Fully Persistent Spatial Data Structures for Efficient Queries in Path-Dependent Motion Planning Applications

Sathwik Karnik, Tomás Lozano-Pérez, Leslie Pack Kaelbling, Gustavo Nunes Goretkin

Introduction

In classical robotic motion planning, the environment is often treated as a Markovian system where the feasibility of a future state depends solely on the current configuration. However, many sophisticated planning tasks—such as visibility-aware navigation, minimum constraint removal, and belief-space planning—are inherently path-dependent. In these scenarios, the validity of a robot's next move is contingent upon the history of its trajectory (e.g., "Has the robot already sensed this region?" or "What obstacles have been cleared?").

The computational bottleneck in path-dependent planning is the "lookback" operation. To validate a new state, the planner must traverse the entire history of the path, leading to a computational complexity that scales linearly ($O(L)$) with the path length $L$. As plans grow in complexity and duration, this linear overhead becomes a significant barrier to real-time performance.

Methodology: Fully Persistent Spatial Data Structures

To address this scaling issue, researchers from MIT have introduced Fully Persistent Spatial Data Structures (FPSDS). In the context of computer science, a "persistent" data structure is one that preserves previous versions of itself when modified. A "fully persistent" structure allows for both access and modification of any version, making it ideal for the branching search trees common in motion planning.

The Fully Persistent Nearest-Neighbor Tree (FPNNT)

The core of this approach is the Fully Persistent Nearest-Neighbor Tree (FPNNT). This structure optimizes the lookback process by replacing linear scans with efficient geometric queries.

  1. Static-to-Dynamic Transformation: The FPNNT utilizes a technique that organizes geometric points into a forest of static trees (such as kd-trees). This allows the structure to handle dynamic insertions while maintaining the query efficiency of static structures.
  2. Logarithmic Query Efficiency: Rather than checking every point in a path, the FPNNT enables range queries that quickly filter out irrelevant historical configurations. This shifts the query complexity from linear to sub-linear.
  3. Geometric Versioning: Each node in the motion planner’s search tree is associated with a specific version of the FPNNT. When the planner explores a new branch, the FPNNT "evolves" to include new geometric data without the need to duplicate the entire history, significantly saving on computational overhead.

Experimental Evaluation

The proposed method was evaluated across three simulated 2D environments designed to test varying degrees of visibility constraints:

  • ONEHALLWAY: A baseline environment for initial testing.
  • HORSESHOEHALLWAY: A U-shaped corridor that necessitates long-range memory and historical lookbacks.
  • GLASSHALLWAY: A complex environment where the robot must "clear" areas by looking through glass walls before it can safely enter them, creating high path-dependency.

These benchmarks were used to measure how the algorithm scales as the domain length and path duration increase.

Key Insights and Results

The integration of persistence into geometric planning yields several critical insights:

  • Performance Gains: In the most demanding "Glass Hallway" scenarios, the FPNNT method achieved a 2x speedup compared to the brute-force linear lookback baseline.
  • Asymptotic Scaling: While the baseline's computation time exploded linearly as path lengths grew, the FPNNT maintained a relatively flat performance profile, demonstrating superior scalability for long-horizon tasks.
  • Memory-Performance Trade-off: The primary cost of persistence is memory. The FPNNT requires storing additional pointers and tree nodes to maintain version history. Experiments showed a memory overhead of approximately 4.2x compared to the baseline. Given the substantial speedup, this is considered a favorable trade-off for modern hardware.
  • Insertion vs. Query Costs: The FPNNT makes inserting a new node slightly more expensive (amortized $O(\log^2 L)$), but the drastic reduction in query time for visibility checks results in a net gain in efficiency.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the FPSDS framework offers a significant leap in efficiency, several areas for future research remain:

  • High-Dimensional Scaling: While 4.2x memory overhead is manageable in 2D and 3D, further optimization may be required for high-dimensional configuration spaces.
  • Advanced Geometric Primitives: The current implementation uses bounding balls for range queries. Transitioning to more complex structures like R-Trees could further optimize queries for non-spherical volumes.
  • Continuous Planning: The current study focused on discrete lattice-based search. Adapting these persistent structures to continuous planners like RRT* presents a challenge, particularly regarding the "rewiring" step, which would require a more complex versioning logic.

Conclusion

By applying fully persistent data structures to the domain of motion planning, this research provides a robust solution to the "lookback" problem in path-dependent tasks. The FPNNT demonstrates that geometric versioning can effectively decouple query time from path length, enabling more complex and longer-duration robotic missions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Motion planning is a ubiquitous problem that is often a bottleneck in robotic applications. We demonstrate that motion planning problems such as minimum constraint removal, belief-space planning, and visibility-aware motion planning (VAMP) benefit from a path-dependent formulation, in which the state at a search node is represented implicitly by the path to that node. A naïve approach to computing the feasibility of a successor node in such a path-dependent formulation takes time linear in the path length to the node, in contrast to a (possibly very large) constant time for a more typical search formulation. For long-horizon plans, performing this linear-time computation, which we call the lookback, for each node becomes prohibitive. To improve upon this, we introduce the use of a fully persistent spatial data structure (FPSDS), which bounds the size of the lookback. We then focus on the application of the FPSDS in VAMP, which involves incremental geometric computations that can be accelerated by filtering configurations with bounding volumes using nearest-neighbor data structures. We demonstrate an asymptotic and practical improvement in the runtime of finding VAMP solutions in several illustrative domains. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first use of a fully persistent data structure for accelerating motion planning.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{karnik2022fully,
  author = {Sathwik Karnik and Tomás Lozano-Pérez and Leslie Pack Kaelbling and Gustavo Nunes Goretkin},
  title = {{Fully Persistent Spatial Data Structures for Efficient Queries in Path-Dependent Motion Planning Applications}},
  booktitle = {IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=G9A-ZO3PTm},
}
Figure