Formation of amyloid loops in brain tissues is controlled by the flexibility of protofibril chains

Alyssa Miller, Jiapeng Wei, Sarah Meehan, Christopher M. Dobson, Mark E. Welland, David Klenerman, Michele Vendruscolo, Francesco Simone Ruggeri, Tuomas P. J. Knowles

TL;DR

This paper investigates the formation of amyloid loops, which are implicated in neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer's. By combining atomic force microscopy with biopolymer theory, the researchers found that the flexibility of early-stage protein chains (protofibrils) is the key factor enabling them to form these ring-like structures, unlike the rigid, mature amyloid fibrils. This work sheds light on the diverse structures formed during protein aggregation and their potential role in disease.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Neurodegenerative diseases, such as Alzheimer's disease (AD), are linked to the aggregation of proteins into amyloid fibrils. While mature, insoluble fibrils are a hallmark, growing evidence points to soluble, low-molecular-weight aggregates as major contributors to disease toxicity. Among these, closed-loop, pore-like structures have been observed in various amyloid systems and are associated with neuropathology in AD brains. However, the precise mechanisms by which these loops form and how they relate to mature fibrils have remained unclear. This paper aims to bridge this gap by characterizing these loop structures, particularly those found in AD brain tissue, and understanding the physical principles governing their formation.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM): This technique was used to visualize and measure the physical dimensions and morphology of both in vitro (using bovine α-lactalbumin as a model) and ex vivo (from AD patient brains) amyloid aggregates. AFM allowed for single-molecule imaging and the analysis of bending fluctuations.
  • Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM): Used to complement AFM, TEM provided high-resolution images of the aggregate structures.
  • Statistical Theory of Biopolymers: This theoretical framework was applied to analyze the mechanical properties of the protofibril chains, specifically their flexibility and persistence length. This allowed the researchers to model the probability of loop formation based on chain length and mechanical characteristics.

The novelty lies in the direct characterization of ex vivo AD brain-derived protofibrils and the quantitative link established between their mechanical properties (flexibility) and their ability to form closed-loop structures, using a theoretical model grounded in biopolymer physics.

Datasets

The study utilized two main sources of protein aggregates:

  • In vitro aggregates: Formed from recombinant bovine α-lactalbumin under specific conditions (low pH, high temperature) to mimic amyloid formation.
  • Ex vivo aggregates: Soluble aggregates extracted from the hippocampus of postmortem Alzheimer's disease patient brains.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the study focused on characterizing existing biological samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Flexibility is Key to Loop Formation: The most significant finding is that the ability of protofibrils to form closed loops is directly governed by their inherent flexibility. Unlike the rigid, highly ordered structures of mature amyloid fibrils, these early-stage chains are more pliable.
  • Ex Vivo Structures Mirror In Vitro Models: The study found that amyloid loop structures observed in AD brain tissue share similar characteristics and mechanical properties with those formed in vitro from α-lactalbumin. This suggests that the fundamental principles of loop formation are conserved across different protein systems and biological contexts.
  • Heterogeneity in AD Aggregates: The ex vivo AD brain samples revealed a heterogeneous population of aggregates, including both open and closed conformations. This challenges the notion of a single, uniform toxic species and supports the idea that a dynamic ensemble of low-molecular-weight structures contributes to disease pathogenesis.
  • Link Between Structure and Toxicity: The increased flexibility of protofibrils, which allows for loop formation, also implies a lower level of structural robustness. This could make them more prone to nonspecific interactions with cellular components, potentially explaining their observed toxicity.

Key Results

  • Persistence Length: The persistence length ($l_p$) of in vitro α-lactalbumin protofibrils was found to be approximately 20 nm, and for ex vivo AD protofibrils, it was around 21 nm. These values are significantly lower than those of mature amyloid fibrils, indicating greater flexibility.
  • Bending Rigidity: The bending rigidity ($C_B$) was calculated to be around $8.5 \times 10^{-29}$ Nm for ex vivo protofibrils and $8.1 \times 10^{-29}$ Nm for in vitro protofibrils. These values are orders of magnitude lower than those of mature amyloid fibrils.
  • Loop Probability: The study quantitatively modeled the probability of loop closure as a function of protofibril arc length, showing that longer chains have a higher probability of forming loops, up to a certain point where the ends may become too far apart to efficiently find each other.
  • Structural Organization: The measured persistence lengths are below those typically found for mature amyloid fibrils, suggesting a lower level of structural organization in these early-stage aggregates.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mechanism of Action Not Directly Studied: While the paper establishes the structural and mechanical properties of loop-forming aggregates and links them to disease relevance, it does not directly investigate their specific mechanisms of cellular toxicity. The authors suggest that this work builds upon previous studies that have explored these mechanisms.
  • Focus on Specific Protein Systems: The study primarily uses α-lactalbumin as an in vitro model and characterizes AD brain aggregates. While the findings suggest generality, further studies on a wider range of amyloidogenic proteins would strengthen this conclusion.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that their findings provide a framework for understanding the diversity of structures formed during protein aggregation and their role in disease. Future work could focus on elucidating the precise molecular interactions that lead to the observed toxicity of these flexible, loop-forming aggregates and exploring how modulating their flexibility might impact disease progression.

Summary updated

Abstract

Neurodegenerative diseases, such as Alzheimer's disease (AD), are associated with protein misfolding and aggregation into amyloid fibrils. Increasing evidence suggests that soluble, low-molecular-weight aggregates play a key role in disease-associated toxicity. Within this population of aggregates, closed-loop pore-like structures have been observed for a variety of amyloid systems, and their presence in brain tissues is associated with high levels of neuropathology. However, their mechanism of formation and relationship with mature fibrils have largely remained challenging to elucidate. Here, we use atomic force microscopy and statistical theory of biopolymers to characterize amyloid ring structures derived from the brains of AD patients. We analyze the bending fluctuations of protofibrils and show that the process of loop formation is governed by the mechanical properties of their chains. We conclude that ex vivo protofibril chains possess greater flexibility than that imparted by hydrogen-bonded networks characteristic of mature amyloid fibrils, such that they are able to form end-to-end connections. These results explain the diversity in the structures formed from protein aggregation and shed light on the links between early forms of flexible ring-forming aggregates and their role in disease.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{miller2023formation,
  author = {Alyssa Miller and Jiapeng Wei and Sarah Meehan and Christopher M. Dobson and Mark E. Welland and David Klenerman and Michele Vendruscolo and Francesco Simone Ruggeri and Tuomas P. J. Knowles},
  title = {{Formation of amyloid loops in brain tissues is controlled by the flexibility of protofibril chains}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2216234120},
}
Figure