Generative Principal Component Regression via Variational Inference

Austin Talbot, Corey J. Keller, David E. Carlson, Alex V. KotlararXiv 2024 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces Generative Principal Component Regression (gPCR), a novel method that improves how generative models learn from data, especially when predicting low-variance outcomes. By addressing a key discrepancy in existing supervised variational autoencoders (SVAEs), gPCR leads to more effective target selection for manipulations in complex systems like the brain, outperforming standard methods in both synthetic and real-world neuroscience datasets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many scientific fields, particularly neuroscience, deal with high-dimensional data where understanding underlying structures is crucial. Generative latent variable models, like Probabilistic Principal Component Analysis (PPCA), are excellent for dimensionality reduction and interpretability. However, when trying to design interventions or manipulations based on these models (e.g., to treat psychiatric disorders), a significant challenge arises: these models often struggle to capture subtle, low-variance signals that are critical for predicting specific outcomes. This can lead to suboptimal interventions with minimal efficacy.

Existing approaches like Supervised Variational Autoencoders (SVAEs) try to incorporate outcome-specific information. However, the authors identify a critical flaw: the "supervision loss" in SVAEs can "drag" the model's learned latent space away from what the generative model itself would predict. This creates a discrepancy between the encoder (which learns the latent representation) and the decoder (which reconstructs the data from the latent representation), making manipulations based on the encoder's latent space less effective than expected.

Methods

The core contribution is a new objective function for generative models, specifically designed for linear models like PPCA, which they term Generative Principal Component Regression (gPCR). This method builds upon the framework of Supervised Variational Autoencoders (SVAEs) but crucially modifies the objective.

Instead of using a separate encoder to approximate the posterior distribution of latent variables given the data and outcome ($q(z|x, y)$), gPCR uses the generative posterior ($p(z|x)$) directly. This is achieved by replacing the encoder's learned distribution with the generative model's own posterior distribution. This approach aims to:

  1. Infer a linear predictive model: This model emphasizes sparsity in dimensionality (i.e., which latent factors are important) rather than sparsity in covariates.
  2. Infer a factor model relevant to an outcome: It ensures the learned latent factors are informative about the outcome of interest.
  3. Eliminate the encoder-decoder discrepancy: By forcing the latent representation to be consistent with the generative model, it improves the reliability of using these latent variables for experimental design and manipulation target selection.

The authors derive this objective as a variational lower bound, which can be optimized using gradient descent. They note that batch training with momentum outperformed stochastic methods and modern optimizers like Adam in their experiments.

Datasets

The paper evaluates gPCR on two neuroscience datasets:

  1. Tail Suspension Test (TST) Dataset: This dataset contains electrophysiological recordings from mice undergoing a stress paradigm. The goal was to characterize electrophysiology related to stress and potentially identify targets for interventions. The data was preprocessed into 616 spectral power covariates.
  2. Social Interaction Dataset: This dataset includes electrophysiology from mice during social interaction tasks. The objective was to identify brain activity relevant to social behavior. This dataset was preprocessed into 448 spectral power covariates.

The authors also created a synthetic dataset to specifically demonstrate and isolate the encoder-decoder discrepancy issue in SVAEs and to showcase gPCR's advantages in target selection.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Encoder-Decoder Discrepancy is Real and Problematic: The paper provides strong empirical evidence that the learned latent representations from an SVAE's encoder can be significantly different from what the generative model's posterior would suggest, leading to reduced predictive performance when using the generative posterior.
  • Generative Models Can Be Made Predictive: By carefully designing the objective function, generative models can be made to effectively incorporate predictive information without sacrificing their interpretability or generative capabilities.
  • Latent Space Matters for Manipulation: The effectiveness of interventions designed from latent variable models hinges on the accurate representation of relevant information in the latent space. gPCR directly addresses this by ensuring the latent space is both generative and predictive.
  • Low-Variance Signals are Key: The paper highlights that standard methods often miss low-variance signals crucial for predicting specific outcomes. gPCR's formulation is designed to better capture these subtle but important dynamics.

Key Results

  • Synthetic Data: gPCR dramatically improved target selection efficacy compared to standard Principal Component Regression (PCR) and SVAEs. The average stimulation shift for gPCR was 0.89, compared to 0.18 for PCR and 0.41 for SVAE.
  • TST Dataset (Imputation): In imputing missing brain region activity, gPCR performed comparably to linear regression and significantly outperformed PCR, PLS, and CCA.
  • TST Dataset (Prediction - Stress vs. Non-stress): gPCR achieved an AUC of 0.91±0.003, closely matching regression-based methods (AUC ~0.94) and significantly outperforming PCR (AUC 0.82).
  • Social Interaction Dataset (Prediction): gPCR achieved an AUC of 0.57±0.005, matching L2 and Elastic Net regression and outperforming L1 regression, demonstrating its ability to find weak predictive signals.
  • SVAE Deficiencies: Across both neuroscience datasets, SVAEs showed a significant discrepancy between their encoder and posterior, leading to reduced predictive ability when using the posterior mean for prediction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Linear Model Assumption: The current gPCR formulation relies on analytic forms for $p(z|x)$ and $D_{KL}(p(z|x,y)||p(z))$, which currently restricts it to linear models.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest relaxing the analytic requirement to extend gPCR to broader classes of latent variable models. They also propose further investigation into why SVAEs struggle to incorporate phenotypically relevant information into their generative parameters. Finally, they aim to demonstrate experimentally that stimulation based on gPCR outperforms competitor methods in real-world applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

The ability to manipulate complex systems, such as the brain, to modify specific outcomes has far-reaching implications, particularly in the treatment of psychiatric disorders. One approach to designing appropriate manipulations is to target key features of predictive models. While generative latent variable models, such as probabilistic principal component analysis (PPCA), is a powerful tool for identifying targets, they struggle incorporating information relevant to low-variance outcomes into the latent space. When stimulation targets are designed on the latent space in such a scenario, the intervention can be suboptimal with minimal efficacy. To address this problem, we develop a novel objective based on supervised variational autoencoders (SVAEs) that enforces such information is represented in the latent space. The novel objective can be used with linear models, such as PPCA, which we refer to as generative principal component regression (gPCR). We show in simulations that gPCR dramatically improves target selection in manipulation as compared to standard PCR and SVAEs. As part of these simulations, we develop a metric for detecting when relevant information is not properly incorporated into the loadings. We then show in two neural datasets related to stress and social behavior in which gPCR dramatically outperforms PCR in predictive performance and that SVAEs exhibit low incorporation of relevant information into the loadings. Overall, this work suggests that our method significantly improves target selection for manipulation using latent variable models over competitor inference schemes.
BibTeX
@misc{talbot2024generative,
  author = {Austin Talbot and Corey J. Keller and David E. Carlson and Alex V. Kotlar},
  title = {{Generative Principal Component Regression via Variational Inference}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2409.02327},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.02327},
}
Figure