collection and avoiding location tracking. We advocate the conceptual advantage of a decentralized approach, where both contact and location data are collected exclusively in individual citizens’ “personal data stores”, to be shared separately and selectively (e.g., with a backend system, but possibly also with other citizens), voluntarily, only when the citizen has tested positive for COVID-19, and with a privacy preserving level of granularity. This approach better protects the personal sphere of citizens and affords multiple benefits: it allows for detailed information gathering for infected people in a privacy-preserving fashion; and, in turn this enables both contact tracing, and, the early detection of outbreak hotspots on more finely-granulated geographic scale. The decentralized approach is also scalable to large populations, in that only the data of positive patients need be handled at a central level. Our recommendation is two-fold. First to extend existing decentralized architectures with a light touch, in order to manage the collection of location data locally on the device, and allow the user to share spatio-temporal aggregates—if and when they want and for specific aims—with health authorities, for instance. Second, we favour a longer-term pursuit of realizing a Personal Data Store vision, giving users the opportunity to contribute to collective good in the measure they want, enhancing self-awareness, and cultivating collective efforts for rebuilding society.
BibTeX
@article{nanni2021give,
  author = {Mirco Nanni and Gennady L. Andrienko and Albert-László Barabási and Chiara Boldrini and Francesco Bonchi and Ciro Cattuto and Francesca Chiaromonte and Giovanni Comandé and Marco Conti and Mark Coté and Frank Dignum and Virginia Dignum and Josep Domingo-Ferrer and Paolo Ferragina and Fosca Giannotti and Riccardo Guidotti and Dirk Helbing and Kimmo Kaski and János Kertész and Sune Lehmann and Bruno Lepri and Paul Lukowicz and Stan Matwin and David Megías Jiménez and Anna Monreale and Katharina Morik and Nuria Oliver and Andrea Passarella and Andrea Passerini and Dino Pedreschi and Alex Pentland and Fabio Pianesi and Francesca Pratesi and Salvatore Rinzivillo and Salvatore Ruggieri and Arno Siebes and Vicenç Torra and Roberto Trasarti and Jeroen van den Hoven and Alessandro Vespignani},
  title = {{Give more data, awareness and control to individual citizens, and they will help COVID-19 containment}},
  journal = {Ethics Inf. Technol.},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1007/s10676-020-09572-w},
}
Figure