Geometric Representations of Whitney Forms and their Generalization to Minkowski Spacetime

Joe Salamon, John Atwell Moody, Melvin LeokarXiv 2014 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In this work, we present two alternative yet equivalent representation formulae for Whitney forms that are valid for any choice of coordinates, and generalizes the original characterization of Whitney forms in Whitney (1957) that requires the use of barycentric coordinates. In addition, we demonstrate that these formulae appropriately generalize the notion of Whitney forms and barycentric coordinates to Minkowski spacetime, and naturally to any other flat pseudo-Riemannian manifold. These alternate forms are related to each other through a duality between the exterior algebras on vectors and covectors. In addition, these two formulae have a geometrically intuitive interpretation which provide interesting insights into their structure. Furthermore, we obtain an explicit characterization of the Hodge dual of the space of Whitney forms on Minkowski spacetime, and this opens the door to treating the theory of classical electromagnetism in a fully covariant fashion through the combination of multisymplectic variational integration and spacetime finite-element exterior calculus (FEEC) techniques. We conclude the paper with the results from an $\mathbb{R}^{1+1}$ wave equation simulation, as a proof-of-concept of the spacetime formulation described herein.

Introduction

Whitney forms are a cornerstone of Finite Element Exterior Calculus (FEEC), enabling the creation of "mimetic" numerical simulations that preserve the underlying geometric structure of physical laws. However, the original 1957 definition by Whitney relies on barycentric coordinates and Euclidean geometry, which poses challenges for relativistic physics. To simulate phenomena like electromagnetism in a fully covariant manner, researchers require a version of Whitney forms that operates directly on spacetime simplicial meshes, independent of coordinate systems or specific metric signatures. This paper provides such a generalization, extending Whitney forms to flat pseudo-Riemannian manifolds like Minkowski spacetime.

Coordinate-Free Representation Formulae

The authors derive two equivalent, coordinate-free methods for representing Whitney forms:

  1. The Covector Approach: This defines a Whitney $j$-form using the Hodge dual of its "complementary" simplex. It describes the form in terms of the geometry not occupied by the simplex, scaled by the total simplex volume.
  2. The Vector Approach: This uses "vector proxies" and inner products to evaluate forms, providing a more computationally intuitive perspective on how a form acts on the mesh.
Geometric representation of a Whitney 1-form on a triangular simplex.

These approaches are dual to one another and mathematically equivalent to Whitney’s original Euclidean definition. By utilizing the language of exterior algebra, these definitions are extended to Minkowski spacetime, the 4D framework of special relativity.

Generalization to Minkowski Spacetime

A significant insight of this work is the characterization of the Hodge dual within the space of Whitney forms. The authors show that the Hodge dual of a Whitney form is not another Whitney form on the same simplex but instead forms a basis on the geometric dual mesh. This clarification is vital for the proper discretization of operators like the codifferential ($\delta$) and allows for the treatment of classical electromagnetism in a fully covariant fashion through the combination of multisymplectic variational integration and spacetime FEEC techniques.

Numerical Proof-of-Concept: The 1+1 Wave Equation

To demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed formulation, the authors conducted a simulation of a 1+1 dimensional wave equation ($\mathbb{R}^{1+1}$). The simulation used an abstract simplicial complex topologically equivalent to a cylinder, representing periodic spatial boundaries evolving over time.

Numerical simulation of the 1+1 dimensional wave equation on a spacetime simplicial mesh.

The simulation results highlighted the importance of light-cone alignment. When the spacetime mesh is aligned with the physical paths light takes through spacetime, the method achieves perfect recovery of the solution, even at low resolutions.

Key Results and Insights

  • Numerical Stability: The $\mathbb{R}^{1+1}$ wave equation simulation demonstrated zero numerical dissipation. While some numerical dispersion was observed in non-aligned meshes, the system's energy was preserved.
  • Lorentz Covariance: The formulation is shown to be Lorentz-equivariant, meaning physical consistency is maintained across different observer frames—a mandatory requirement for relativistic physics.
  • Metric Duality: The research establishes a deep link between Whitney forms and the underlying metric via Hodge duals, which is essential for characterizing the discrete Hodge star operator.

Conclusion and Future Work

This work successfully provides a coordinate-free formula for Whitney forms valid for any flat pseudo-Riemannian manifold. While currently limited to flat manifolds, this research "opens the door" to fully covariant electromagnetism and sets the stage for future generalizations to curved manifolds (General Relativity) and higher-order spacetime Whitney forms.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this work, we present two alternative yet equivalent representation formulae for Whitney forms that are valid for any choice of coordinates, and generalizes the original characterization of Whitney forms in Whitney (1957) that requires the use of barycentric coordinates. In addition, we demonstrate that these formulae appropriately generalize the notion of Whitney forms and barycentric coordinates to Minkowski spacetime, and naturally to any other flat pseudo-Riemannian manifold. These alternate forms are related to each other through a duality between the exterior algebras on vectors and covectors. In addition, these two formulae have a geometrically intuitive interpretation which provide interesting insights into their structure. Furthermore, we obtain an explicit characterization of the Hodge dual of the space of Whitney forms on Minkowski spacetime, and this opens the door to treating the theory of classical electromagnetism in a fully covariant fashion through the combination of multisymplectic variational integration and spacetime finite-element exterior calculus (FEEC) techniques. We conclude the paper with the results from an $\mathbb{R}^{1+1}$ wave equation simulation, as a proof-of-concept of the spacetime formulation described herein.
BibTeX
@misc{salamon2014geometric,
  author = {Joe Salamon and John Atwell Moody and Melvin Leok},
  title = {{Geometric Representations of Whitney Forms and their Generalization to Minkowski Spacetime}},
  year = {2014},
  eprint = {1402.7109},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1402.7109},
}

Loading related content...

Figure