Regularized Estimating Equations from the Fixed-point and Variational Inequality Perspectives

Yi Yang, Yuwen Gu, Yue Zhao, Jun Fan

Abstract

In this working note, we make some observations about the equivalences between regularized estimating equations, fixed-point problems and variational inequalities. A summary of our findings is given below: (a) A regularized estimating equation is equivalent to a fixed-point problem, specified by the proximal operator of the corresponding penalty; (b) A regularized estimating equation is equivalent to a generalized variational inequality; (c) Both equivalences extend to any estimating equations and any penalty functions. To our knowledge, these observations have never been presented in the literature before. We hope our new findings can lead to further research in both computational and theoretical aspects of regularized estimating equations.

Introduction

In statistical inference, estimating equations (EEs) serve as a vital tool for parameter estimation when a full likelihood function is unavailable or difficult to specify. Common examples include quasi-likelihood methods and generalized estimating equations (GEE). However, as modern datasets grow in dimensionality, the need for regularization—such as the Lasso for sparsity—becomes paramount.

Integrating regularization into the estimating equation framework has historically been challenging. Traditional approaches to Regularized Estimating Equations (REEs) often rely on Local Quadratic Approximation (LQA) or Newton-Raphson updates. These methods suffer from significant drawbacks: they are often restricted to simple, separable penalties; they are computationally expensive due to the need for large matrix inversions; and they frequently rely on heuristic thresholds to achieve sparsity. This paper establishes a formal mathematical bridge between REEs, fixed-point theory, and variational inequalities (VIs), providing a unified framework that overcomes these limitations.

Theoretical Framework

The core of this research lies in redefining the REE through the subgradient of a general convex penalty function, $\Omega(\beta)$. By moving away from specific penalty formulas, the authors establish two fundamental equivalences that transform how these problems are solved.

The Fixed-Point Perspective

The authors demonstrate that solving an REE is mathematically equivalent to finding the fixed point of a mapping that incorporates the proximal operator. The proximal operator acts as a "universal translator," allowing researchers to handle non-differentiable penalties (like the $L_1$ norm) without the need for smooth approximations. If the proximal operator of a penalty is known—as it is for Lasso, Group Lasso, and others—the estimation problem can be solved through simple, iterative fixed-point updates.

The Variational Inequality Perspective

Furthermore, the paper proves that the REE can be reformulated as a generalized variational inequality (VI). This is a significant theoretical advancement, as VIs are a cornerstone of optimization theory. By framing REEs as VIs, the entire library of highly refined VI solvers becomes available for statistical estimation. This includes algorithms that do not require the estimating function to be the gradient of an objective function, making the framework applicable to robust statistics and econometrics where traditional loss functions may not exist.

Algorithmic Implications and Convergence

By establishing these links, the paper suggests a shift away from traditional Newton-type methods toward more efficient iterative algorithms. Key algorithmic contributions include:

  • Krasnosel’skii–Mann (KM) Iteration: A robust fixed-point iteration method.
  • Golden Ratio Algorithm (GRA): An adaptive algorithm for solving VIs that does not require prior knowledge of the system's Lipschitz constant.

Unlike the heuristic LQA methods, these fixed-point and VI-based algorithms come with rigorous convergence guarantees, specifically achieving rates of $O(1/k)$. Moreover, because these methods utilize proximal operators, they produce exact zero coefficients by design, eliminating the need for arbitrary truncation thresholds to achieve sparsity.

Universality and Constraints

A key insight of this work is its universality. These equivalences are not limited to specific models; they extend to any estimating equation and any convex penalty, including complex structures like Group Lasso and Sparse Group Lasso. Additionally, the authors show that constrained estimation (e.g., restricting parameters to a specific set) is mathematically identical to the regularized framework when an indicator function is used as the penalty.

Limitations and Future Research

While this working note provides a robust theoretical foundation, several areas remain for future exploration:

  1. Convexity: The current results primarily assume the penalty function $\Omega(\beta)$ is convex. While non-convex penalties like SCAD are mentioned, the fixed-point/VI bridge is most stable in the convex case.
  2. Monotonicity: For VI solvers to guarantee convergence, the estimating function $U(\beta)$ generally needs to satisfy monotonicity conditions, which may not hold for all statistical models.
  3. Empirical Validation: As a theoretical note, this work does not include empirical benchmarks on high-dimensional datasets. Future research is required to compare the performance of these proposed solvers against existing REE algorithms in practical settings.

Conclusion

By establishing the equivalence between REEs, fixed-point problems, and variational inequalities, this work provides a new theoretical lens for statistical computation. This unified perspective not only simplifies the treatment of complex penalties but also provides a clear path toward faster, more stable algorithms for high-dimensional statistical inference.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this working note, we make some observations about the equivalences between regularized estimating equations, fixed-point problems and variational inequalities. A summary of our findings is given below: (a) A regularized estimating equation is equivalent to a fixed-point problem, specified by the proximal operator of the corresponding penalty; (b) A regularized estimating equation is equivalent to a generalized variational inequality; (c) Both equivalences extend to any estimating equations and any penalty functions. To our knowledge, these observations have never been presented in the literature before. We hope our new findings can lead to further research in both computational and theoretical aspects of regularized estimating equations.
BibTeX
@misc{yang2021regularized,
  author = {Yi Yang and Yuwen Gu and Yue Zhao and Jun Fan},
  title = {{Regularized Estimating Equations from the Fixed-point and Variational Inequality Perspectives}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2110.11074},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2110.11074},
}
Figure