Abstract
Enterovirus D68 (EV-D68) has emerged as a significant global health concern, linked to severe respiratory outbreaks and Acute Flaccid Myelitis (AFM). This study provides a longitudinal analysis of EV-D68 prevalence and genetic evolution among children in Shanghai from 2013 to 2020. Screening 3,997 respiratory samples from hospitalized children revealed a low but persistent prevalence of 0.2%. Genomic sequencing of seven isolates identified multiple circulating clades, including D1, D2, D3, and B3. Significant amino acid mutations were observed in the VP1 capsid loops, alongside evidence of inter-clade recombination. These results suggest that EV-D68 maintains a "quiet" circulation between major outbreaks, accumulating genetic changes that may facilitate future epidemics.
Introduction
Once considered a rare respiratory virus, Enterovirus D68 (EV-D68) gained international prominence following a massive 2014 outbreak in North America. Beyond causing severe respiratory distress, EV-D68 has been strongly associated with Acute Flaccid Myelitis (AFM), a polio-like neurological condition. Despite its clinical importance, the virus's behavior during inter-epidemic periods remains poorly understood. This study addresses the need for long-term molecular surveillance in high-density urban settings like Shanghai to map the virus's "genetic instability" and identify the evolutionary mechanisms—such as point mutations and recombination—that drive its virulence.
Methods
Researchers conducted a retrospective screen of 3,997 respiratory samples (nasopharyngeal swabs and bronchoalveolar lavage fluid) collected from children hospitalized with community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) at the Children’s Hospital of Fudan University between 2013 and 2020.
Key technical steps included:
- Detection: Fluorescence RT-PCR targeting the 5’ non-translated region (5’-NTR) was used to identify enteroviruses.
- Sequencing: Sanger sequencing obtained either complete genomes or partial sequences of the polyprotein gene (3D).
- Phylogenetic Analysis: Strains were mapped using Neighbor-Joining methods to determine clade and subclade classification.
- Recombination Analysis: SimPlot (BootScan analysis) was employed to detect genetic exchange between different viral strains.
- Homology Mapping: Amino acid sequences of the VP1 capsid protein loops (BC, DE, and GH) were compared to identify mutations critical for immune evasion.
Results and Discussion
Low-Level Persistence and Clade Dynamics
The study found a remarkably low positive rate of 0.2% (9/3,997), with the majority of cases (77.8%) occurring in infants under one year old. This "quiet" circulation suggests that the virus can persist in the population without causing large-scale outbreaks, potentially undergoing cumulative mutations in the background.
Phylogenetic analysis revealed a shift in the dominant clades over time. Early isolates from 2013 and 2014 belonged to clades D1 and D2. However, later years saw the emergence of subclades B3 (2014, 2018) and D3 (2019). Subclade B3, in particular, has been globally associated with recent spikes in AFM cases.
Molecular Evolution and Immune Evasion
A key finding was the identification of specific amino acid mutations within the VP1 "loops" (BC and DE). These loops are primary targets for the human immune system; mutations here likely represent the virus's attempt to evade neutralizing antibodies or adapt to different cellular receptors, such as sialic acid.
Furthermore, the study provided evidence for genomic recombination. The Shanghai B3 strains exhibited genetic signatures suggesting exchange with B1 and B2 strains from the 2014 US outbreak. This indicates that EV-D68 evolution is driven not only by gradual genetic drift but also by rapid "shuffling" of genetic material between different lineages.
Conclusion
The seven-year surveillance in Shanghai underscores the genetic diversity and evolutionary potential of EV-D68. While the prevalence remained low, the detection of multiple clades and the identification of significant mutations in the viral capsid suggest a high degree of genetic instability. These findings emphasize the importance of continuous molecular monitoring to anticipate and prepare for future large-scale outbreaks of EV-D68-associated disease.
Limitations
The study's focus on hospitalized pneumonia patients may have missed milder community cases. Additionally, the lack of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) screening prevents a direct link between these specific strains and neurological symptoms like AFM. Future work should incorporate broader outpatient surveillance and functional assays to determine how specific mutations influence viral tropism and pathogenicity.
Summary updated