Fish Meal vs. Corn Gluten Meal as a Protein Source for Dry Cat Food.

Masayuki Funaba, Tetsuji Tanaka, Masahiro Kaneko, Tsunenori Iriki, Yoshikazu Hatano, Matanobu AbeJournal of Veterinary Medical Science 2001 · DOI

Abstract

To compare the effects of two dietary protein sources, fish meal (FM) and corn gluten meal (CGM), fecal moisture content, nitrogen balance and urinary excretion were examined in adult cats. The dietary protein source did not cause a significant difference in daily food intake, water intake, urine volume, dry matter digestibility or urinary nitrogen excretion, but fecal moisture content was lower (P<0.02) in the CGM group. The HCl-insoluble fraction of urinary sediment tended to be higher in the CGM group (P<0.10), although urinary pH was similar in the two groups. These results suggest that CGM is comparable with FM in respect to nutritional value and the urine acidifying effect, but FM may be preferable to CGM for the prevention of constipation and struvite urolithiasis in cats.

Introduction

Cats, as obligate carnivores, have evolved specific metabolic requirements for nutrients typically found in animal tissues. However, the production of commercial dry cat food often necessitates the inclusion of plant-based ingredients (40–60%) for structural integrity and cost-efficiency. Corn gluten meal (CGM) is a common plant protein substitute for fish meal (FM). While many plant proteins are alkalizing—a risk factor for struvite urolithiasis—CGM is unique due to its high concentration of sulfur-containing amino acids, which can have an acidifying effect on urine. This study investigates the physiological impact of replacing FM with CGM on feline digestion, nitrogen balance, and urinary health.

Methods

A cross-over trial was conducted using six healthy adult cats (three male, three female). The study consisted of two 3-week periods during which cats were fed either an FM-based diet (33.5% fish meal) or a CGM-based diet (36.6% corn gluten meal). Both diets were formulated to be isonitrogenous (~32.5% crude protein) and met NRC requirements.

Cats were housed in metabolic cages to facilitate the precise collection of food and water intake, feces, and urine. Key analyses included:

  • Nitrogen Balance: Measured in food, feces, and urine to assess protein utilization.
  • Urinary Sediment Fractionation: Urine was centrifuged and the sediment was divided into HCl-soluble (inorganic) and HCl-insoluble (organic) fractions.
  • Digestibility: Calculated based on dry matter intake and fecal output.

Results

The study found that CGM is nutritionally comparable to FM in several key areas, including nitrogen retention and dry matter digestibility. Both diets successfully maintained an acidic urinary pH (6.33 for FM vs. 6.25 for CGM), which is essential for preventing struvite crystal formation.

However, significant differences were observed in fecal characteristics and urinary sediment. Fecal moisture content was significantly lower in the CGM group (63.7%) compared to the FM group (73.0%, $P < 0.02$), suggesting a potential risk for constipation.

Table 3: Intake, excretion, and digestibility metrics showing significant differences in fecal moisture.

Additionally, the CGM group exhibited a trend toward higher levels of HCl-insoluble urinary sediment (0.32 mg/ml vs. 0.13 mg/ml in FM, $P < 0.10$). This organic fraction can act as a matrix or "glue" for crystal growth, potentially increasing the risk of urolithiasis despite the favorable pH.

Table 2: Urinary pH and sediment analysis highlighting the trend in HCl-insoluble sediment.

Discussion

The results indicate that while CGM is a viable protein source from a nutritional standpoint, it may have physiological drawbacks. The reduction in fecal moisture could predispose cats to constipation, especially in those with low water intake. Furthermore, the increase in the organic matrix of urinary sediment suggests that CGM might provide more scaffolding for bladder stone formation.

The study's limitations include a small sample size ($n=6$) and a relatively short duration. While the trend in urinary sediment was not statistically significant at the $P < 0.05$ level, it warrants further investigation. Future research should focus on the specific organic components of the sediment and the long-term effects of CGM on urinary tract health. In conclusion, while CGM is an effective acidifying protein source, FM remains the preferred option for cats susceptible to urinary issues or digestive irregularities.

Summary updated

Abstract

To compare the effects of two dietary protein sources, fish meal (FM) and corn gluten meal (CGM), fecal moisture content, nitrogen balance and urinary excretion were examined in adult cats. The dietary protein source did not cause a significant difference in daily food intake, water intake, urine volume, dry matter digestibility or urinary nitrogen excretion, but fecal moisture content was lower (P<0.02) in the CGM group. The HCl-insoluble fraction of urinary sediment tended to be higher in the CGM group (P<0.10), although urinary pH was similar in the two groups. These results suggest that CGM is comparable with FM in respect to nutritional value and the urine acidifying effect, but FM may be preferable to CGM for the prevention of constipation and struvite urolithiasis in cats.
BibTeX
@article{funaba2001fish,
  author = {Masayuki Funaba and Tetsuji Tanaka and Masahiro Kaneko and Tsunenori IRIKI and Yoshikazu Hatano and Matanobu ABE},
  title = {{Fish Meal vs. Corn Gluten Meal as a Protein Source for Dry Cat Food.}},
  journal = {Journal of Veterinary Medical Science},
  year = {2001},
  doi = {10.1292/jvms.63.1355},
}
Figure