Geodesic Regression Characterizes 3D Shape Changes in the Female Brain During Menstruation

Adele Myers, Caitlin Taylor, Emily Jacobs, Nina Miolane

TL;DR

This paper introduces highly efficient approximation schemes for geodesic regression on 3D discrete surface spaces to study how sex hormones affect brain anatomy. By applying these methods to dense time-series MRI data, the authors provide the first characterization of 3D shape changes in the female hippocampus during the menstrual cycle, revealing a distinct shear deformation tied to progesterone fluctuations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Despite women being at a higher risk for Alzheimer’s disease and other neurological conditions post-menopause, female-specific health factors like menstruation, pregnancy, and menopause accounted for a mere 0.3% of neuroimaging literature between 1995 and 2022. The hippocampus is highly sensitive to sex hormones and is one of the first regions to show structural changes in Alzheimer's progression. While prior studies found no significant volumetric changes in the whole hippocampus during the menstrual cycle, the authors hypothesize that its overall 3D shape does change.

Mathematically, tracking these shape changes over a continuous variable (like progesterone levels) requires geodesic regression on nonlinear Riemannian manifolds. However, standard geodesic regression is computationally prohibitive for 3D surface meshes because it requires calculating expensive exponential and logarithm maps at every optimization step. This paper aims to bridge the gap between computer vision and clinical neuroimaging by making 3D shape regression practically viable.

Methods

The authors propose two fast approximation schemes to bypass the computational bottlenecks of standard geodesic regression (GR):

  1. Linear Regression (LR) Baseline: Performs standard linear regression directly on the 3D coordinates of the mesh vertices. While extremely fast and analytically solvable, it lacks parameterization invariance—meaning the results can change if the mesh vertices are indexed or arranged differently.
  2. Geodesic Regression with Linear Residuals (GRLR): A novel hybrid approach. It retains the Riemannian exponential map to model the underlying shape trajectory (ensuring parameterization invariance) but substitutes standard Euclidean (linear) residuals into the loss function. This eliminates the need to calculate $n$ costly logarithm maps at every gradient descent iteration.

To help practitioners choose the right tool, the authors introduce two "rules of thumb" based on the manifold's local curvature:

  • The $\delta$-Test: If the noise/residual magnitude ($\delta$) is small relative to the curvature, GRLR can be safely used.
  • The $\Delta$-Test: If the total deformation/distance covered by the dataset ($\Delta$) is small relative to the curvature, standard Linear Regression (LR) is sufficient.
Figure 3. Distances in surface space vs shape space. q1 and q2 are two surfaces with different parameterization and different shape. The distance given by the second-order Sobolev metric 2 measures both the parameterization and shape differences. The shape space distance 3 only measures difference in shape.

Datasets

The methods were evaluated using two distinct datasets:

  • Synthetic Mesh Dataset: Ellipsoid meshes deformed with isotropic Gaussian noise at varying scales (1%, 10%, 50%, and 100% of the mesh diameter) and vertex counts (42, 162, and 642 vertices) to rigorously benchmark the speed-accuracy trade-offs of the approximations.
  • Real-World Brain MRI Dataset: A dense time-series consisting of 11 high-resolution structural MRI scans taken over 11 consecutive days from a single female subject, precisely capturing the progesterone peak of her natural menstrual cycle. Blood hormone levels were drawn in tandem with each scan.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shape Spaces are Locally Linear: Because curved shape spaces behave linearly over small regions, standard linear methods or hybrid linear-geodesic models can approximate complex differential geometry surprisingly well when deformations are subtle.
  • Volume Doesn't Tell the Whole Story: Relying solely on volumetric metrics can cause researchers to miss crucial anatomical responses. A structure can undergo significant spatial reorganization (like twisting or shearing) while its total volume remains constant.

Key Results

  • Massive Computational Speedups: Synthetic experiments demonstrated that approximating geodesics with straight lines yields a speedup of up to 14 million times for meshes with hundreds of vertices, while sacrificing less than 0.05% in accuracy (RMSD) for small deformations.
  • Biological Discovery: The $\Delta$-test indicated that the real hippocampal dataset fell safely within the linear regime (showing roughly a 10% deformation factor relative to the mesh diameter).
  • Characterizing the Hippocampus: Applying linear regression revealed for the first time that the whole hippocampal formation undergoes a clear shear deformation in response to rising progesterone levels during the menstrual cycle.
Linear regression reveals hippocampal deformation associated with an increase in progesterone.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation of the biological application is its sample size: the real-world evaluation was conducted on a dense time-series from a single individual focused exclusively on the 11-day progesterone peak. Additionally, the framework assumes that all meshes have been pre-parameterized with valid point-to-point correspondences.

Future work includes scaling this methodology to larger patient cohorts, mapping full 30-day menstrual cycles, and investigating shape dynamics across other major hormonal transitions such as pregnancy and menopause.

Summary updated

Abstract

Women are at higher risk of Alzheimer's and other neurological diseases after menopause, and yet research connecting female brain health to sex hormone fluctuations is limited. We seek to investigate this connection by developing tools that quantify 3D shape changes that occur in the brain during sex hormone fluctuations. Geodesic regression on the space of 3D discrete surfaces offers a principled way to characterize the evolution of a brain's shape. However, in its current form, this approach is too computationally expensive for practical use. In this paper, we propose approximation schemes that accelerate geodesic regression on shape spaces of 3D discrete surfaces. We also provide rules of thumb for when each approximation can be used. We test our approach on synthetic data to quantify the speed-accuracy trade-off of these approximations and show that practitioners can expect very significant speed-up while only sacrificing little accuracy. Finally, we apply the method to real brain shape data and produce the first characterization of how the female hippocampus changes shape during the menstrual cycle as a function of progesterone: a characterization made (practically) possible by our approximation schemes. Our work paves the way for comprehensive, practical shape analyses in the fields of bio-medicine and computer vision. Our implementation is publicly available on GitHub: https://github.com/bioshape-lab/my28brains.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{myers2023geodesic,
  author = {Adele Myers and Caitlin Taylor and Emily Jacobs and Nina Miolane},
  title = {{Geodesic Regression Characterizes 3D Shape Changes in the Female Brain During Menstruation}},
  booktitle = {Workshops @ ICCV},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/iccvw60793.2023.00268},
}
Figure