Geodynamics of Super‐Earth GJ 486b

Tobias G. Meier, Dan J. Bower, Tim Lichtenberg, Mark Hammond, Paul Tackley, Raymond T. Pierrehumbert, J. A. Caballero, Shang‐Min Tsai, Megan Mansfield, Nicola Tosi, Philipp Baumeister

TL;DR

Researchers have modeled the interior of the super-Earth GJ 486b to discover how its atmosphere—or lack thereof—dictates the churning of its mantle. They found that while a strong lithosphere is the primary driver of "hemispheric tectonics" (where one side of the planet sinks while the other rises), a sharp temperature contrast between the permanent dayside and nightside is required to "anchor" this pattern in place.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many super-Earths are tidally locked, meaning one side perpetually faces their star while the other sits in eternal darkness. This creates extreme surface temperature gradients. However, the presence of an atmosphere can act as a heat distributor, smoothing out these differences.

Geoscientists want to know how this atmospheric heat transport influences the "engine" inside the planet: mantle convection. On Earth, convection is relatively uniform, but on a tidally locked world, could the interior flow become lopsided? The authors use GJ 486b—a prime candidate for JWST atmospheric characterization—as a laboratory to explore the link between a planet's climate and its deep interior geodynamics.

Methods

The study employs a multi-stage numerical modeling approach:

  1. Atmospheric Modeling: The team used Exo-FMS, a General Circulation Model (GCM), to simulate various atmospheric scenarios (varying pressure, optical depth, and molecular weight). This provided realistic surface temperature maps for the planet.
  2. Interior Modeling: These temperatures were used as boundary conditions for StagYY, a code that simulates mantle convection in a 2D spherical annulus.
  3. Parameter Sweeps: The researchers varied the lithospheric strength (plastic yield stress) and the efficiency of heat redistribution to see which factors most strongly influenced the resulting tectonic regime.

Datasets

As a theoretical modeling paper, the study does not use external training "datasets" in the machine-learning sense. Instead, it relies on:

  • Planetary Parameters: Mass ($3.0 M_\oplus$) and radius ($1.34 R_\oplus$) data for GJ 486b derived from radial velocity and transit observations.
  • Mineralogical Models: Reference density and viscosity profiles based on Birch-Murnaghan equations of state for Earth-like minerals (olivine, bridgmanite, etc.).
  • GCM Outputs: Newly generated surface temperature profiles for GJ 486b under different atmospheric compositions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Degree-1 Convection: The models frequently resulted in "hemispheric tectonics," a degree-1 convection pattern where cold material sinks (downwelling) on one hemisphere and hot material rises (upwelling) on the other.
  • Lithosphere vs. Temperature: Surprisingly, the strength of the lithosphere—the rigid outer shell—is the main reason degree-1 convection happens. If the lithosphere is weak, the planet exhibits uniform, small-scale convection regardless of the surface temperature.
  • The "Anchoring" Effect: While a strong lithosphere creates the lopsided flow, the surface temperature contrast determines if that flow stays put. In "anchored" regimes, the downwelling is pinned to the dayside. This happens because higher temperatures reduce mantle viscosity, making it easier for the stiff lithosphere to "bend" and subduct on the hot side.
  • Mobile Hemispheric Tectonics: If the atmosphere is thick enough to equalize temperatures, the degree-1 pattern still exists but becomes "mobile," meaning the sinking and rising zones can drift around the planet over billions of years.

Key Results

  • Threshold for Hemispheric Flow: Degree-1 convection consistently emerges when the ductile yield stress ($\sigma_{duct}$) exceeds 125–250 MPa.
  • GJ 486b Interior Structure: The authors calculated a core-mantle boundary radius of approximately 4900 km and a mantle depth of 3380 km, with a surface gravity of 16.4 m/s².
  • Tectonic Map: The researchers produced a regime map (Figure 13) showing that "Anchored" tectonics requires a dayside temperature significantly higher than the nightside (a contrast of $\approx 200$ K or more).

Limitations and Future Work

  • 2D vs. 3D: The simulations were performed in 2D. While 2D models capture the essential physics of degree-1 flow, 3D models are needed to understand more complex planforms and how they might affect surface features like volcanic provinces.
  • Internal Heating: The models assumed the mantle is heated primarily from the core (basal heating). Incorporating internal radioactive heating could change the timing and vigor of the convection.
  • Observational Links: The authors note that while we cannot see mantle convection directly, an anchored tectonic regime might lead to preferential volcanic outgassing on one side of the planet. This could create chemical asymmetries in the atmosphere that JWST might eventually detect, providing a "window" into the planet's deep interior.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Many super‐Earths are on very short orbits around their host star and, therefore, more likely to be tidally locked. Because this locking can lead to a strong contrast between the dayside and nightside surface temperatures, these super‐Earths could exhibit mantle convection patterns and tectonics that could differ significantly from those observed in the present‐day solar system. The presence of an atmosphere, however, would allow transport of heat from the dayside toward the nightside and thereby reduce the surface temperature contrast between the two hemispheres. On rocky planets, atmospheric and geodynamic regimes are closely linked, which directly connects the question of atmospheric thickness to the potential interior dynamics of the planet. Here, we study the interior dynamics of super‐Earth GJ 486b ( , , K), which is one of the most suitable M‐dwarf super‐Earth candidates for retaining an atmosphere produced by degassing from the mantle and magma ocean. We investigate how the geodynamic regime of GJ 486b is influenced by different surface temperature contrasts by varying possible atmospheric circulation regimes. We also investigate how the strength of the lithosphere affects the convection pattern. We find that hemispheric tectonics, the surface expression of degree‐1 convection with downwellings forming on one hemisphere and upwelling material rising on the opposite hemisphere, is a consequence of the strong lithosphere rather than surface temperature contrast. Anchored hemispheric tectonics, where downwellings und upwellings have a preferred (day/night) hemisphere, is favored for strong temperature contrasts between the dayside and nightside and higher surface temperatures.
BibTeX
@article{meier2024geodynamics,
  author = {Tobias G. Meier and Dan J. Bower and Tim Lichtenberg and Mark Hammond and Paul Tackley and Raymond T. Pierrehumbert and J. A. Caballero and Shang‐Min Tsai and Megan Mansfield and Nicola Tosi and Philipp Baumeister},
  title = {{Geodynamics of Super‐Earth GJ 486b}},
  journal = {Journal of Geophysical Research Planets},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1029/2024je008491},
}

Loading related content...

Figure