Genomic epidemiology of the cholera outbreak in Malawi 2022-2023

Lucious Chabuka, Wonderful T. Choga, Carla Mavian, Monika Moir, Houriiyah Tegally, Eduan Wilkinson, Yeshnee Naidoo, Rhys Inward, Christian Morgenstern, Samir Bhatt, G. R. WilliamWint, Kamran Khan, Isaac I. Bogoch, Moritz U. G. Kraemer, Cheryl Baxter, Massimiliano S. Tagliamonte, Marco Salemi, Richard Lessells, Collins Mitambo, Ronald Chitatanga, Joseph Bitilinyu- Bango, Mabvuto Chiwaula, Yollamu Chavula, Mphatso Bukhu, Happy Manda, Moses Chitenje, Innocent Malolo, Alex Mwanyongo, Dr Bernard Mvula, Dr Mirrium Nyenje, Túlio de Oliveira, Dr Mathew KagolimedRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

By sequencing 49 Vibrio cholerae genomes, researchers have traced Malawi’s largest-ever cholera outbreak (2022–2023) back to a 2022 outbreak in Pakistan. The study demonstrates how extreme weather events and international travel act as catalysts for the transcontinental spread of infectious diseases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cholera has been endemic in Malawi since 1998, typically following a seasonal pattern tied to the rainy season. However, starting in early 2022, the country faced an unprecedented crisis: over 58,000 cases and 1,700 deaths, marking its most severe outbreak on record.

The central question for public health officials was whether this surge was driven by local strains exacerbated by climate change or a new, more virulent importation. Understanding the "genomic epidemiology"—the intersection of the pathogen's genetic code, human movement, and environmental factors—is crucial for predicting future outbreaks and coordinating regional responses.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-disciplinary approach combining genomics, phylogenetics, and epidemiological modeling:

  • Genomic Sequencing: They performed whole-genome sequencing (WGS) on 49 high-quality isolates collected across Malawi between late 2022 and early 2023.
  • Phylogenetic Inference: Using Maximum Likelihood (IQ-TREE) and Bayesian frameworks (BEAST), they compared the Malawian sequences against a massive global dataset to find the closest "relatives."
  • Epidemiological Modeling: They used a semi-mechanistic Bayesian framework (via the epidemia R package) to calculate the time-varying reproduction number ($R_t$) and correlate it with environmental data.
  • Connectivity Analysis: To support the transmission hypothesis, they analyzed international air travel data (IATA) to quantify passenger volumes between Asia and Malawi.

Datasets

  • New Data: 49 near-complete Vibrio cholerae genomes from Malawi.
  • Global Reference Set: 2,159 publicly available genomes spanning Africa, Asia, the Americas, and Europe (1957–2023).
  • Environmental Data: Satellite-derived flooding data from NASA (MODIS) and NOAA (VIIRS) to track the impact of Cyclones Ana, Gombe, and Freddy.
  • Travel Data: IATA passenger itineraries for the first half of 2022.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Pakistan Connection: The most striking finding is that the Malawian strains are nearly identical to those from the 2022 Pakistan cholera outbreak. The Malawian sequences formed a "monophyletic clade" (a single evolutionary branch) nested within the Pakistan strains, suggesting a single long-range transmission event.
  • Climate as a Multiplier: The study highlights a "perfect storm" of environmental factors. The most recent common ancestor (MRCA) of the Malawi lineage was estimated to exist around July 2022—shortly after the Pakistan floods and just as Malawi was reeling from Cyclones Ana and Gombe.
  • The "T15" Lineage: This specific lineage appears to have emerged during the Pakistan floods and was subsequently introduced to Malawi, where it was exacerbated by local flooding and mass human displacement.
  • Urban Hubs: Phylogeographic analysis suggests that once the virus took hold, it spread from initial hubs like Machinga and Blantyre to Lilongwe, eventually reaching all 29 districts of Malawi.

Key Results

  • Scale of Outbreak: 58,000+ confirmed cases and 1,761 deaths as of May 2023.
  • Genetic Link: Malawian strains showed a high bootstrap support (>90%) for their relationship to the 2022 Pakistan isolates.
  • Transmission Timing: The MRCA for the Malawi strains was dated to July 2022 (95% HPD: March–October 2022).
  • Environmental Correlation: The study found a positive association between flooding events and increases in the reproduction number ($R_t$), confirming that extreme weather directly facilitated the epidemic's acceleration.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sampling Bias: Because the 49 samples were collected between December 2022 and February 2023, the researchers cannot definitively prove if this specific introduction started the outbreak in early 2022 or simply fueled its later, more massive expansion.
  • Missing Links: There is a need for more sequences from earlier in the 2022 outbreak and from neighboring African countries to understand the full extent of regional cross-border transmission.
  • Future Directions: The paper calls for a permanent, coordinated global genomic surveillance system for cholera, emphasizing that an outbreak in one part of the world (like Pakistan) is a direct threat to public health thousands of miles away (like Malawi) in our highly connected world.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Since early 2022, in the aftermath of two extreme weather events, Malawi experienced its largest ever cholera outbreak, with over 58,000 reported cases and 1,761 deaths as of May 2023. We generated 49 high-quality, near-complete Vibrio cholerae genomes in Malawi from isolates collected between December 2022 and March 2023 from all three regions of Malawi. Using phylogenetic methods with 2159 publicly available genomes, we present evidence suggesting that the Malawi outbreak strains originated from the Pakistan outbreak, the estimated most recent ancestor of this lineage, named T15, was during the Pakistan floods, and once introduced into Malawi was exacerbated by major floods between June and October 2022. The extreme weather events and humanitarian crises in Malawi provided the environment for the spread of Vibrio cholerae, and the subsequent movement of large numbers of people may have facilitated its spread to susceptible populations in areas relatively unaffected by cholera for over a decade.
BibTeX
@misc{chabuka2023genomic,
  author = {Lucious Chabuka and Wonderful T. Choga and Carla Mavian and Monika Moir and Houriiyah Tegally and Eduan Wilkinson and Yeshnee Naidoo and Rhys Inward and Christian Morgenstern and Samir Bhatt and G. R. WilliamWint and Kamran Khan and Isaac I. Bogoch and Moritz U. G. Kraemer and Cheryl Baxter and Massimiliano S. Tagliamonte and Marco Salemi and Richard Lessells and Collins Mitambo and Ronald Chitatanga and Joseph Bitilinyu- Bango and Mabvuto Chiwaula and Yollamu Chavula and Mphatso Bukhu and Happy Manda and Moses Chitenje and Innocent Malolo and Alex Mwanyongo and Dr Bernard Mvula and Dr Mirrium Nyenje and Túlio de Oliveira and Dr Mathew Kagoli},
  title = {{Genomic epidemiology of the cholera outbreak in Malawi 2022-2023}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.08.22.23294324},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure