Free-Space Optical MISO Communications With an Array of Detectors

Muhammed Salman Bashir, Mohamed‐Slim Alouini

Abstract

Multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) and multiple-input single-output (MISO) schemes have yielded promising results in free space optical (FSO) communications by providing diversity against fading of the received signal intensity. In this article, we have analyzed the probability of error performance of a multiple-input single-output (MISO) free-space optical channel that employs array(s) of detectors at the receiver. In this regard, we have considered the maximal ratio combiner (MRC) and equal gain combiner (EGC) fusion algorithms for the array of detectors, and we have examined the performance of these algorithms subject to phase and pointing errors for strong atmospheric turbulence conditions. It is concluded that when the variance of the phase and pointing errors are below certain thresholds, signal combining with a single array of detectors yields significantly better performance than a multiple arrays receiver. In the final part of the paper, we examine the probability of error of the single detector array receiver as a function of the beam radius, and the probability of error is minimized by (numerically) optimizing the beam radius of the received signal beams.

Introduction: The Challenge of Atmospheric FSO

Free-Space Optical (FSO) communication offers a high-bandwidth, secure, and license-free alternative to traditional radio frequency (RF) links. However, its widespread adoption is hindered by the unpredictable nature of the Earth's atmosphere. Atmospheric turbulence introduces two primary degradations: scintillation, which causes rapid fluctuations in signal intensity, and beam wander, where pointing errors cause the laser beam to physically shift off its intended target.

To mitigate these effects, researchers utilize spatial diversity through Multiple-Input Multiple-Output (MIMO) or Multiple-Input Single-Output (MISO) architectures. By transmitting the same information over multiple spatially separated paths, the probability that all paths fail simultaneously is greatly reduced.

A MISO FSO scenario where multiple ground-based laser transmitters target a single aerial receiver (drone).

A critical design choice in these systems involves the receiver hardware: should each incoming beam be captured by its own dedicated detector array, or should all beams be focused onto a single, shared array? This paper investigates this trade-off, focusing on how noise floors and interference patterns dictate the optimal architecture.

Methodology and Modeling

The study employs a rigorous analytical framework to evaluate performance under strong atmospheric turbulence. The researchers modeled the laser intensity at the receiver as a circularly symmetric Gaussian density function.

3D representation of the Gaussian intensity distribution of a laser beam on the detector plane.

Signal Fusion and Error Sources

The performance of two standard combining algorithms was analyzed:

  1. Maximal Ratio Combining (MRC): Signals are weighted according to their instantaneous signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) before being summed.
  2. Equal Gain Combining (EGC): All signals are summed with equal weight, offering a lower-complexity alternative to MRC.

The model accounts for two critical error types: pointing errors, modeled as a Gauss-Markov process representing the beam's jitter on the detector surface, and phase errors, treated as zero-mean Gaussian random variables representing the lack of perfect synchronization between incoming beams.

Optimization via Genetic Algorithms

To find the optimal beam radius ($\rho$) that minimizes the Bit Error Rate (BER), the authors used a real-number genetic algorithm. This numerical approach is necessary because the relationship between beam size, pointing error, and noise is non-linear. A narrow beam concentrates energy but is easily lost due to jitter; a wide beam is robust to jitter but spreads energy across more noisy detectors.

Key Insights: The Single-Array Advantage

The core finding of the research is a "hardware paradox": a single detector array often outperforms a multi-array setup.

The Noise Floor Argument

In a multi-array receiver, each additional array introduces its own thermal and shot noise. When signals are combined, these noise components accumulate. In contrast, a single array processes multiple overlapping beams while maintaining a single, constant noise floor. This "cleaner" sufficient statistic allows for better decoding, provided the beams are reasonably aligned.

The Threshold of Interference

The superiority of the single-array approach is not absolute. It depends heavily on the precision of the system. If the variance of phase or pointing errors exceeds specific thresholds, the beams interfere destructively on the single array. In such high-error environments, the isolation provided by separate arrays becomes more beneficial, acting as a safeguard against catastrophic interference.

Results and Performance

The authors validated their mathematical derivations using Monte Carlo simulations. The results showed:

  • High Analytical Fidelity: The closed-form expressions for error probability matched the simulations almost perfectly.
  • Optimization Valleys: Plotting the probability of error against the beam radius revealed clear "valleys," confirming that there is a mathematically optimal physical geometry for the laser beam in any given turbulence condition.
  • Diversity Gains: Under low-error conditions, the single-array receiver provided significant BER improvements, effectively leveraging MISO diversity without the noise penalty of multiple hardware chains.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research provides a clear roadmap for designing robust FSO MISO systems. By demonstrating that a single detector array is often the superior choice, it simplifies hardware requirements while improving performance. Future work may extend these findings to different turbulence regimes, such as weak or moderate turbulence, and explore more complex modulation formats beyond Pulse Position Modulation (PPM).

Summary updated

Abstract

Multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) and multiple-input single-output (MISO) schemes have yielded promising results in free space optical (FSO) communications by providing diversity against fading of the received signal intensity. In this article, we have analyzed the probability of error performance of a muliple-input single-output (MISO) free-space optical channel that employs array(s) of detectors at the receiver. In this regard, we have considered the maximal ratio combiner (MRC) and equal gain combiner (EGC) fusion algorithms for the array of detectors, and we have examined the performance of these algorithms subject to phase and pointing errors for strong atmospheric turbulence conditions. It is concluded that when the variance of the phase and pointing errors are below certain thresholds, signal combining with a single array of detectors yields significantly better performance than a multiple arrays receiver. In the final part of the paper, we examine the probability of error of the single detector array receiver as a function of the beam radius, and the probability of error is minimized by (numerically) optimizing the beam radius of the received signal beams.
BibTeX
@article{bashir2020free,
  author = {Muhammed Salman Bashir and Mohamed‐Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Free-Space Optical MISO Communications With an Array of Detectors}},
  journal = {IEEE Open Journal of the Communications Society},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/ojcoms.2020.3035600},
}

Loading related content...

Figure