Forecasting the long-term trend of COVID-19 epidemic using a dynamic model

Jichao Sun, Xi Chen, Ziheng Zhang, Shengzhang Lai, Bo ‍Zhao, Hualuo Liu, Shuojia Wang, Wenjing Huan, Ruihui Zhao, Man Tat Alexander Ng, Yefeng Zheng

TL;DR

This paper introduces the Dynamic-Susceptible-Exposed-Infective-Quarantined (D-SEIQ) model, a novel approach that combines traditional epidemic modeling with machine learning for more accurate long-term forecasting of COVID-19 trends. The D-SEIQ model demonstrated strong predictive capabilities in China, accurately forecasting outbreak peaks and cumulative cases, and provided insights into the effectiveness of public health interventions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Forecasting the trajectory of infectious disease outbreaks like COVID-19 is crucial for public health authorities to implement effective prevention and control strategies. Traditional epidemic models (e.g., SEIR) and pure machine learning approaches have limitations. SEIR models often struggle with accurate parameter estimation in real-world, rapidly evolving scenarios, leading to underfitting or overfitting. Pure machine learning models, while powerful, can lack the interpretability and epidemiological grounding needed for robust long-term predictions, especially with limited early-stage data. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a hybrid model that leverages the strengths of both approaches.

Methods

The core of the paper is the proposed Dynamic-Susceptible-Exposed-Infective-Quarantined (D-SEIQ) model. This model is a modification of the traditional Susceptible-Exposed-Infective-Recovered (SEIR) model. Key modifications include:

  • Replacing "Recovered" with "Quarantined" (Q): Recognizing that COVID-19 patients are typically quarantined rather than simply recovering and re-entering the general population, the model explicitly includes a quarantined state.
  • Dynamic Effective Reproduction Number ($R_t$): Instead of a static basic reproduction number ($R_0$), the model incorporates a time-dependent effective reproduction number ($R_t$). This dynamic $R_t$ is modeled as decaying exponentially over time, reflecting the impact of interventions. The equation used is $R_t = R_\infty + (R_0 - R_\infty) \times e^{-\theta t}$, where $R_\infty$ is the final reproduction number, $\theta$ is the decrease ratio, and $t$ is time.
  • Machine Learning-Based Parameter Optimization: The model integrates machine learning techniques for parameter optimization. Specifically, it uses a grid search approach with dynamically adapted search steps to estimate parameters like $R_0$, $R_\infty$, incubation period ($T_E$), infectious period ($T_I$), and the decrease ratio ($\theta$). This optimization is performed under epidemiological rational constraints, ensuring that parameter values remain within plausible ranges.

Datasets

The study primarily uses publicly available data on confirmed COVID-19 cases.

  • Training and Evaluation Data: Daily and cumulative confirmed case numbers from the National Health Commission (NHC) of the People's Republic of China. Data was collected from January 20, 2020, to March 10, 2020.
  • Regional Analysis: The model was applied to three distinct regions within China:
  • China excluding Hubei
    1. Hubei excluding Wuhan
    2. Wuhan
  • External Validation: Data from five other countries (US, Spain, Italy, France, and Germany) were used to assess the model's external validity.

The paper also notes an adjustment made to Wuhan's data between February 12-14 due to the inclusion of clinically confirmed cases without a test, which were redistributed based on the previous 7 days' suspected case distribution.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hybrid Models Excel: Combining the mechanistic understanding of epidemic spread (from SEIR-like models) with the data-fitting power of machine learning offers a more robust approach than either method alone, particularly for complex, evolving outbreaks.
  • Dynamic $R_t$ is Crucial: The effective reproduction number ($R_t$) is not static. Its dynamic nature, influenced by interventions, is key to accurately forecasting epidemic trajectories. Modeling its exponential decay provides a more realistic representation of control efforts.
  • Quarantine as a Key State: Explicitly modeling the "Quarantined" state is more appropriate for COVID-19 than a generic "Recovered" state, as quarantine directly removes infectious individuals from the transmission chain.
  • Intervention Effectiveness Revealed: The parameters learned by the D-SEIQ model (e.g., the decrease ratio $\theta$) provide quantitative insights into the effectiveness of public health interventions in different regions.
  • Early Data is Challenging but Informative: While early data can be noisy and incomplete (especially in Wuhan), the model's ability to adapt and learn from it, even with adjustments, highlights the potential for early forecasting.

