Gaussian optimizers for entropic inequalities in quantum information

Giacomo De Palma, Dario Trevisan, Vittorio Giovannetti, Luigi Ambrosio

Abstract

We survey the state of the art for the proof of the quantum Gaussian optimizer conjectures of quantum information theory. These fundamental conjectures state that quantum Gaussian input states are the solution to several optimization problems involving quantum Gaussian channels. These problems are the quantum counterpart of three fundamental results of functional analysis and probability: the Entropy Power Inequality, the sharp Young's inequality for convolutions, and the theorem "Gaussian kernels have only Gaussian maximizers." Quantum Gaussian channels play a key role in quantum communication theory: they are the quantum counterpart of Gaussian integral kernels and provide the mathematical model for the propagation of electromagnetic waves in the quantum regime. The quantum Gaussian optimizer conjectures are needed to determine the maximum communication rates over optical fibers and free space. The restriction of the quantum-limited Gaussian attenuator to input states diagonal in the Fock basis coincides with the thinning, which is the analog of the rescaling for positive integer random variables. Quantum Gaussian channels provide then a bridge between functional analysis and discrete probability.

Introduction

In classical information theory, Gaussian distributions are uniquely significant: they maximize entropy for a given variance and serve as optimal optimizers for numerous functional inequalities. In the quantum domain, particularly when modeling electromagnetic signals in optical fibers, we utilize Quantum Gaussian Channels.

The central question in this field is whether Gaussian input states remain the "best" (the optimizers) for these quantum channels. For decades, researchers have conjectured that Gaussian inputs minimize output entropy and maximize communication rates. Proving these conjectures is essential for determining the ultimate physical limits of quantum communication. However, many of these seemingly intuitive results have remained unproven, particularly when extending from single-mode to multi-mode systems.

Mathematical Methods

Proving these conjectures requires a sophisticated mathematical arsenal spanning functional analysis, majorization theory, and quantum mechanics:

  • Majorization Theory: This framework allows for the comparison of "disorder" between quantum states. Proving that one state majorizes another is a key step in demonstrating entropy minimization.
  • Logarithmic Sobolev Inequalities: These provide "infinitesimal" versions of the conjectures, which can be integrated to establish global results.
  • Heat Semigroup Techniques: Borrowed from classical physics, these techniques involve analyzing how the entropy of states evolves as they are "blurred" over time, a method instrumental in proving the Quantum Entropy Power Inequality.
  • Stinespring Dilation: This standard quantum tool represents a noisy channel as a clean unitary interaction with an environment, facilitating the tracking of information leakage.

Key Results and Theoretical Framework

The landscape of these conjectures and their proven counterparts is complex, involving a web of logical implications between various fundamental inequalities.

Logical relationships between conjectures (red/yellow) and proven theorems (green) in quantum Gaussian information theory.

Several significant milestones have been reached in recent years:

  • Minimum Output Entropy (Proven): It is now established (Theorem IV.1) that the vacuum state minimizes the output entropy for $n$-mode Gaussian attenuators and amplifiers.
  • One-Mode Constrained Entropy: For a single mode, it has been proven that Gaussian states minimize output entropy even under fixed input entropy constraints.
  • Multiplicativity of Norms: Research indicates that the $p \to q$ norms of these channels are achieved by Gaussian inputs in specific cases (e.g., $p=q$), reinforcing the "Gaussian maximizer" hypothesis.
  • The Quantum-Classical Bridge: A notable discovery is the connection between quantum attenuators and the classical concept of "thinning" (the discrete version of rescaling a random variable). This allows quantum mechanical proofs to solve open problems in classical discrete mathematics, such as identifying geometric probability distributions as optimizers for thinning operations.

Discussion and Open Challenges

The primary obstacle remains the multi-mode case. Many sophisticated proofs for single-mode channels rely on passive state rearrangements that do not generalize to multiple modes.

Current open challenges include:

  1. The Constrained Minimum Output Entropy Conjecture: This remains unproven for multi-mode channels.
  2. The Entropy Photon-number Inequality (EPnI): While the "Power" version is proven (Theorem VII.1), the "Photon-number" version remains a significant open challenge.
  3. New Mathematical Tools: Overcoming the "multi-mode barrier" may require novel approaches, potentially drawing from the theory of Optimal Transport, to finally establish the fundamental limits of quantum information transmission.

Summary updated

Abstract

We survey the state of the art for the proof of the quantum Gaussian optimizer conjectures of quantum information theory. These fundamental conjectures state that quantum Gaussian input states are the solution to several optimization problems involving quantum Gaussian channels. These problems are the quantum counterpart of three fundamental results of functional analysis and probability: the Entropy Power Inequality, the sharp Young's inequality for convolutions, and the theorem "Gaussian kernels have only Gaussian maximizers." Quantum Gaussian channels play a key role in quantum communication theory: they are the quantum counterpart of Gaussian integral kernels and provide the mathematical model for the propagation of electromagnetic waves in the quantum regime. The quantum Gaussian optimizer conjectures are needed to determine the maximum communication rates over optical fibers and free space. The restriction of the quantum-limited Gaussian attenuator to input states diagonal in the Fock basis coincides with the thinning, which is the analog of the rescaling for positive integer random variables. Quantum Gaussian channels provide then a bridge between functional analysis and discrete probability.
BibTeX
@article{palma2018gaussian,
  author = {Giacomo De Palma and Dario Trevisan and Vittorio Giovannetti and Luigi Ambrosio},
  title = {{Gaussian optimizers for entropic inequalities in quantum information}},
  journal = {Journal of Mathematical Physics},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1063/1.5038665},
}

Loading related content...

Figure