Abstract
Free energy principle (FEP) is a burgeoning theory in theoretical neuroscience that provides a universal law for modelling living systems of any scale. Expecting a digital twin mind from this first principle, we propose a macro-level interpretation that bridge neuroscience and psychoanalysis through the lens of computational Lacanian psychoanalysis. In this article, we claim three fundamental parallels between FEP and Lacanian psychoanalysis, and suggest a FEP approach to formalizing Lacan's theory. Sharing the non-linear temporal structure that combines prediction and retrospection (logical time), both of two theories focus on epistemological questions that how systems represented themselves and external world, and those elements failed to be represented (lacks and free energy) significantly influence the systems' subsequent states. Additionally, the fundamental hypothesis of FEP that the precise state of environment is always concealed, accounts for object petit a, the core concept in Lacan's theory. With neuropsychoanalytic mapping from three orders (the Real, the Symbolic, and the Imaginary, RSI) onto brain regions, we propose a brain-wide FEP model for a minimal definition of Lacanian mind - composite state of RSI that is perturbated by desire running over the logical time. The FEP-RSI model involves three FEP units connected by respective free energy with a natural compliance with logical time, mimicking core dynamics of Lacanian mind. The biological plausibility of current model is considered from perspectives of cognitive neuroscience. In conclusion, the FEP-RSI model encapsulates a unified framework for digital twin modeling at the macro level.
Introduction
Creating a "digital twin" of the human mind is a primary objective of computational neuroscience. However, existing models often focus on narrow tasks or micro-level neuronal firing, frequently overlooking the "macro-level" psychic dynamics—such as desire, the unconscious, and social influence—that define the human experience. This research proposes a formal bridge between the Free Energy Principle (FEP) and Lacanian psychoanalysis to address this gap, providing a mathematical framework for the tripartite structure of the mind.
The FEP-RSI Model
The proposed framework, the FEP-RSI model, maps Jacques Lacan’s three orders onto specific functional brain regions and interconnected FEP units:
- The Real: Associated with the brainstem and diencephalon, representing the unrepresentable, biological core.
- The Imaginary: Associated with the parietal and occipital lobes, representing perceptive self-image and sensory processing.
- The Symbolic: Associated with the prefrontal and parietal lobes, representing the realm of language, social laws, and meaning-making.
Instead of a standard hierarchy, these orders are modeled as recurrent FEP units where prediction errors (free energy) propagate between them, mimicking the non-linear "logical time" of the psyche.
Variational Free Energy and the Lacanian "Lack"
A central tenet of FEP is that living systems act to minimize variational free energy, a mathematical proxy for surprise or prediction error. This research equates the "hidden state" of the environment—which is always concealed from the organism—with Lacan’s object petit a, the unattainable object of desire.
As shown in the figure above, the system maintains a generative model $Q(s)$ to predict the state of the world. The divergence ($D_{KL}$) between this internal prediction and the actual observation $P(s|o)$ constitutes the free energy. In Lacanian terms, this divergence represents a "lack" or failure of representation that drives the system's subsequent states and search for meaning.
Computational Simulations and Results
The model was implemented using the pymdp library to simulate individual and multi-agent interactions over 15-timestep dynamics.
- Individual Dynamics: By perturbing the Symbolic unit, the simulation reproduced dynamics resembling a "depressed mood," where a failure in symbolic meaning-making disrupts the stability of the entire RSI system.
- Interpersonal Synchronization: The authors redefine "desire" as a drive toward partial generalized synchronization. Simulations of two agents showed that "perfect" synchronization is impossible, mirroring the Lacanian view that human connection is always marked by an inherent "gap."
- Collective Dynamics: In multi-agent simulations, individuals were shown to indirectly synchronize with a broader group, illustrating Lacan’s dictum: "Desire is the desire of the Other."
Conclusion
The FEP-RSI model offers a unified, biologically plausible framework for digital twin modeling at the macro level. By formalizing psychoanalytic concepts through the lens of active inference, it provides a path toward understanding how complex psychological states emerge from the fundamental drive to minimize uncertainty.
Summary updated