Forest production efficiency increases with growth temperature

Alessio Collalti, Andreas Ibrom, Anders Stockmarr, Alessandro Cescatti, Ramdane Alkama, Marcos Fernández‐Martínez, Gioṙgio Matteucci, Stephen Sitch, Pierre Friedlingstein, Philippe Ciais, Daniel S. Goll, Julia E. M. S. Nabel, Julia Pongratz, Almut Arneth, Vanessa Haverd, I. Colin Prentice

TL;DR

This study challenges the prevailing assumption that forest carbon use efficiency (FPE) decreases with increasing temperature. By analyzing a comprehensive global dataset, researchers found that FPE actually increases with temperature, latitude, and precipitation, while decreasing with stand age. This counterintuitive finding suggests that current ecosystem models, which predict the opposite temperature effect, may overestimate carbon losses in a warming climate.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Forests play a critical role in the global carbon cycle, acting as significant carbon sinks. Understanding how efficiently forests convert assimilated carbon into biomass (Forest Production Efficiency, FPE) is crucial for predicting their future role in mitigating climate change. Historically, research and ecosystem models have largely assumed that FPE, often represented by Carbon Use Efficiency (CUE) or Biomass Production Efficiency (BPE), is relatively constant or declines with increasing temperature due to higher respiration rates. However, there has been a lack of a comprehensive global analysis to confirm this. This paper addresses this gap by providing a large-scale, data-driven investigation into the drivers of FPE, specifically questioning the assumed negative relationship with temperature and its implications for climate modeling.

Methods

The researchers compiled a global dataset of forest FPE, CUE, and BPE from over 300 peer-reviewed articles. They employed a mixed-effects multiple linear regression model to analyze the relationships between FPE and various environmental and structural variables. This statistical approach allowed them to disentangle the contributions of multiple predictors, even when they were correlated. The key predictors investigated were mean annual temperature (MAT), stand age, total annual precipitation (TAP), and absolute latitude (|lat|). The method used to estimate Gross Primary Production (GPP) was included as a random effect to account for potential methodological biases. To validate their findings and assess current modeling capabilities, the researchers also applied a similar regression model to outputs from eight Dynamic Global Vegetation Models (DGVMs) from the TRENDY v.7 project.

Datasets

The study utilized a global compilation of forest FPE data, including estimates of Carbon Use Efficiency (CUE, n=47) and Biomass Production Efficiency (BPE, n=197), totaling 244 records from over 100 forest sites worldwide. These sites spanned a wide range of environments, from tropical lowlands to high latitudes and altitudes, and included various forest types (deciduous broad-leaf, evergreen broad-leaf, evergreen needle-leaf, and mixed forests). The data primarily covered the period from 1995 to 2015. The study also used outputs from eight DGVMs within the TRENDY v.7 project, which provided simulated CUE data for analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Temperature's Counterintuitive Effect: The most striking finding is that FPE increases with mean annual temperature. This directly contradicts the expectation that higher temperatures would lead to increased respiration, thus reducing efficiency. This suggests a "top-down" regulation of carbon loss, where plants might be more efficient at higher temperatures, possibly due to physiological adaptations or altered carbon allocation strategies.
  • Beyond Respiration: The observed temperature effect implies that simple models based on short-term physiological responses of respiration are insufficient. It points towards longer-term acclimation or adaptation mechanisms that allow plants to maintain or even improve efficiency under warmer conditions.
  • Latitude Matters: FPE also increases with absolute latitude. This could be linked to factors like longer summer days and increased diffuse radiation at higher latitudes, potentially enhancing photosynthetic light-use efficiency.
  • Precipitation's Positive Role: Higher total annual precipitation is associated with increased FPE, likely due to improved water availability and stomatal opening, which can boost photosynthesis.
  • Age-Related Decline: The well-established finding that FPE declines with stand age was also confirmed, suggesting that as forests mature, their efficiency in converting carbon to biomass decreases.
  • Model Mismatch: Current ecosystem models consistently predict a decrease in FPE with increasing temperature, a stark contrast to the empirical findings. This suggests these models may overestimate carbon losses in a warming world and need significant revision.

Key Results

  • A global dataset of 244 forest FPE records was analyzed.
  • FPE was found to increase significantly with mean annual temperature (MAT), total annual precipitation (TAP), and absolute latitude (|lat|). The estimated sensitivity of FPE to MAT was +0.006 °C⁻¹.
  • FPE was found to decrease significantly with stand age, with an estimated slope of -0.0004 yr⁻¹.
  • The mixed-effects model explained 30% of the variance in observed FPE values, which was considered unexpectedly high given the inherent uncertainties in FPE estimation.
  • When applied to DGVM outputs, the models consistently showed a negative relationship between CUE and MAT, with an average slope of -0.005 °C⁻¹, highlighting the discrepancy with empirical data.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the FPE data have inherent uncertainties, particularly in the measurement of NPP and GPP. While their statistical model accounted for some of this uncertainty and explained a significant portion of the variance, there is still room for improvement. The study also notes that some FPE values exceeded previously established upper bounds, suggesting that these might occur in young, actively growing forests.

Future work should focus on refining ecosystem models to incorporate the observed positive relationship between FPE and temperature. This would involve investigating the underlying physiological and ecological mechanisms responsible for this phenomenon, such as thermal acclimation, changes in enzyme kinetics, and altered carbon allocation strategies. Further research into the role of non-structural carbohydrates and their allocation patterns could also provide valuable insights. Ultimately, a more accurate representation of FPE in climate models is crucial for better predictions of the future carbon balance of forests under a changing climate.

Summary updated

Abstract

Forest production efficiency (FPE) metric describes how efficiently the assimilated carbon is partitioned into plants organs (biomass production, BP) or-more generally-for the production of organic matter (net primary production, NPP). We present a global analysis of the relationship of FPE to stand-age and climate, based on a large compilation of data on gross primary production and either BP or NPP. FPE is important for both forest production and atmospheric carbon dioxide uptake. We find that FPE increases with absolute latitude, precipitation and (all else equal) with temperature. Earlier findings-FPE declining with age-are also supported by this analysis. However, the temperature effect is opposite to what would be expected based on the short-term physiological response of respiration rates to temperature, implying a top-down regulation of carbon loss, perhaps reflecting the higher carbon costs of nutrient acquisition in colder climates. Current ecosystem models do not reproduce this phenomenon. They consistently predict lower FPE in warmer climates, and are therefore likely to overestimate carbon losses in a warming climate.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{collalti2020forest,
  author = {Alessio Collalti and Andreas Ibrom and Anders Stockmarr and Alessandro Cescatti and Ramdane Alkama and Marcos Fernández‐Martínez and Gioṙgio Matteucci and Stephen Sitch and Pierre Friedlingstein and Philippe Ciais and Daniel S. Goll and Julia E. M. S. Nabel and Julia Pongratz and Almut Arneth and Vanessa Haverd and I. Colin Prentice},
  title = {{Forest production efficiency increases with growth temperature}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-020-19187-w},
}
Figure