Genus one Belyi maps by quadratic correspondences

Raimundas Vidūnas, Yang‐Hui He

TL;DR

This paper introduces a "quadratic correspondence" method to derive complex Belyi maps on elliptic curves (genus one) from simpler maps on the Riemann sphere (genus zero). By treating the genus one map as a radical of a genus zero map, the authors provide explicit algebraic solutions for "brane-tilings" in string theory, including the long-standing challenge of the "suspended pinched point."

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the intersection of algebraic geometry and theoretical physics, Belyi maps are rational functions that ramify at exactly three points. These maps are visually represented by dessins d’enfant ("children's drawings")—bipartite graphs embedded on surfaces.

While computing these maps for a sphere (genus zero) is relatively straightforward, doing so for a torus or elliptic curve (genus one) is notoriously difficult. This is a significant bottleneck for physicists studying brane-tilings in string theory, where these graphs represent the structure of supersymmetric gauge theories. Many physical models, such as the "suspended pinched point" (SPP), lacked explicit algebraic descriptions for years because the underlying Belyi maps were too complex to solve directly.

Methods

The authors propose a shortcut called Quadratic Correspondence. Instead of solving for a genus one map $\phi_1$ from scratch, they define it using a radical expression of a genus zero map $\phi_0$:

$$\phi_1 = \mathcal{Q}\{\phi_0\} := \frac{1}{2} + \frac{\sqrt{1 - \phi_0}}{2}$$

Key aspects of the methodology include:

  • Passport Matching: The authors define "correspondent passports"—specific branching patterns that allow a genus one map to be reduced to a genus zero map.
  • Symmetry Exploitation: The method relies on the existence of a central anti-symmetry in the dessin (the graph), which allows the elliptic curve to be defined by the square root of the genus zero function.
  • Computational Tools: They utilize specialized Maple programs to compute nearly-regular genus zero Belyi maps, which are then transformed into the desired genus one maps.
  • Painlevé Inspiration: The technique is inspired by symmetric representations of algebraic solutions to the Painlevé VI equation, a classic non-linear differential equation.

Datasets

The paper does not use traditional "big data" sets. Instead, it targets established "catalogues" of physical models:

  • DHP Catalogue: A standard list of brane-tilings from Davey, Hanany, and Pasukonis (2010).
  • FHSY Catalogue: A comprehensive survey of brane-tilings by Franco, He, Sun, and Xiao (2017).
  • The authors specifically target tilings labeled as "SPP," $L^{131}$, $L^{222}(II)$, $dP_1$, and $L^{232}$.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Radical Link: The "aha moment" is realizing that the radical $\sqrt{1 - \phi_0}$ essentially "builds" the elliptic curve. If $\phi_0$ is chosen correctly, the resulting $\phi_1$ is a valid Belyi map on that curve.
  • Geometric Reduction: A complex bipartite graph on a torus can often be "folded" or reduced to a simpler graph on a sphere if it possesses specific involution symmetries.
  • Physics-Math Bridge: The paper demonstrates that bipartite graphs arising in string theory (physics) and those arising in the study of differential equations (math) are often the same objects, allowing techniques from one field to solve "impossible" problems in the other.

Key Results

  • Solving the SPP: The authors successfully found the explicit Belyi map for the Suspended Pinched Point, a problem that had been a "standing challenge for a number of years."
  • New Explicit Maps: They provided a library of explicit genus one Belyi maps for degrees ranging from 7 to 12.
  • Classification: They established the "Passport Structure" (Section 2), which provides a rigorous set of rules for when a genus one map can be simplified using this quadratic method.
  • Painlevé Connection: They demonstrated that several known algebraic solutions to the Painlevé VI equation are actually Belyi maps in disguise.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Symmetry Requirement: The method is not universal; it only works for genus one maps that possess a specific "central anti-symmetry." Maps without this symmetry cannot be reduced to genus zero via this specific quadratic correspondence.
  • Automation Gaps: While the computation of genus zero maps is efficient, simplifying the resulting elliptic curve equations into the "canonical" Weierstrass form ($y^2 = 4x^3 - g_2x - g_3$) remains a cumbersome, manual process.
  • Orbifold Theories: The authors mention "orbifold" theories that their current method doesn't fully address, leaving these for a future systematic study involving isogenies (mappings between elliptic curves).

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a method of obtaining a Belyi map on an elliptic curve from that on the Riemann sphere. This is done by writing the former as a radical of the latter, which we call a quadratic correspondence, with the radical determining the elliptic curve. With a host of examples of various degrees, we demonstrate that the correspondence is an efficient way of obtaining genus one Belyi maps. As applications, we find the Belyi maps for the dessins d’enfant which have arisen as brane-tilings in the physics community, including ones, such as the so-called suspended pinched point, which have been a standing challenge for a number of years.
BibTeX
@article{vidunas2020genus,
  author = {Raimundas Vidūnas and Yang‐Hui He},
  title = {{Genus one Belyi maps by quadratic correspondences}},
  journal = {International Journal of Mathematics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1142/s0129167x20500342},
}

Loading related content...

Figure