Key Results

  • China Excluding Hubei: The model accurately predicted the long-term trend for up to 40 days and the exact outbreak peak date. The predicted cumulative number on March 10, 2020 (12,506) was only 3.8% different from the actual number (13,005).
  • Hubei Excluding Wuhan: After adjusting for clinically confirmed cases, the model predicted the cumulative number with a 6% error.
  • Wuhan: The model showed a convincing simulation of the overall trend, with a 9% error in cumulative cases by the endpoint after data adjustment.
  • Parameter Insights:
    • The basic reproduction number ($R_0$) was estimated to be higher in China excluding Hubei (6.3) and Hubei excluding Wuhan (6.3) compared to Wuhan (4.63).
  • The decrease ratio ($\theta$) was largest in China excluding Hubei (0.20), indicating faster control.
  • The final reproduction number ($R_\infty$) for all regions approached zero, demonstrating successful epidemic containment.
  • The infectious period ($T_I$) was longer in Wuhan than in other regions, potentially reflecting resource limitations.
  • External Validity: Predictions for five other countries showed reasonable accuracy, with differences between predicted and real numbers ranging from -0.2% (Germany) to -16.0% (US).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Applicability Conditions: The D-SEIQ model is most effective when there are adequate medical capacities, consistent containment measures, timely case detection, and reporting. This explains why it performed better in China excluding Hubei.
  • International Application Caution: Applying the model to other countries requires careful consideration of their specific detection, reporting, and intervention strategies, which can differ significantly.
  • Single Epidemic Wave: The current model is designed to predict a single epidemic wave. It does not account for potential second waves, which have emerged due to imported cases or relaxed containment measures.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that mathematical models need to be developed to predict the possibility of second waves. Further research could also explore more sophisticated machine learning techniques for parameter optimization and incorporate additional data sources.

Summary updated

Abstract

The current outbreak of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has recently been declared as a pandemic and spread over 200 countries and territories. Forecasting the long-term trend of the COVID-19 epidemic can help health authorities determine the transmission characteristics of the virus and take appropriate prevention and control strategies beforehand. Previous studies that solely applied traditional epidemic models or machine learning models were subject to underfitting or overfitting problems. We propose a new model named Dynamic-Susceptible-Exposed-Infective-Quarantined (D-SEIQ), by making appropriate modifications of the Susceptible-Exposed-Infective-Recovered (SEIR) model and integrating machine learning based parameter optimization under epidemiological rational constraints. We used the model to predict the long-term reported cumulative numbers of COVID-19 cases in China from January 27, 2020. We evaluated our model on officially reported confirmed cases from three different regions in China, and the results proved the effectiveness of our model in terms of simulating and predicting the trend of the COVID-19 outbreak. In China-Excluding-Hubei area within 7 days after the first public report, our model successfully and accurately predicted the long trend up to 40 days and the exact date of the outbreak peak. The predicted cumulative number (12,506) by March 10, 2020, was only 3·8% different from the actual number (13,005). The parameters obtained by our model proved the effectiveness of prevention and intervention strategies on epidemic control in China. The prediction results for five other countries suggested the external validity of our model. The integrated approach of epidemic and machine learning models could accurately forecast the long-term trend of the COVID-19 outbreak. The model parameters also provided insights into the analysis of COVID-19 transmission and the effectiveness of interventions in China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2020forecasting,
  author = {Jichao Sun and Xi Chen and Ziheng Zhang and Shengzhang Lai and Bo ‍Zhao and Hualuo Liu and Shuojia Wang and Wenjing Huan and Ruihui Zhao and Man Tat Alexander Ng and Yefeng Zheng},
  title = {{Forecasting the long-term trend of COVID-19 epidemic using a dynamic model}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-78084-w},
}
Figure