Abstract: An inevitable consequence of the global power system transition towards nearly 100% renewable-based generation is the loss of conventional bulk generation by synchronous machines, their inertia, and accompanying frequency and voltage control mechanisms. This gradual transformation of the power system to a low-inertia system leads to critical challenges in maintaining system stability. Novel control techniques for converters, so-called grid-forming strategies, are expected to address these challenges and replicate functionalities that so far have been provided by synchronous machines. This article presents a low-inertia case study that includes synchronous machines and converters controlled under various grid-forming techniques. In this work 1) the positive impact of the grid-forming converters on the frequency stability of synchronous machines is highlighted, 2) a qualitative analysis which provides insights into the frequency stability of the system is presented, 3) we explore the behavior of the grid-forming controls when imposing the converter dc and ac current limitations, 4) the importance of the dc dynamics in grid-forming control design as well as the critical need for an effective ac current limitation scheme are reported, and lastly 5) we analyze how and when the interaction between the fast grid-forming converter and the slow synchronous machine dynamics can contribute to the system instability.
Introduction
As global power systems transition toward 100% renewable-based generation, they face the critical challenge of losing conventional bulk generation provided by synchronous machines (SMs). These traditional machines provide inherent physical inertia and established frequency and voltage control mechanisms. Their replacement by power-electronic converters leads to "low-inertia" systems where frequency stability is harder to maintain. Grid-forming converters (GFCs) are emerging as a key solution, designed to replicate the stabilizing functionalities of SMs.
Modeling Grid-Forming Converters
To accurately assess stability, the researchers developed high-fidelity electromagnetic transient (EMT) models. A crucial aspect of this work is the detailed representation of the converter's DC-side dynamics. Unlike simplified models that assume an infinite DC source, this study accounts for the response time of the primary energy source (e.g., batteries or PV) and the dynamics of the DC-link capacitor.
The study compares four GFC control strategies: Droop Control, Virtual Synchronous Machine (VSM), Matching Control, and Dispatchable Virtual Oscillator Control (dVOC). Each offers a different approach to mimicking or improving upon traditional generator behavior.
Experimental Setup
The performance of these controllers was evaluated using a modified IEEE 9-bus test system. To simulate a low-inertia environment, two of the three original synchronous generators were replaced with aggregate models of grid-forming converters, representing a significant portion of the total system capacity.
Key Insights and Stability Analysis
The research highlights several critical findings regarding the interaction between fast power electronics and slow mechanical machines:
- Superior Response Speed: GFCs can react nearly instantaneously to disturbances. This speed allows them to arrest frequency drops much faster than SMs, significantly improving the frequency nadir and reducing the Rate of Change of Frequency (RoCoF).
- The Robustness of Matching Control: Matching control proved exceptionally resilient during severe disturbances. By naturally synchronizing frequency to available DC power, it prevents the DC-link voltage collapse that plagued other "DC-agnostic" strategies like Droop or VSM when pushed to their limits.
- Unexpected Destabilization: A key discovery was that the slow response of traditional SM turbines can actually destabilize fast GFCs. If an SM takes too long to ramp up, it forces GFCs to operate at their limits for extended periods, potentially leading to instability if DC reserves are depleted.
- Current Limitation Importance: Effective AC current limitation is vital. The study demonstrates that a scheme modifying the active power set-point can successfully prevent converter instability during massive overloads.
Results
Across a wide range of load disturbance scenarios, the integration of GFCs consistently improved system stability metrics. In a severe 0.9 pu load increase test, only the Matching control and GFCs with specific current-limiting modifications remained stable, while standard implementations failed due to DC voltage collapse. Interestingly, the simulations suggest that 100% GFC systems might be more inherently stable than mixed systems by eliminating the "tug-of-war" between mechanical and electronic dynamics.
Conclusion
Grid-forming converters are essential for the stability of future low-inertia grids. However, their design must account for DC-side dynamics and robust current limitation to handle extreme events. While GFCs significantly enhance frequency stability, the complex interactions between fast electronic controls and slow mechanical governors require careful coordination to avoid new forms of system instability.
Summary updated