Geometry-informed irreversible perturbations for accelerated convergence of Langevin dynamics

B. Zhang, Youssef Marzouk, Konstantinos Spiliopoulos

Abstract

We introduce a novel geometry-informed irreversible perturbation that accelerates convergence of the Langevin algorithm for Bayesian computation. It is well documented that there exist perturbations to the Langevin dynamics that preserve its invariant measure while accelerating its convergence. Irreversible perturbations and reversible perturbations (such as Riemannian manifold Langevin dynamics (RMLD)) have separately been shown to improve the performance of Langevin samplers. We consider these two perturbations simultaneously by presenting a novel form of irreversible perturbation for RMLD that is informed by the underlying geometry. Through numerical examples, we show that this new irreversible perturbation can improve estimation performance over irreversible perturbations that do not take the geometry into account. Moreover we demonstrate that irreversible perturbations generally can be implemented in conjunction with the stochastic gradient version of the Langevin algorithm. Lastly, while continuous-time irreversible perturbations cannot impair the performance of a Langevin estimator, the situation can sometimes be more complicated when discretization is considered. To this end, we describe a discrete-time example in which irreversibility increases both the bias and variance of the resulting estimator.

Introduction

In Bayesian statistics, calculating expectations from a target posterior distribution is a fundamental challenge. These distributions are often high-dimensional and complex, necessitating the use of Langevin Dynamics (LD) to simulate a particle's path through the parameter space. Over time, the distribution of these samples converges to the target distribution. However, standard LD often suffers from slow convergence.

Two primary strategies have emerged to accelerate this process:

  1. Reversible Perturbations (Riemannian Manifold LD): These methods utilize the underlying geometry of the distribution (the Riemannian metric) to "warp" the space, allowing the sampler to navigate complex landscapes—such as steep canyons or flat plains—more efficiently.
  2. Irreversible Perturbations: These add a non-conservative drift, or "swirl," to the particle's movement. By breaking detailed balance, these perturbations prevent the particle from backtracking, forcing more rapid exploration of the state space.

Historically, these two approaches have been treated in isolation. Standard irreversible perturbations typically use a constant "swirl" matrix that does not account for the varying local geometry of the distribution. This paper introduces a hybrid approach that synergizes these two concepts.

Methodology: Geometry-Informed Irreversible Perturbations (GiIrr)

The core innovation is the development of Geometry-Informed Irreversible Perturbations (GiIrr). The authors propose a state-dependent drift term that incorporates the Riemannian metric $B(\theta)$. Instead of a constant skew-symmetric matrix $J$, they define a state-dependent matrix $C(\theta)$ as: $$C(\theta) = \frac{1}{2}(JB(\theta) + B(\theta)J)$$ This construction ensures that the irreversible "push" is scaled and oriented according to the local geometry. The table below summarizes the drift $b(\theta)$ and diffusion $\sigma(\theta)$ terms for various Langevin variants.

Comparison of drift and diffusion terms for different Langevin dynamics variants.

Crucially, the GiIrr method is compatible with Stochastic Gradient Langevin Dynamics (SGLD). This makes it applicable to large-scale datasets where computing the full gradient is computationally prohibitive. If a Riemannian metric $B(\theta)$ is already being computed, adding the GiIrr perturbation incurs minimal additional cost, requiring only extra matrix-vector multiplications.

Experimental Evaluation

The performance of GiIrr was evaluated across several benchmarks:

  • Linear Gaussian: A synthetic benchmark for theoretical validation.
  • Normal Distribution Parameters: Estimating the mean and variance of a normal distribution, a classic non-Gaussian problem.
  • Bayesian Logistic Regression: Applied to the German Credit dataset (20 dimensions).
  • Independent Component Analysis (ICA): A complex, multi-modal distribution problem.

Key Results and Insights

The experiments revealed several critical findings:

  • Significant Performance Gains: In the normal distribution example, GiIrr reduced the asymptotic variance of the estimator by one to two orders of magnitude compared to standard LD.
  • Enhanced Mixing: In the ICA task, GiIrr demonstrated superior "mixing," effectively jumping between different modes of the distribution where other methods struggled.
  • Lower Discrepancy: GiIrr consistently achieved the lowest Kernelized Stein Discrepancy (KSD) across all tests, indicating a more accurate representation of the target distribution.
  • Non-Gaussian Advantage: The benefits of GiIrr are most pronounced as the target distribution deviates from a simple Gaussian shape.

Discussion and Limitations

While continuous-time theory suggests that irreversible perturbations always improve or maintain performance, the reality of discrete-time implementation is more nuanced.

  • Stiffness and Discretization: Adding a strong drift can make the system "stiff," necessitating smaller step sizes ($h$) to maintain numerical stability. If the step size is not sufficiently small, irreversibility can actually increase both bias and variance. The authors provide a cautionary example of this "discretization trap" in their analysis.
  • Future Directions: To mitigate stiffness, future research could explore the use of advanced multiscale integrators. Additionally, while numerical evidence is strong, a rigorous theoretical characterization of convergence rates for GiIrr in general non-linear systems remains an open area for investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We introduce a novel geometry-informed irreversible perturbation that accelerates convergence of the Langevin algorithm for Bayesian computation. It is well documented that there exist perturbations to the Langevin dynamics that preserve its invariant measure while accelerating its convergence. Irreversible perturbations and reversible perturbations (such as Riemannian manifold Langevin dynamics (RMLD)) have separately been shown to improve the performance of Langevin samplers. We consider these two perturbations simultaneously by presenting a novel form of irreversible perturbation for RMLD that is informed by the underlying geometry. Through numerical examples, we show that this new irreversible perturbation can improve estimation performance over irreversible perturbations that do not take the geometry into account. Moreover we demonstrate that irreversible perturbations generally can be implemented in conjunction with the stochastic gradient version of the Langevin algorithm. Lastly, while continuous-time irreversible perturbations cannot impair the performance of a Langevin estimator, the situation can sometimes be more complicated when discretization is considered. To this end, we describe a discrete-time example in which irreversibility increases both the bias and variance of the resulting estimator.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2022geometry,
  author = {B. Zhang and Youssef Marzouk and Konstantinos Spiliopoulos},
  title = {{Geometry-informed irreversible perturbations for accelerated convergence of Langevin dynamics}},
  journal = {Stat. Comput.},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s11222-022-10147-6},
}
Figure