FOUR FACTS ABOUT ESG BELIEFS AND INVESTOR PORTFOLIOS

Stefano Giglio, Matteo Maggiori, Johannes Stroebel, Zhenhao Tan, Stephen P. Utkus, Xu Xiao

This paper, titled "Four Facts About ESG Beliefs and Investor Portfolios," provides a rare, data-driven look into the psychology of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) investing. By linking what investors say in surveys to what they actually do with their money, the authors reveal a complex tug-of-war between moral values and financial pragmatism.

TL;DR

Most retail investors expect ESG investments to underperform the broader market, yet a small, dedicated group invests anyway, primarily driven by ethical motives. However, even for these "moral" investors, financial expectations act as a gatekeeper: they only allocate significant capital to ESG funds if they believe those funds will actually beat the market.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The explosion of ESG investing—surpassing $2.5 trillion in assets by late 2022—has sparked a heated debate. Are investors chasing "alpha" (excess returns), hedging against climate disasters, or simply trying to be "good people"?

Until now, researchers struggled to answer this because they usually had only half the picture: either survey data on beliefs (which can be prone to "virtue signaling") or portfolio data (which doesn't explain why a trade was made). This paper bridges that gap by linking anonymized administrative portfolio data from Vanguard to a recurring survey of its clients, allowing the authors to see if an investor’s stated philosophy matches their actual asset allocation.

Methods

The researchers utilized a "panel survey" approach, meaning they tracked the same individuals over multiple time periods (ten waves between June 2021 and December 2022).

  • Belief Elicitation: The survey asked for 10-year annualized return expectations for both the general market and a diversified ESG portfolio. It also forced respondents to pick their primary motivation: (1) no reason, (2) excess returns, (3) ethical reasons, or (4) climate hedging.
  • Behavioral Linking: These responses were matched to the investors' actual holdings in ESG-labeled mutual funds and ETFs.
  • Statistical Modeling: The authors used individual fixed-effects regressions to determine if ESG beliefs are persistent traits or just temporary reactions to market news.

Datasets

  • GMSU-Vanguard Survey: A random sample of U.S.-based Vanguard retail and retirement clients (approx. 2,000 responses per wave).
  • Vanguard Administrative Data: Anonymized records of the respondents' actual portfolio compositions.
  • Morningstar: Used the "Sustainable Investment Overall" indicator to classify which funds in the portfolios were truly ESG-focused.
  • First Street Foundation: Provided zip-code level flood risk data to see if physical climate risk influenced hedging motives.
  • 2020 US Election Data: Used to proxy political leanings based on the respondent's county.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Pessimism" Fact: On average, investors are ESG skeptics. They expected ESG to underperform the market by 1.4% per year over a decade. This suggests that for the average retail investor, the "ESG premium" is perceived as a cost, not a benefit.
  • The Gatekeeper Effect: This is the most striking "aha" moment. The authors found that even among investors who say they invest for "ethical reasons," they only hold meaningful amounts of ESG assets if they also expect those assets to outperform. If an ethical investor expects ESG to lag the market, their actual holdings remain near zero. Financial pragmatism effectively "vetoes" moral sentiment.
  • Belief Heterogeneity: ESG views are highly polarized. 45% of respondents see no reason to invest in ESG at all. Among the rest, the motivations are split: 25% are ethical, 22% are hedging, and only 7% expect better returns.
  • Persistence: Beliefs about ESG are not flighty. An investor who is an ESG optimist today is very likely to be one 18 months from now, regardless of how the market performs in the interim.

Key Results

  • Participation is Low: Only 3.5% of the sampled investors actually owned any ESG-focused funds.
  • Motives Matter: Investors driven by "ethics" held the highest share of ESG assets (averaging 1% of their total portfolio), followed by those seeking "outperformance" (0.8%).
  • Climate Concern: 80% of those who actually hold ESG assets report being "highly concerned" about climate change.
  • The Return Gap: The gap between expected market returns (~7%) and expected ESG returns (~5.6%) widened over the study period as ESG funds faced a difficult 2022.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their sample—Vanguard clients—is wealthier (average portfolio ~$689k), older (average age 63), and more likely to be male (65%) than the average American. This "sophisticated" demographic might not represent the behavior of younger Gen Z investors or those using "neobroker" apps.

Additionally, the paper notes that some investors might avoid ESG funds not due to a lack of concern for the planet, but due to a lack of trust in ESG labels (fear of "greenwashing"). Future research could explore whether standardized, more transparent ESG ratings would lower the "financial gatekeeping" barrier and allow more ethical investors to align their portfolios with their values.

Summary updated

Abstract

We analyze survey data on ESG beliefs and preferences in a large panel of retail investors linked to administrative data on their investment portfolios. The survey elicits investors' expectations of long-term ESG equity returns and asks about their motivations, if any, to invest in ESG assets. We document four facts. First, investors generally expected ESG investments to underperform the market. Between mid-2021 and late-2022, the average expected 10-year annualized return of ESG investments relative to the overall stock market was $-1.4\%$. Second, there is substantial heterogeneity across investors in their ESG return expectations and their motives for ESG investing: 45\% of survey respondents do not see any reason to invest in ESG, 25\% are primarily motivated by ethical considerations, 22\% are driven by climate hedging motives, and 7\% are motivated by return expectations. Third, there is a link between individuals' reported ESG investment motives and their actual investment behaviors, with the highest ESG portfolio holdings among individuals who report ethics-driven investment motives. Fourth, financial considerations matter independently of other investment motives: we find meaningful ESG holdings only for investors who expect these investments to outperform the market, even among those investors who reported that their most important ESG investment motives were ethical or hedging reasons.
BibTeX
@article{giglio2024four,
  author = {Stefano Giglio and Matteo Maggiori and Johannes Stroebel and Zhenhao Tan and Stephen P. Utkus and Xu Xiao},
  title = {{FOUR FACTS ABOUT ESG BELIEFS AND INVESTOR PORTFOLIOS}},
  journal = {Journal of Financial Economics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jfineco.2024.103984},
}

Loading related content...

Figure