TL;DR
This study investigates how French companies strategically manage their reported earnings by manipulating Research and Development (R&D) expenses, both before and after adopting International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). It reveals that companies prioritize accounting-based strategies (capitalization) over real earnings management (adjusting R&D spending) to meet financial targets, and that IFRS adoption has created new avenues for this accounting-based management.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper tackles the complex issue of "earnings management," where companies intentionally influence their reported financial results to meet specific targets or present a more favorable financial picture. Specifically, it focuses on two key R&D-related strategies:
- Real Earnings Management: Managers might cut or defer R&D spending to boost short-term profits. This is often termed "myopic investment behavior" and can harm long-term innovation and competitiveness.
- Accruals-Based Earnings Management (Accounting Choice): Companies can choose how to account for R&D expenses. They can either expense them immediately (as a cost) or capitalize them (as an asset on the balance sheet). Capitalizing R&D can delay the recognition of expenses, thus inflating current earnings.
The research aims to understand if these two methods are used sequentially or concurrently, and how the adoption of IFRS in France in 2005 impacted these practices. The core question is whether IFRS, intended to standardize accounting, has truly curbed earnings management or simply shifted its form.
Methods
The study employs a multi-faceted econometric approach:
- Regression Analysis: Multiple linear regressions are used to model the determinants of R&D expense adjustment (AJUST_R&D) and R&D capitalization (DEP_ACTIV). Key explanatory variables include the "earnings gap" (difference between target and actual earnings), R&D tax credits (CIR), debt levels (ENDETT), company size (TOT_BILAN), and other accruals (ACCRUALS).
- Mediation Analysis: To test the "processual earnings management" hypothesis (i.e., using accounting choices first, then real adjustments if needed), a mediation analysis is conducted. This method, based on Baron and Kenny (1986) and refined by Preacher and Hayes (2008) using Bootstrap, examines how one variable (activation) influences the relationship between an independent variable (earnings gap) and a dependent variable (R&D adjustment).
- Moderation Analysis: To assess the impact of IFRS adoption, moderation analysis is used. This involves testing whether the accounting standard (IFRS vs. French GAAP) alters the relationship between the earnings gap and R&D management strategies.
- Group Comparisons: The sample is segmented into groups based on their R&D accounting practices (chargeurs vs. capitalizers) before and after IFRS adoption to compare their management behaviors.
Datasets
The study uses a dataset of French listed companies from the Economics Industrial Research and Innovation (EIRI) classification for the period 2001-2010. This selection focuses on companies with significant R&D investment, as these are more likely to use R&D for earnings management. The final sample consists of 172 companies, with 86 operating under French GAAP and 86 under IFRS.
Key Insights and Ideas
- R&D as a Tool for Earnings Management: The research strongly supports the idea that R&D expenses are not just about innovation but are actively managed to meet earnings targets.
- Prioritizing Accounting Choices: French companies tend to use accounting-based strategies (capitalization) to manage earnings before resorting to real earnings management (adjusting R&D spending). This suggests a preference for less disruptive methods that don't immediately impact future performance.
- IFRS as a Catalyst for New Management: Contrary to expectations that IFRS might curb earnings management, the study found that for some companies, IFRS adoption created a new opportunity to manage earnings through capitalization, especially for those that previously expensed all R&D.
- "Processual" Earnings Management: The findings support a sequential approach where companies first attempt to manage earnings through capitalization. Only when this is insufficient do they resort to adjusting R&D spending.
- Myopic Investment Behavior Persists: While IFRS might have reduced the need for some companies to engage in myopic investment, the underlying incentive to manage earnings remains.
Key Results
- Significant Explanatory Power: The earnings gap (ECAR_R) significantly explains both R&D expense adjustment (negative relationship) and capitalization (positive relationship), indicating a clear intent to manage results.
- Mediation Effect Confirmed: Activation of R&D expenses partially mediates the relationship between the earnings gap and R&D adjustment. This means that capitalization influences the decision to adjust R&D spending. Specifically, higher capitalization leads to lower R&D adjustments.
- IFRS Impact Varies:
- For companies that were already capitalizing R&D under French GAAP, IFRS adoption did not significantly alter their capitalization practices.
- For companies that previously expensed R&D, IFRS adoption led to a significant increase in capitalization, creating a new earnings management tool and reducing the need for real earnings management.
- Model Explanatory Power: Regression models explained a substantial portion of R&D adjustment (up to 51% for Group 0) and capitalization (up to 38.1%).
Limitations and Future Work
- Sample Size: The authors acknowledge that the sample size, while sufficient for Bootstrap analysis, could be larger. Future work could explore broader definitions of earnings targets and include companies not exhibiting myopic behavior.
- Future Performance: The study did not directly examine the long-term consequences of these earnings management strategies on future company performance or market signaling. Integrating future performance variables would provide a more complete picture.
- Broader Management Strategies: The research focused on R&D. Expanding the analysis to include other discretionary expenses and a wider range of earnings management techniques could offer a more holistic understanding of corporate financial reporting strategies.
- Normative Implications: The findings raise questions about the effectiveness of IFRS in ensuring financial statement relevance, as accounting choices appear to be driven by earnings management rather than purely economic substance. Further research could explore how to better align accounting practices with economic reality.
Summary updated