Abstract
The evolution of limb morphology plays an important role in animal adaptation to different ecological niches. To fully adapt to aquatic life, cetaceans underwent hindlimb degeneration and forelimb transformed into flipper; however, the molecular mechanisms underlying the limb changes in cetaceans remain unclear. We previous study had shown that the Tbx4 hindlimb enhancer A (Tbx4-HLEA) in cetaceans exhibited specific deletions and nucleotide substitutions, with significantly reduced regulatory activity. To further investigate whether cetacean HLEA has a potential impact on hindlimb development in vivo, a knock-in mouse model was generated by knocking in the homologous cetacean HLEA in the present study. Phenotypic analysis showed a significant reduction in hindlimb bud development in homozygous knock-in mice at embryonic day (E)10.5; however, the phenotypic difference was rescued after E11.5. Transcriptomic and epigenetic analyses indicated that the cetacean HLEA acts as an enhancer in the mouse embryos and significantly reduces the transcriptional expression levels of Tbx4 at E10.5, supporting that downregulation of cetaceans HLEA regulatory activity reduces the expression of Tbx4. Additionally, both the number of activated non-coding elements and chromatin accessibility near Tbx4 were increased in homozygous knock-in mice at E11.5. The functional redundancy of enhancers compensated for the functional defect of cetacean HLEA, rescuing the expression level of Tbx4, and may account for the phenotype restoration after E11.5. In conclusion, our study suggested that the evolution of cetacean HLEA may be an important link with relevant molecular mechanism for the hindlimb degeneration.
Introduction
Around 50 million years ago, the ancestors of modern cetaceans (whales and dolphins) transitioned from terrestrial to aquatic environments. This shift required profound morphological adaptations, most notably the transformation of forelimbs into flippers and the complete degeneration of hindlimbs to achieve a hydrodynamic body shape. While the fossil record provides a clear timeline for these physical changes, the underlying genetic drivers have remained largely theoretical.
Previous in vitro research identified a specific non-coding DNA region—the Tbx4 hindlimb enhancer A (HLEA)—that shows significant sequence divergence in cetaceans, including specific deletions and reduced regulatory activity. However, whether these mutations are sufficient to drive hindlimb loss in vivo was unknown. This study addresses this gap by utilizing a CRISPR-Cas9 knock-in mouse model to test the functional impact of the cetacean HLEA sequence within a living mammalian developmental context.
Methods and Materials
The researchers employed an "evo-devo" (evolutionary developmental biology) framework to test the functionality of the cetacean enhancer.
CRISPR/Cas9 Knock-in Strategy
A mouse model was engineered where the endogenous 1.1 kb mouse HLEA sequence was replaced with the homologous HLEA sequence from the bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus). This allowed for the direct observation of how cetacean-specific mutations affect limb development in a land-mammal background.
Phenotypic and Omics Analysis
- Morphological Phenotyping: Hindlimb bud areas were measured from Embryonic Day (E)10.5 to E12.5. Skeletal preparations were analyzed at postnatal day 1 (P1) to assess bone length and digit formation.
- Transcriptomics (RNA-seq): RNA was extracted from hindlimb buds at E10.5 and E11.5 to identify differentially expressed genes (DEGs), focusing on the Tbx4 pathway.
- Epigenomic Profiling (CUT&Tag): To assess enhancer activity and chromatin accessibility, the team performed CUT&Tag assays for H3K27ac and H3K4me1, which are markers of active regulatory elements. These results were compared against public ENCODE datasets.
Results
Early Developmental Delay and Gene Dysregulation
At the critical early stage of limb formation (E10.5), homozygous knock-in mice (HKM) exhibited significantly smaller hindlimb buds compared to wild-type (WT) controls. For instance, the mean area of the right hindlimb bud was 1.45 mm² in HKM versus 1.67 mm² in WT (p = 0.0026).
This morphological reduction correlated with massive transcriptomic changes. RNA-seq at E10.5 identified 1,214 DEGs. Most importantly, Tbx4—the primary target of the HLEA enhancer—was severely downregulated (log2FC = -1.7). Other essential limb-patterning genes, such as Hand2 and Fgf8, also showed significantly reduced expression, confirming that the cetacean HLEA mutations actively suppress the early limb development program.
Spontaneous Phenotypic Rescue via Enhancer Redundancy
Surprisingly, the initial developmental delay did not persist. By E11.5 and E12.5, the size difference between WT and HKM hindlimb buds disappeared. At birth (P1), the knock-in mice possessed normal skeletal structures, including full-length bones and all digits.
Epigenetic analysis provided the explanation for this "rescue." At E11.5, CUT&Tag data revealed a significant increase in H3K27ac signals and the activation of additional non-coding elements near the Tbx4 gene in the knock-in mice. This compensatory activity by redundant enhancers effectively restored Tbx4 expression levels, reducing the number of DEGs from 1,214 at E10.5 to just 53 at E11.5.
Discussion
This study provides the first in vivo evidence that the evolutionary decay of the Tbx4-HLEA enhancer contributed to the hindlimb degeneration seen in cetaceans. The results demonstrate that sequence divergence in a single regulatory element can significantly impair early limb bud initiation.
However, the observed phenotypic rescue in the mouse model highlights a critical concept in evolutionary biology: enhancer redundancy. In land-dwelling mammals like mice, the genome maintains "shadow enhancers" or redundant regulatory elements that act as fail-safes. The fact that the mouse could compensate for the defective cetacean HLEA suggests that the complete loss of hindlimbs in whales likely required a two-step process: first, the decay of primary enhancers like HLEA, followed by the evolutionary degradation of these redundant backup elements.
Limitations and Future Directions
While the mouse model is a powerful tool, it does not perfectly replicate the cetacean genomic environment, where these redundant enhancers may have already been lost or modified. Future research should focus on identifying these compensatory elements and investigating their evolutionary status across different cetacean lineages. Mapping the "passive decay" of the entire Tbx4 regulatory landscape will be essential to fully understanding the molecular history of aquatic adaptation.
Summary updated