Gauge Enhanced Quantum Criticality and Time Reversal Domain Wall: SU(2) Yang-Mills Dynamics with Topological Terms

Yunqin Zheng, Yi‐Zhuang You, Juven WangBulletin 2020

TL;DR

This paper explores the complex low-energy behavior of SU(2) Yang-Mills theory at a specific theta angle ($\theta = \pi$), revealing a rich landscape of possible quantum phases. By considering different "siblings" of the theory enriched by Lorentz and time-reversal symmetries, the authors uncover scenarios ranging from spontaneous time-reversal symmetry breaking to deconfined U(1) gauge theories, and even propose a novel "gauge enhanced quantum critical point" where the gauge group temporarily becomes non-Abelian.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The dynamics of SU(N) Yang-Mills theory in 3+1 dimensions are notoriously difficult to study due to its strongly coupled nature at low energies. While the behavior at $\theta=0$ is generally believed to be confining with a mass gap, the case at $\theta=\pi$ is more enigmatic. This specific theta angle is time-reversal symmetric, but it's known to possess a mixed anomaly between time-reversal and the center symmetry. This anomaly implies that the theory cannot simply flow to a trivial gapped phase. The authors aim to systematically explore the possible low-energy outcomes for SU(2) Yang-Mills at $\theta=\pi$, considering how different symmetry enrichments (specifically, Lorentz and time-reversal symmetries) influence these outcomes. They investigate two main scenarios: spontaneous breaking of time-reversal symmetry, leading to domain walls between different vacua, and the emergence of deconfined, gapless U(1) gauge theories.

Methods

The paper employs a combination of theoretical tools from quantum field theory and topological field theory. Key methods include:

  • 't Hooft Anomaly Matching: This is a central tool used to constrain the possible low-energy theories. Anomalies in the bulk theory must be saturated by the low-energy degrees of freedom, providing powerful restrictions on the nature of the quantum phases.
  • Domain Wall Theories: When time-reversal symmetry is spontaneously broken, domain walls can form between the different time-reversal partner vacua. The authors analyze the properties and anomalies of these 3D domain wall theories.
  • Symmetry Enrichment: The paper systematically considers how the SO(3,1) Lorentz symmetry and time-reversal symmetry can enrich the SU(2) Yang-Mills theory. This is done by "fractionalizing" these symmetries on Wilson line operators, leading to the concept of "Four Siblings" of the theory, each characterized by a pair of integers $(K_1, K_2)$.
  • Chern-Simons Theory: The low-energy theories, particularly on the domain walls and in the deconfined U(1) phases, are often described by Chern-Simons theories. The authors identify the specific levels and types of these Chern-Simons theories.
  • RG Flow and Higgsing: In the context of SU(2) QCD with fermions, the authors utilize Renormalization Group (RG) flow to understand how the theory evolves to its low-energy state. They propose a mechanism where the SU(2) gauge group can be "Higgsed" down to a U(1) gauge group, leading to U(1) spin liquid phases.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Four Siblings" of SU(2) Yang-Mills: The interplay between Lorentz symmetry and time-reversal symmetry leads to four distinct ways to enrich the SU(2) Yang-Mills theory at $\theta=\pi$. These "siblings" have different properties, particularly on domain walls, even though the bulk 't Hooft anomaly is independent of the Lorentz enrichment.
  • Domain Wall Anomalies: The anomaly in the 4d theory induces a non-trivial anomaly on the 3d domain wall. This anomaly necessitates the presence of gapless degrees of freedom on the wall, which are identified as Chern-Simons theories.
  • Deconfined U(1) Phases: The authors show that SU(2) Yang-Mills at $\theta=\pi$ can potentially flow to deconfined U(1) gauge theories, which can be interpreted as quantum spin liquids. This is a significant departure from the standard lore of confining SU(N) theories.
  • Gauge Enhanced Quantum Critical Points (GEQCP): A particularly exciting proposal is the existence of GEQCPs. Here, the system can transition between different U(1) spin liquids or between a spin liquid and a trivial vacuum, with the SU(2) gauge group temporarily "enhancing" at the critical point. This suggests a novel mechanism for phase transitions.
  • Connection between QCD and Spin Liquids: The paper establishes a link between SU(2) QCD with a large number of fermions and the deconfined U(1) spin liquid phases. By tuning the fermion mass, the theory can flow to a state where the SU(2) gauge group is Higgsed down to U(1), realizing these spin liquid phases.

Key Results

  • The paper systematically analyzes the domain wall theories for the four siblings of SU(2) Yang-Mills at $\theta=\pi$, identifying them as specific Chern-Simons theories (SU(2)$_1$ or SU(2)$_{-1}$).
  • It demonstrates that the theory can flow to deconfined U(1) gauge theories, which are characterized by specific 't Hooft anomalies and can be identified with various U(1) quantum spin liquids.
  • The authors propose the existence of "Gauge Enhanced Quantum Critical Points" where the gauge group temporarily becomes SU(2) during a transition between U(1) spin liquids or between a spin liquid and a trivial phase.
  • They provide a mechanism for realizing these GEQCPs through the Higgsing of SU(2) QCD with many fermions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small N vs. Large N: While the "Standard Lore" for large N SU(N) Yang-Mills is well-established, the paper focuses on the less understood case of small N (specifically SU(2)). The authors acknowledge that for small N, multiple scenarios are possible and not all have been definitively excluded.
  • Experimental Realization: The proposed GEQCPs are theoretical constructs. Future work would involve exploring whether these phenomena can be observed in condensed matter systems or other physical realizations.
  • Completeness of Scenarios: The paper explores two main scenarios (spontaneous time-reversal breaking and deconfined U(1) phases). Other possibilities, such as gapped deconfined phases or gapless CFTs preserving time-reversal symmetry, are mentioned but not explored in full detail.
  • Understanding Sign Correlations: The paper notes that the sign correlation between the fermion mass and the interaction strength $u$ in the QCD4 action, which dictates whether Higgsing occurs, still requires a deeper understanding.
  • Mapping to Specific Spin Liquids: While the anomalies provide constraints, fully determining which specific U(1) spin liquid is realized for each sibling requires further physical considerations beyond just anomaly matching.

The authors suggest that further investigation into the GEQCPs and their connection to deconfined quantum critical points in other systems would be fruitful.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zheng2020gauge,
  author = {Yunqin Zheng and Yi‐Zhuang You and Juven Wang},
  title = {{Gauge Enhanced Quantum Criticality and Time Reversal Domain Wall: SU(2) Yang-Mills Dynamics with Topological Terms}},
  journal = {Bulletin},
  year = {2020},
}
Figure