Flux Linkage Based Evaluation Method for Voltage Inertia and Voltage Recovery Capability Under Large Disturbances

Yinhong Lin, Huaichang Ge, Bin Wang, Qinglai Guo, Hongbin Sun

Abstract

High-voltage direct current (HVDC) transmission applications and the growth of the dynamic load in large-scale receiving-end grids lead to a higher risk of short-term voltage instability. An effective way to address this problem is to improve the system's dynamic voltage support capability by changing the operation status of dynamic var devices. Due to the time delay in synchronous machine excitation systems, the dynamic var reserved at steady state cannot be exploited immediately under large disturbances. This paper analyzes the voltage support effect based on flux linkage and proposes two novel indexes—Voltage Inertia Capability (VIC) and Voltage Recovery Capability (VRC)—to evaluate voltage nadir and recovery speed. Numerical simulations based on the IEEE 39-bus system verify that these indexes can quantify voltage support capabilities and maintain system security.

Introduction: The Limitations of Dynamic Var Reserve

As power grids evolve, they are increasingly integrated with High-Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) transmission and heavy dynamic loads, such as induction motors. This shift makes the grid more susceptible to Short-Term Voltage Stability (STVS) issues. When a fault occurs, voltage can drop dangerously low, potentially triggering commutation failures in HVDC stations or causing motors to stall.

Traditionally, engineers have relied on Dynamic Var Reserve (DVR)—the spare reactive power capacity available in generators. However, DVR assumes reactive power can be deployed instantly. In reality, the excitation systems of synchronous machines have a significant time delay. As illustrated in Figure 2, the "spontaneous" reactive power output ($Q_{spon}$) occurs immediately through electromagnetic induction, while the controlled "excitation" response ($Q_{exc}$) lags significantly. By the time the reserve kicks in, the voltage may have already crashed.

Reactive power response components showing the gap between spontaneous output and delayed excitation.

Methodology: Quantifying Voltage Inertia via Flux Linkage

To address the need for a metric that captures immediate electromagnetic support, the researchers turned to the physics of flux linkage conservation. In the milliseconds following a fault, the magnetic flux linkage within a generator’s windings cannot change instantly. This physical constraint forces an immediate spontaneous reactive power response.

The researchers derived analytical expressions using a third-order model of a synchronous generator and introduced two novel indexes:

  1. Voltage Inertia Capability (VIC): Measures the support at the exact moment a fault occurs, directly relating to the "voltage nadir."
  2. Voltage Recovery Capability (VRC): An integral measure quantifying how effectively a device helps the voltage bounce back after fault clearance.
Dynamic response of flux linkage and voltage, defining the areas used for VIC and VRC indices.

To make these calculations practical for grid operators, a "stepped" voltage approximation was used to simulate fault impacts, allowing for analytical solutions rather than relying solely on time-intensive numerical simulations.

Key Insights and Results

The proposed method was validated using the IEEE 39-bus system. The analytical "stepped" voltage method proved highly accurate, with a maximum error of only 0.39% during the fault period and 1.17% during the recovery phase compared to full simulations.

Key findings include:

  • Voltage as "Inertia": Much like rotating mass provides frequency inertia, stored magnetic field energy provides "voltage inertia."
  • Operating Points Matter: Simply having a large reactive power reserve is insufficient; the initial state of the generator significantly changes its ability to provide immediate voltage inertia.
  • Security Thresholds: The researchers successfully identified minimum VIC and VRC requirements to maintain voltage above 0.85 p.u., a common safety threshold to prevent HVDC failure.

Conclusion and Future Applications

By using VIC and VRC, voltage security requirements can be converted into simple linear constraints. This allows for Optimal Reactive Power Dispatch (ORPD) to be solved more efficiently without needing thousands of iterative time-domain simulations. While the current study focuses on traditional synchronous machines, future work will explore "virtual" voltage inertia in inverter-dominated systems (wind, solar, and batteries).

Summary updated

Abstract

High-voltage direct current (HVDC) transmission applications and the growth of the dynamic load in large-scale receiving-end grids lead to a higher risk of short-term voltage instability. An effective way to address this problem is to improve the system's dynamic voltage support capability by changing the operation status of dynamic var devices, and the dynamic var reserve (DVR) is commonly used. Due to the time delay in synchronous machine excitation systems, the dynamic var reserved at steady state cannot be exploited immediately under large disturbances. In addition, some reactive power is produced immediately through electromagnetic induction. The voltage support effect of the two capabilities is analyzed based on the flux linkage and an approximate simulation of the fault impact. Then two novel indexes for evaluating the voltage inertia and voltage recovery capability are proposed, which are related to the voltage nadir and voltage recovery speed. The indexes' physical meanings are revealed by comparison with the frequency response, and the potential applications in planning and optimal reactive power dispatch (ORPD) are introduced. Numerical simulations based on the IEEE 39-bus system verify that the indexes can quantify the voltage support capabilities, and the minimum voltage support requirements are obtained to maintain systems' security.
BibTeX
@misc{lin2022flux,
  author = {Yinhong Lin and Huaichang Ge and Bin Wang and Qinglai Guo and Hongbin Sun},
  title = {{Flux Linkage Based Evaluation Method for Voltage Inertia and Voltage Recovery Capability Under Large Disturbances}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2209.01615},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2209.01615},
}
Figure