Genetic evolution of class I Newcastle disease virus from poultry at live bird markets in Eastern China

Xiaolong Lu, Xiaoquan Wang, Yifan Sun, Xin Wang, Feng Lin, Yu Chen, Tiansong Zhan, Naiqing Xu, Tianxing Liao, Jiao Hu, Zenglei Hu, Min Gu, Shunlin Hu, Xiaowen Liu, Xiufan LiuResearch 2020 · DOI

Introduction

Newcastle Disease Virus (NDV) remains one of the most significant threats to the global poultry industry, causing substantial economic losses. While highly virulent "class II" strains are the primary focus of surveillance, "class I" strains—which are typically lentogenic (mild or asymptomatic)—circulate quietly in wild and domestic waterfowl. Live Bird Markets (LBMs) serve as a natural reservoir for these viruses and play a critical role in their evolution and spread.

Because LBMs house diverse species in close proximity, they provide a unique environment for viruses to jump species and mutate. This study investigates the specific role of LBMs versus commercial farms in the spread and evolution of class I NDV in Eastern China, mapping the prevalence, host distribution, and genetic trajectory of these "silent" viruses as they adapt to domestic poultry.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a comprehensive epidemiological survey between 2017 and 2018, collecting 1,618 samples (including swabs and environmental samples) from LBMs and commercial farms across Eastern China. Standard virology techniques were employed for virus isolation using SPF chicken embryos, followed by identification via hemagglutination (HA) and hemagglutination inhibition (HI) assays.

To understand the evolutionary context, the team performed RT-PCR and Sanger sequencing of the F (fusion) gene, a standard marker for NDV classification. They compared their new isolates against a dataset of 308 historical isolates collected by their laboratory between 2002 and 2016, as well as 241 public sequences from NCBI. This allowed for a comprehensive phylogenetic analysis spanning nearly two decades of viral evolution in the region.

Results and Discussion

The "Mixing Pot" Effect of Live Bird Markets

The study revealed a stark contrast in viral prevalence between commercial farms and LBMs. While commercial chicken farms were largely free of class I NDV, LBMs were identified as significant hotspots. In the 2017–2018 survey, class I NDV was detected in 1.42% of chickens and 0.19% of geese at LBMs.

Interestingly, while the virus was absent in commercial chickens, it was present in commercial waterfowl (up to 3.5% in Muscovy ducks) before they reached the markets. This suggests that ducks act as a bridge, carrying the virus from the wild or commercial breeding environments into the LBMs. Once there, the "traditional feeding mode"—characterized by mixed species in close quarters—facilitates the spillover from waterfowl to terrestrial poultry.

A Major Host Shift Toward Terrestrial Poultry

Historically, class I NDV was primarily considered a "water bird virus." However, the retrospective analysis of data from 2002 to 2018 reveals a dramatic transition. The prevalence of the virus in terrestrial birds (chickens) rose to 82.7%, while it dropped in water birds to just 17.3%. This shift indicates that the virus is successfully adapting to a new ecological niche within the domestic poultry industry, moving beyond its natural reservoir.

Genetic Diversification and the Emergence of Sub-genotype 3d

The study tracked the dominance of specific genetic lineages over time. Since 2010, sub-genotype 3c has become the primary "epidemic" strain in China, outcompeting older lineages like genotype 2. Furthermore, the researchers identified a new sub-genotype, designated as 3d. This classification was based on two specific strains (HQ398796 and HQ398797) that showed a mean evolutionary distance from existing branches (3a, 3b, 3c) ranging from 0.044 to 0.084, meeting the established criteria for a new sub-genotype.

Analysis of the F protein's signal peptide in sub-genotype 3c also showed specific amino acid mutations (S→G, P→L, M→V) occurring over time. These subtle genetic shifts suggest the virus is continuously fine-tuning its ability to infect and replicate within its hosts.

Conclusion

The findings provide clear evidence that the traditional feeding and housing modes in LBMs facilitate the spread and adaptation of class I NDVs. While these strains are currently avirulent, the potential for them to mutate into virulent forms—as seen in historical outbreaks—poses a significant risk to the poultry industry.

To mitigate this threat, the authors emphasize the need for stricter monitoring and a transition away from the "live bird" model. Implementing centralized slaughtering and "all-in-all-out" management systems is essential to break the cycle of viral evolution and protect the regional poultry industry from future epidemics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background: Live bird markets (LBMs) serve as a natural reservoir for class I Newcastle disease virus (NDV) and play an important role in viral evolution and spread. LBMs and commercial farms are the main sources of daily poultry products. However, limited studies are available for the class I NDV circulating at LBMs and commercial farms. In this study, significant progress has been made in sample detection and genetic analysis at LBMs and commercial farms in Eastern China. Methods: A long-term epidemiological investigation at LBMs and commercial farms in Eastern China was conducted. We sequentially conducted the collection of samples, virus isolation, RNA extraction, RT-PCR, and phylogenetic analysis. We also analyzed class I NDVs deposited in NCBI during 2002 – 2018 from China in terms of the host, genotype, time, and functional domains. Results: Here we report that class I NDVs continue to circulate in LBMs. Class I NDVs were detected at a high prevalence in chickens (23/26) but were seldom detected in waterfowl (3/26) at LBMs. In contrast, class I NDVs were rarely detected in commercial chickens but were present in commercial waterfowl at a certain frequency before they were brought to the LBMs. This observation suggests that the mixture of poultry and the conventional housing at LBMs cause the spread of class I NDVs. Sequence analysis of Class I NDV genomes deposited in NCBI during 2002 – 2018 from China revealed a high prevalence of class I NDVs in terrestrial birds (82.7%), which was much higher than in water birds (17.3%). In addition, we found that the class I NDVs predominantly belonged to the sub-genotype 3c and rarely evolved into a new sub-genotype such as the 3d. Furthermore, the epidemic sub-genotype 3c seems to be under ongoing evolution. Conclusions: Our study provides evidence that the traditional feeding mode at LBMs causes the spread of class I NDVs and poses a great risk of NDV epidemics in the poultry industry in Eastern China. The sub-genotype 3c is circulating at LBMs and currently the terrestrial bird is the predominant host of class I NDVs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2020genetic,
  author = {Xiaolong Lu and Xiaoquan Wang and Yifan Sun and Xin Wang and Feng Lin and Yu Chen and Tiansong Zhan and Naiqing Xu and Tianxing Liao and Jiao Hu and Zenglei Hu and Min Gu and Shunlin Hu and Xiaowen Liu and Xiufan Liu and Xiufan Liu and Xiufan Liu},
  title = {{Genetic evolution of class I Newcastle disease virus from poultry at live bird markets in Eastern China}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-41422/v1},
}
Figure