Flagship species, ecological complementarity and conserving the diversity of mammals and birds in sub‐Saharan Africa

Paul H. Williams, Neil Burgess, Carsten RahbekAnimal 2000 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates whether charismatic "flagship" species, like the "Big Five," are effective surrogates for conserving broader biodiversity in sub-Saharan Africa. The study finds that using these popular species to select conservation areas is no better than random selection for representing mammal and bird diversity, highlighting the need for a more nuanced approach that prioritizes ecological complementarity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Conservation efforts often rely on "flagship" species – those that are charismatic and attract public support – to drive funding and conservation initiatives. The underlying assumption is that protecting these species will also protect many others, acting as "umbrella" species. However, the effectiveness of this strategy for truly conserving broad biodiversity, especially for less charismatic species, has been questioned. This paper addresses this by empirically testing whether selecting conservation areas based on popular flagship species (both conservationist-defined and tourist-popular "Big Five") actually leads to better representation of mammal and bird diversity in sub-Saharan Africa compared to other selection methods, including random selection.

Methods

The researchers employed quantitative area-selection methods to assess how well different species groups represent overall biodiversity. They used a "maximal covering" approach, aiming to select a limited number of areas that maximize the representation of target species. Three primary methods were used:

  1. Hotspots of richness: Selecting areas with the highest number of species.
  2. Hotspots of narrow endemism: Selecting areas with the highest concentration of species with restricted distributions.
  3. Hotspots of complementary richness: Selecting areas that contribute the largest number of unrepresented species to a growing set of selected areas. This method explicitly seeks to maximize the addition of new species with each selected area, aiming for ecological complementarity.

They also incorporated the concept of "flexibility" in area selection, acknowledging that multiple sets of areas can achieve similar representation goals, and analyzed the variation in biodiversity representation across these flexible sets.

Datasets

The study utilized detailed distribution data for:

  • 938 mammal species across mainland sub-Saharan Africa, mapped onto a 1° grid (approximately 105x105 km cells). Data for well-known species were based on estimated ranges from 1970-1989, while less-known species had ranges interpolated or plotted directly from records.
  • 1749 breeding bird species, also mapped onto the same 1° grid.
  • 98 ecoregions within sub-Saharan Africa, as defined by Itoua et al. (1997).

This combined dataset comprised 2687 species (mammals and birds) and 663,003 species-in-grid-cell records.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Flagships are poor surrogates: The most striking finding is that neither the conservationist-defined flagship species nor the tourist-popular "Big Five" are effective surrogates for representing broader mammal and bird diversity in sub-Saharan Africa. Selecting areas based on these species yields no significant improvement over random selection.
  • Ecological complementarity is key: To achieve good representation of biodiversity, selected species groups must have low overlaps in their distributions. This "ecological complementarity" ensures that different areas are chosen, capturing a wider range of habitats and species.
  • "Best" random groups outperform flagships: When randomly sampling groups of six species, the "best" performing groups (those that represented the most biodiversity) were not large-bodied mammals but rather species with low spatial overlap and broad ecoregion coverage.
  • Hotspots of richness are insufficient: Even selecting areas based on general species richness (hotspots of richness) performed no better than random selection for representing the overall mammal and bird diversity.
  • The need for explicit policy: The study strongly suggests a disconnect between the goals of flagship-driven conservation (raising public support) and broader biodiversity conservation. A policy is needed to balance these, likely by identifying and promoting non-overlapping flagship organisms that represent distinct biotas.

Key Results

  • When selecting more than three areas, only hotspots of narrow endemism (when including all species) and hotspots of complementary richness (using all species or large mammals) significantly outperformed random selection.
  • Using hotspots of complementary richness with all mammal and bird species yielded the highest species representation.
  • When considering the flexibility of area sets (multiple combinations of areas achieving similar representation), flagship species actually represented fewer species than the Big Five, contrary to what might be expected.
  • Crucially, even with flexible area sets, flagship species and the Big Five species failed to represent more species of sub-Saharan mammals and birds in 50 areas than would be expected by chance.
  • The "best" six species found through random sampling (which outperformed flagships and Big Five) had low overlap and covered many ecoregions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data limitations: While the study used extensive data, it acknowledges that for less well-known species, distribution data were interpolated or based on limited records, which could constrain accuracy. The study also did not consider existing conservation areas, cost, or population viability, which are crucial for real-world conservation planning.
  • Scale: The analysis was conducted at a 1° grid cell scale. While useful for broad patterns, finer-scale analyses might reveal different dynamics.
  • Future Directions: The authors emphasize the need for explicit policies to balance flagship conservation with broader biodiversity goals. Future work should focus on identifying and promoting non-overlapping flagship organisms that represent distinct biotas. Further analysis is needed to disentangle the dependencies between various factors influencing area selection success, such as ecoregion coverage and species overlap. The study also points to the potential of using habitat and environmental diversity directly for area selection, though species data, when available, offer finer discrimination.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract More biodiversity could be protected in situ if the few species that attract the most popular support (the ‘flagship’ species) had distributions that also covered the broader diversity of organisms. We studied how well different groups of mammals performed for representing the diversity of mammals and breeding birds among 1° areas of sub‐Saharan Africa. We demonstrate that choosing areas of sub‐Saharan Africa using either conservationists' six primary flagship mammals, or the six ‘Big Five’ mammals popular with wildlife tourists, is not significantly better for representing the diversity of mammals and birds than choosing areas at random. Furthermore, neither of these groups is significantly better for representing the diversity of mammals and birds than groups of the same number of species chosen at random. We show that in order to succeed in representing many mammals and birds in area selection, it is not sufficient for the groups used for selection to occur in many different eco‐regions, they must also have low overlaps in distribution, so as to provide high ecological complementarity (a similar pattern of ecological complementarity must be shared by the larger group of species to be represented). Therefore there may be a need for an explicit policy to balance the requirements of flagship conservation and broader biodiversity conservation, which will have implications for the distribution of resources.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{williams2000flagship,
  author = {Paul H. Williams and Neil Burgess and Carsten Rahbek},
  title = {{Flagship species, ecological complementarity and conserving the diversity of mammals and birds in sub‐Saharan Africa}},
  booktitle = {Animal},
  year = {2000},
  doi = {10.1111/j.1469-1795.2000.tb00110.x},
}

Loading related content...

Figure