Simultaneous selection of multiple important single nucleotide polymorphisms in familial genome wide association studies data

Subhabrata Majumdar, Saonli Basu, Matt McGue, Snigdhansu ChatterjeeScientific 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Identifying relevant genetic variants in family-based studies is often hindered by computational complexity and the presence of shared environmental factors. Traditional single-marker association analyses frequently miss weak genetic signals that contribute to complex traits. We present a resampling-based fast variable selection technique for detecting relevant single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in multi-marker mixed-effect models. By utilizing an e-values framework and a scalable generalized bootstrap procedure, our method effectively identifies multiple SNPs simultaneously while accounting for familial dependency. Numerical studies and analysis of the Minnesota Center for Twin and Family Research (MCTFR) dataset demonstrate that this approach outperforms traditional single-marker and model selection methods in detecting SNPs associated with traits like alcohol consumption.

Introduction

Genome-Wide Association Studies (GWAS) are essential for linking genetic variations to specific diseases or behaviors. However, the standard practice of "single-SNP analysis"—testing one variant at a time—often fails to capture the subtle, joint contributions of multiple genetic variants. This limitation is particularly pronounced in family studies (involving twins or siblings), where shared genes and environments create complex dependencies in the data.

While joint modeling of genetic variants within a gene or pathway offers higher power to detect weak effects, the computational cost of traditional model selection in family data is often prohibitive. This paper introduces a computationally efficient approach based on the e-values framework to overcome these bottlenecks, allowing for the simultaneous detection of relevant SNPs in familial datasets.

Methodology

The Statistical Model and E-Values

Our approach utilizes a Linear Mixed Model (LMM), specifically the ACE model, which partitions phenotypic variance into additive genetic effects (A), common shared environment (C), and unique environmental error (E). To perform variable selection within this framework, we employ e-values rather than traditional p-values.

E-values quantify the "relevance" of a variable by measuring how much the model's predictive power changes when a specific SNP is excluded. Unlike p-values, which rely on rigid distributional assumptions and null hypothesis testing, e-values provide an "assumption-lean" metric that is more robust for complex biological data.

Computational Efficiency via Generalized Bootstrap (GBS)

To address the computational intensity of refitting complex models, we implement a Generalized Bootstrap (GBS) procedure. Instead of the traditional bottleneck of refitting the model thousands of times, GBS fits the model once and uses Monte-Carlo sampling to weight the results. This makes the selection process highly parallelizable and scalable to large datasets.

Quantile Selection Logic

A critical innovation in our method is the use of quantile e-values. We observed that for weak genetic signals, the average of the bootstrap distribution can often wash out the signal. By focusing on the tails of the distribution (e.g., the 90th percentile), we can more effectively separate true genetic signals from random noise.

Distribution of e-values (E1) for non-zero (blue) and zero (red) indices across varying signal strengths (s). As signal strength increases, the separation between true signals and noise becomes more distinct, particularly in the distribution tails.

Results and Validation

Simulation Studies

In synthetic environments with 250 families and 50 SNPs, our e-value method consistently outperformed standard methods such as mBIC2 and RFGLS+BH. Notably, at low heritability levels—where traditional methods often failed to detect any signal—our approach maintained a respectable detection rate, demonstrating its sensitivity to weak genetic effects.

Real-World Application: MCTFR Dataset

We applied the method to the Minnesota Center for Twin and Family Research (MCTFR) dataset, comprising 7,605 individuals across 2,151 nuclear families. Focusing on alcohol consumption phenotypes, our method identified significantly more SNPs in established "alcohol genes" (such as GABRA2, ADH, and ALDH2) than competing approaches. Many of the detected SNPs were located in or near exons, suggesting high biological and functional relevance.

Conclusion

Our proposed resampling-based variable selection method provides a powerful and efficient alternative to single-SNP analysis in family-based GWAS. By leveraging e-values and the generalized bootstrap, researchers can now identify multiple relevant SNPs simultaneously without the prohibitive computational costs of traditional joint modeling. Future work will focus on scaling this method to genome-wide levels through initial screening steps and extending the framework to handle more complex pedigree structures.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose a resampling-based fast variable selection technique for detecting relevant single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP) in a multi-marker mixed effect model. Due to computational complexity, current practice primarily involves testing the effect of one SNP at a time, commonly termed as 'single SNP association analysis'. Joint modeling of genetic variants within a gene or pathway may have better power to detect associated genetic variants, especially the ones with weak effects. In this paper, we propose a computationally efficient model selection approach-based on the e-values framework-for single SNP detection in families while utilizing information on multiple SNPs simultaneously. To overcome computational bottleneck of traditional model selection methods, our method trains one single model, and utilizes a fast and scalable bootstrap procedure. We illustrate through numerical studies that our proposed method is more effective in detecting SNPs associated with a trait than either single-marker analysis using family data or model selection methods that ignore the familial dependency structure. Further, we perform gene-level analysis in Minnesota Center for Twin and Family Research (MCTFR) dataset using our method to detect several SNPs using this that have been implicated to be associated with alcohol consumption.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{majumdar2023simultaneous,
  author = {Subhabrata Majumdar and Saonli Basu and Matt McGue and Snigdhansu Chatterjee},
  title = {{Simultaneous selection of multiple important single nucleotide polymorphisms in familial genome wide association studies data}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-023-35379-y},
}
Figure