Evolution and epidemic spread of SARS-CoV-2 in Brazil
Darlan S. Candido, Ingra Morales Claro, Jaqueline Góes de Jesus, William Marciel de Souza, Filipe Romero Rebello Moreira, Simon Dellicour, Thomas A. Mellan, Louis du Plessis, Rafael H. M. Pereira, Flavia Cristina da Silva Sales, Erika R. Manuli, Julien Thézé, Luiz Gonzaga Paula de Almeida, Mariane Talon de Menezes, Carolina Moreira Voloch, Marcílio Jorge Fumagalli, Thaís de Moura Coletti, Camila Alves Maia da Silva, Mariana Severo Ramundo, Mariene R. Amorim, Henrique Hoeltgebaum, Swapnil Mishra, Mandev S. Gill, Luiz Max Carvalho, Lewis Buss, Carlos A. Prete, Jordan Ashworth, Helder I. Nakaya, Pedro Vieira da Silva Peixoto, Oliver J. Brady, Samuel M. Nicholls, Amílcar Tanuri, Átila Duque Rossi, Carlos Kauê Vieira Braga, Alexandra Lehmkuhl Gerber, Ana Paula de Campos Guimarães, Nelson Gaburo, Cecila Salete Alencar, Alessandro Clayton de Souza Ferreira, Cristiano Xavier Lima, José Eduardo Levi, Celso Granato, Giula M. Ferreira, Ronaldo da Silva Francisco, Fabiana Granja, Márcia Teixeira Garcia, Maria Luíza Moretti, Maurício Wesley Perroud, Terezinha Marta Pereira Pinto Castiñeiras, Carolina S. Lázari, Sarah C. Hill, Andreza Aruska de Souza Santos, Camila L. Simeoni, Julia Forato, Andrei C. Spósito, Angélica Zaninelli Schreiber, Magnun Nueldo Nunes Santos, Camila Zolini de Sá, Renan P. Souza, Luciana C. Resende‐Moreira, Mauro Martins Teixeira, Jôsy Hubner, Patrícia Asfora Falabella Leme, Rennan Garcias Moreira, Maurício Lacerda Nogueira, Neil M. Ferguson, Sílvia Figueiredo Costa, José Luiz Proença‐Módena, Ana Tereza Ribeiro de Vasconcelos, Samir Bhatt, Philippe Lemey, Chieh‐Hsi Wu, Andrew Rambaut, Nicholas J. Loman, Renato Santana Aguiar, Oliver G. Pybus, Éster Cerdeira Sabino, Nuno R. FariamedRxiv2020 · DOI
Brazil currently has one of the fastest growing SARS-CoV-2 epidemics in the world. Due to limited available data, assessments of the impact of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) on virus transmission and epidemic spread remain challenging. We investigate the impact of NPIs in Brazil using epidemiological, mobility and genomic data. Mobility-driven transmission models for São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro cities show that the reproduction number ($R_t$) reached below 1 following NPIs but slowly increased to values between 1 to 1.3. Genome sequencing of 427 new genomes and analysis of a geographically representative genomic dataset from 21 of the 27 Brazilian states identified >100 international introductions of SARS-CoV-2 in Brazil. We estimate that three clades introduced from Europe emerged between 22 and 27 February 2020, and were already well-established before the implementation of NPIs and travel bans. During this first phase of the epidemic establishment of SARS-CoV-2 in Brazil, we find that the virus spread mostly locally and within-state borders. Despite sharp decreases in national air travel during this period, we detected a 25% increase in the average distance travelled by air passengers during this time period. This coincided with the spread of SARS-CoV-2 from large urban centers to the rest of the country.
Introduction
In early 2020, Brazil emerged as a global epicenter for COVID-19. However, understanding the virus's spread was hampered by inconsistent testing and significant data gaps. Public health officials faced critical questions regarding the efficacy of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) and the mechanisms by which the virus reached remote regions. This study addresses these gaps by integrating genomic, mobility, and epidemiological data to reconstruct the epidemic's trajectory, moving beyond unreliable confirmed case counts to utilize more robust indicators like deaths from Severe Acute Respiratory Infection (SARI).
Methods and Data Integration
The researchers employed a multi-modal approach to map the epidemic:
Bayesian Semi-Mechanistic Modeling: $R_t$ was modeled using SARI death data and mobility indices from Google and InLoco, providing a real-time view of NPI impacts.
Genomic Surveillance: 427 new SARS-CoV-2 genomes were sequenced from 21 Brazilian states, totaling a dataset of 490 sequences.
Phylogeography: Molecular clock analysis and continuous phylogeographic models were used to track viral evolution and geographic movement over time.
Mobility Data: Integration of geolocation data (InLoco), Google Mobility Reports, and national flight data (ANAC) provided insights into human movement patterns.
Figure 4: Timeline of SARS-CoV-2 introduction and genomic sequencing efforts across Brazilian states. (A) shows the lag between first cases, deaths, and genome collection. (B) correlates genome counts with total cases per state. (C) displays the lag between symptom onset and sample collection.
Analysis revealed that the vast majority of Brazil's early cases resulted from over 100 separate international introductions, primarily from Europe (notably Italy) and the USA. Approximately 75% of the Brazilian genomes belonged to three dominant clades that emerged between February 22 and 27, 2020. Crucially, these lineages were already well-established in the community before travel bans and NPIs were enacted. São Paulo acted as a primary gateway, accounting for 36% of all international imports.
