Gamete simulation improves polygenic transmission disequilibrium analysis

Jiawen Chen, Jing You, Zijie Zhao, Zheng Ni, Kunling Huang, Yuchang Wu, Jason M. Fletcher, Qiongshi LubioRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Polygenic risk scores (PRS) derived from summary statistics of genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have enjoyed great popularity in human genetics research. Applied to population cohorts, PRS can effectively stratify individuals by risk group and has promising applications in early diagnosis and clinical intervention. However, our understanding of within-family polygenic risk is incomplete, in part because the small samples per family significantly limits power. Here, to address this challenge, we introduce ORIGAMI, a computational framework that uses parental genotype data to simulate offspring genomes. ORIGAMI uses state-of-the-art genetic maps to simulate realistic recombination events on phased parental genomes and allows quantifying the prospective PRS variability within each family. We quantify and showcase the substantially reduced yet highly heterogeneous PRS variation within families for numerous complex traits. Further, we incorporate within-family PRS variability to improve polygenic transmission disequilibrium test (pTDT). Through simulations, we demonstrate that modeling within-family risk substantially improves the statistical power of pTDT. Applied to 7,805 trios of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) probands and healthy parents, we successfully replicated previously reported over-transmission of ASD, educational attainment, and schizophrenia risk, and identified multiple novel traits with significant transmission disequilibrium. These results provided novel etiologic insights into the shared genetic basis of various complex traits and ASD.

Introduction

Polygenic Risk Scores (PRS) are essential for predicting susceptibility to complex diseases by aggregating the effects of thousands of genetic variants. While effective for population-level stratification, analyzing risk within families remains a significant challenge. The gold standard for family studies, the polygenic transmission disequilibrium test (pTDT), evaluates whether parents pass more risk alleles to an affected child than expected by chance.

However, standard pTDT assumes a uniform potential for genetic variance across all families. In reality, parental heterozygosity and recombination rates vary significantly, and because most families have few children, this variance cannot be measured directly. This limitation often leads to reduced statistical power and potential false negatives in genetic research.

Methods

To address these limitations, the researchers developed ORIGAMI (Offspring Risk Inference through GAMete sImulation). This framework creates a personalized null distribution for every family by simulating thousands of "pseudo-offspring" from parental genotypes.

The ORIGAMI workflow for simulating offspring genotypes.

The process involves four key steps:

  1. Extraction: Phased parental genotype data is extracted from VCF/BCF files.
  2. Simulation: Realistic recombination events are simulated using sex-specific genetic maps and a chi-square chiasma interference model.
  3. Recombination: Parental chromosomes are recombined based on these simulated crossover points.
  4. Construction: Simulated gametes are randomly selected and combined to construct the genomes of pseudo-offspring.

By generating hundreds of these simulated children per couple, ORIGAMI calculates the empirical standard deviation of PRS for that specific family, which is then used to refine the pTDT statistic.

Key Insights and Results

Within-Family Heterogeneity

A central finding of the study is that genetic risk variability is highly inconsistent across families. The within-family PRS standard deviation was found to range from 13.3% to 208.8% of the population-level standard deviation. Furthermore, traits controlled by fewer genetic variants (e.g., Alzheimer’s) showed more extreme variance fluctuations between families compared to highly polygenic traits like height.

Performance and Power

Simulations demonstrated that the ORIGAMI-informed pTDT substantially improves statistical power over standard methods. Crucially, this boost in sensitivity does not come at the cost of an inflated type-I error (false discovery) rate.

Comparison of Type-I error and statistical power between standard pTDT and ORIGAMI.

Application to ASD

Applying ORIGAMI to 7,805 ASD trios from the AGP, SSC, and SPARK cohorts, the team replicated known over-transmissions for ASD, Schizophrenia, and Educational Attainment. More importantly, the improved power led to the discovery of six novel traits significantly associated with ASD risk, including Cognitive Performance ($p = 7.94 \times 10^{-21}$), Height ($p = 4.10 \times 10^{-4}$), and Bipolar Disorder ($p = 1.27 \times 10^{-3}$).

Discussion and Future Work

ORIGAMI represents a significant advancement in family-based genetic analysis by replacing "one-size-fits-all" assumptions with family-specific simulations. This approach is less susceptible to population stratification and "genetic nurture" effects.

Future iterations of the tool aim to address current limitations, such as the exclusion of sex chromosomes, restriction to SNPs (excluding structural variants), and the dependency on high-quality genomic phasing. Expanding the framework to handle these complexities will further enhance its utility in clinical and research settings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Polygenic risk scores (PRS) derived from summary statistics of genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have enjoyed great popularity in human genetics research. Applied to population cohorts, PRS can effectively stratify individuals by risk group and has promising applications in early diagnosis and clinical intervention. However, our understanding of within-family polygenic risk is incomplete, in part because the small samples per family significantly limits power. Here, to address this challenge, we introduce ORIGAMI, a computational framework that uses parental genotype data to simulate offspring genomes. ORIGAMI uses state-of-the-art genetic maps to simulate realistic recombination events on phased parental genomes and allows quantifying the prospective PRS variability within each family. We quantify and showcase the substantially reduced yet highly heterogeneous PRS variation within families for numerous complex traits. Further, we incorporate within-family PRS variability to improve polygenic transmission disequilibrium test (pTDT). Through simulations, we demonstrate that modeling within-family risk substantially improves the statistical power of pTDT. Applied to 7,805 trios of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) probands and healthy parents, we successfully replicated previously reported over-transmission of ASD, educational attainment, and schizophrenia risk, and identified multiple novel traits with significant transmission disequilibrium. These results provided novel etiologic insights into the shared genetic basis of various complex traits and ASD.
BibTeX
@misc{chen2020gamete,
  author = {Jiawen Chen and Jing You and Zijie Zhao and Zheng Ni and Kunling Huang and Yuchang Wu and Jason M. Fletcher and Qiongshi Lu},
  title = {{Gamete simulation improves polygenic transmission disequilibrium analysis}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.10.26.355602},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure