Genetic and phylogenetic uncoupling of structure and function in human transmodal cortex

Sofie L. Valk, Ting Xu, Casey Paquola, Bo‐yong Park, Richard A. I. Bethlehem, Reinder Vos de Wael, Jessica Royer, Shahrzad Kharabian Masouleh, Şeyma Bayrak, Peter Kochunov, B.t. Thomas Yeo, Daniel S. Margulies, Jonathan Smallw, Simon B. Eickhoff, Boris C. Bernhardt

Abstract: Brain structure scaffolds intrinsic function, supporting cognition and ultimately behavioral flexibility. However, it remains unclear how a static, genetically controlled architecture supports flexible cognition and behavior. Here, we synthesize genetic, phylogenetic and cognitive analyses to understand how the macroscale organization of structure-function coupling across the cortex can inform its role in cognition. In humans, structure-function coupling was highest in regions of unimodal cortex and lowest in transmodal cortex, a pattern that was mirrored by a reduced alignment with heritable connectivity profiles. Structure-function uncoupling in non-human primates had a similar spatial distribution, but we observed an increased coupling between structure and function in association regions in macaques relative to humans. Meta-analysis suggested regions with the least genetic control (low heritable correspondence and different across primates) are linked to social cognition and autobiographical memory. Our findings establish the genetic and evolutionary uncoupling of structure and function in different transmodal systems may support the emergence of complex, culturally embedded forms of cognition.

Introduction

A fundamental mystery in neuroscience is how the brain's relatively static, genetically determined physical structure supports remarkably flexible and abstract human behavior. In primary sensory and motor regions, brain structure typically dictates function: the physical layout of neurons and myelin determines how regions communicate. This "tethering" is highly efficient for basic tasks. However, humans are capable of cognition that isn't tied to immediate sensory input. This study investigates the hypothesis that in "transmodal" regions—areas responsible for abstract thought—the grip of structure over function is loosened, allowing for greater plasticity and learning.

Methodology

The researchers employed a multi-modal approach combining neuroimaging, genetics, and evolutionary biology. Using the Human Connectome Project (HCP) S1200 dataset, they mapped Microstructural Profile Covariance (MPC), which uses T1w/T2w MRI scans to measure cellular similarity between regions, and Resting-state Functional Connectivity (rsFC), which measures functional synchronization. Structure-function coupling was defined as the correlation between these two maps.

To understand the genetic basis of this organization, they performed heritability analysis using SOLAR software on twin data. Evolutionarily, they compared human brain maps with macaque data from the PRIMate-Data Exchange (PRIME-DE). Finally, they used NeuroSynth to perform a meta-analysis of thousands of fMRI studies, mapping cognitive terms onto the identified brain regions.

Figure 1: Overview of microstructural profile covariance (MPC), resting-state functional connectivity (rsFC), and their coupling across the human cortex, including heritability analysis.

Key Insights and Results

The Coupling Gradient

The study revealed a clear spectrum of structure-function coupling across the cortex. Primary sensory areas (vision, touch) are highly "coupled" (r ≈ 0.45), meaning their function is a direct reflection of their physical microstructure. Conversely, transmodal areas, such as the Default Mode Network, are "uncoupled" (r ≈ -0.003), with functional connections appearing largely independent of local anatomy.

Genetic and Evolutionary Untethering

Regions with the lowest structure-function coupling also showed the lowest genetic control. This suggests these areas are less "hard-wired" and more open to being shaped by environment and experience. While macaques show a similar general pattern, humans have significantly more uncoupling in association areas, indicating that "untethering" the brain from physical constraints was a key move in human evolution.

Functional Significance

Cognitive decoding revealed that the most "uncoupled" and human-specific regions are strongly associated with social cognition and autobiographical memory. In contrast, highly "coupled" regions are linked to basic motor and sensory tasks. This suggests that the evolutionary uncoupling of structure and function in transmodal systems supports the emergence of complex, culturally embedded forms of cognition.

Limitations and Future Directions

The study's macroscale resolution (MRI) cannot capture the coupling of individual neurons or synapses. Furthermore, while comparing humans to macaques is informative, including other great apes would provide a clearer picture of when this uncoupling accelerated in the human lineage. Future longitudinal studies are needed to definitively establish if this uncoupling directly causes increased cognitive plasticity in response to learning or cultural environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Brain structure scaffolds intrinsic function, supporting cognition and ultimately behavioral flexibility. However, it remains unclear how a static, genetically controlled architecture supports flexible cognition and behavior. Here, we synthesize genetic, phylogenetic and cognitive analyses to understand how the macroscale organization of structure-function coupling across the cortex can inform its role in cognition. In humans, structure-function coupling was highest in regions of unimodal cortex and lowest in transmodal cortex, a pattern that was mirrored by a reduced alignment with heritable connectivity profiles. Structure-function uncoupling in non-human primates had a similar spatial distribution, but we observed an increased coupling between structure and function in association regions in macaques relative to humans. Meta-analysis suggested regions with the least genetic control (low heritable correspondence and different across primates) are linked to social cognition and autobiographical memory. Our findings establish the genetic and evolutionary uncoupling of structure and function in different transmodal systems may support the emergence of complex, culturally embedded forms of cognition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{valk2022genetic,
  author = {Sofie L. Valk and Ting Xu and Casey Paquola and Bo‐yong Park and Richard A. I. Bethlehem and Reinder Vos de Wael and Jessica Royer and Shahrzad Kharabian Masouleh and Şeyma Bayrak and Peter Kochunov and B.T. Thomas Yeo and Daniel S. Margulies and Jonathan Smallw and Simon B. Eickhoff and Boris C. Bernhardt},
  title = {{Genetic and phylogenetic uncoupling of structure and function in human transmodal cortex}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-022-29886-1},
}
Figure