Transmission Dynamics and NPI Efficacy
The study focused on the impact of NPIs in the major urban centers of São Paulo (SP) and Rio de Janeiro (RJ). Initially, $R_t$ in these cities exceeded 3.0. While NPIs successfully drove $R_t$ below the critical threshold of 1.0, this suppression was short-lived. By early May, $R_t$ values had rebounded to between 1.0 and 1.3, suggesting that the interventions were insufficient for sustained control.
Figure 1: Epidemic growth and transmission dynamics in Brazil. (A) Cumulative cases and deaths on a log scale. (B) Geographic distribution of cases by state. (C-D) Reproduction number (Rt) over time in São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro cities, showing the impact of NPIs (grey shaded area).
A significant finding was the "Air Travel Paradox." While the total volume of domestic flights plummeted during the epidemic's second phase, the average distance traveled by remaining passengers increased by 25%. This shift indicates that while local travel decreased, long-distance "leaks" from major hubs like SP and RJ continued, effectively seeding the virus in the country's interior. Within-state movement was nearly three times more frequent than between-state movement, yet these long-distance connections were sufficient to ignite regional outbreaks.
Conclusion
The joint analysis of genomic and mobility data reveals that SARS-CoV-2 was "ignited" in highly connected urban centers and rapidly exported nationwide. The early establishment of dominant clades before NPI implementation highlights the challenges of containing a silent, widespread community transmission. Furthermore, the rebound of $R_t$ above 1.0 underscores the ongoing risk as interventions are relaxed, particularly for less-resourced regions in the north and northeast.
Summary updated
Abstract
Abstract Brazil currently has one of the fastest growing SARS-CoV-2 epidemics in the world. Due to limited available data, assessments of the impact of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) on virus transmission and epidemic spread remain challenging. We investigate the impact of NPIs in Brazil using epidemiological, mobility and genomic data. Mobility-driven transmission models for São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro cities show that the reproduction number ( R t ) reached below 1 following NPIs but slowly increased to values between 1 to 1.3 (1.0–1.6). Genome sequencing of 427 new genomes and analysis of a geographically representative genomic dataset from 21 of the 27 Brazilian states identified >100 international introductions of SARS-CoV-2 in Brazil. We estimate that three clades introduced from Europe emerged between 22 and 27 February 2020, and were already well-established before the implementation of NPIs and travel bans. During this first phase of the epidemic establishment of SARS-CoV-2 in Brazil, we find that the virus spread mostly locally and within-state borders. Despite sharp decreases in national air travel during this period, we detected a 25% increase in the average distance travelled by air passengers during this time period. This coincided with the spread of SARS-CoV-2 from large urban centers to the rest of the country. In conclusion, our results shed light on the role of large and highly connected populated centres in the rapid ignition and establishment of SARS-CoV-2, and provide evidence that current interventions remain insufficient to keep virus transmission under control in Brazil. One Sentence Summary Joint analysis of genomic, mobility and epidemiological novel data provide unique insight into the spread and transmission of the rapidly evolving epidemic of SARS-CoV-2 in Brazil.
BibTeX
@misc{candido2020evolution,
author = {Darlan S. Candido and Ingra Morales Claro and Jaqueline Góes de Jesus and William Marciel de Souza and Filipe Romero Rebello Moreira and Simon Dellicour and Thomas A. Mellan and Louis du Plessis and Rafael H. M. Pereira and Flavia Cristina da Silva Sales and Erika R. Manuli and Julien Thézé and Luiz Gonzaga Paula de Almeida and Mariane Talon de Menezes and Carolina Moreira Voloch and Marcílio Jorge Fumagalli and Thaís de Moura Coletti and Camila Alves Maia da Silva and Mariana Severo Ramundo and Mariene R. Amorim and Henrique Hoeltgebaum and Swapnil Mishra and Mandev S. Gill and Luiz Max Carvalho and Lewis Buss and Carlos A. Prete and Jordan Ashworth and Helder I. Nakaya and Pedro Vieira da Silva Peixoto and Oliver J. Brady and Samuel M. Nicholls and Amílcar Tanuri and Átila Duque Rossi and Carlos Kauê Vieira Braga and Alexandra Lehmkuhl Gerber and Ana Paula de Campos Guimarães and Nelson Gaburo and Cecila Salete Alencar and Alessandro Clayton de Souza Ferreira and Cristiano Xavier Lima and José Eduardo Levi and Celso Granato and Giula M. Ferreira and Ronaldo da Silva Francisco and Fabiana Granja and Márcia Teixeira Garcia and Maria Luíza Moretti and Maurício Wesley Perroud and Terezinha Marta Pereira Pinto Castiñeiras and Carolina S. Lázari and Sarah C. Hill and Andreza Aruska de Souza Santos and Camila L. Simeoni and Julia Forato and Andrei C. Spósito and Angélica Zaninelli Schreiber and Magnun Nueldo Nunes Santos and Camila Zolini de Sá and Renan P. Souza and Luciana C. Resende‐Moreira and Mauro Martins Teixeira and Jôsy Hubner and Patrícia Asfora Falabella Leme and Rennan Garcias Moreira and Maurício Lacerda Nogueira and Neil M. Ferguson and Sílvia Figueiredo Costa and José Luiz Proença‐Módena and Ana Tereza Ribeiro de Vasconcelos and Samir Bhatt and Philippe Lemey and Chieh‐Hsi Wu and Andrew Rambaut and Nicholas J. Loman and Renato Santana Aguiar and Oliver G. Pybus and Éster Cerdeira Sabino and Nuno R. Faria and Nuno Rodrigues Faria},
title = {{Evolution and epidemic spread of SARS-CoV-2 in Brazil}},
year = {2020},
doi = {10.1101/2020.06.11.20128249},
howpublished = {medRxiv},
}