Safety assessment of subchronic feeding of insect-resistant and herbicide-resistant transgenic soybeans to juvenile channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus)

Dan Xiang, Mingzhong Luo, Fukun Jiang, Zhengrong Wen, Xiaoyun Chen, Xiaofu Wang, Xiaoli Xu, Wei Wei, Junfeng XuScientific 2023 · DOI

This study, published in Scientific Reports, evaluates the safety of two new transgenic soybean varieties (DBN9004 and DBN8002) as primary feed ingredients for juvenile channel catfish. Over an eight-week trial, researchers found no significant differences in survival, growth performance, or metabolic health compared to non-transgenic and conventional soybean diets, suggesting these GM crops are a safe alternative for the aquaculture industry.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As the global demand for aquaculture grows, finding sustainable and cost-effective protein sources for fish feed is critical. Genetically modified (GM) soybeans are a staple in animal agriculture due to their high protein content and traits like herbicide tolerance and insect resistance. However, while the safety of GM crops for terrestrial livestock is well-documented, aquatic ecosystems and species—like the channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus)—require specific validation.

The researchers aimed to determine if soybeans engineered with specific genes—cp4-epsps and pat (for herbicide resistance) and Vip3Aa (for insect resistance)—induce any adverse physiological or "subchronic" effects in catfish. This is particularly important because fish are sensitive to environmental toxins and dietary changes during their juvenile growth stages.

Methods

The researchers conducted an eight-week feeding trial using 480 juvenile channel catfish. The experimental design was robust, comparing six different soybean-based diets:

  • Two Transgenic Varieties: DBN9004 and DBN8002.
  • One Non-Transgenic Parent: JACK (the genetic control).
  • Three Conventional Varieties: Dongsheng3, 7, and 9 (to establish a "natural" baseline of variation).

Key Techniques: * Standardized Feed: All diets were formulated with 45% soybean meal and balanced for nutrient levels. * Growth & Morphological Indices: Measured Weight Gain Rate (WGR), Specific Growth Rate (SGR), and organ-to-body ratios like the Hepatosomatic Index (HSI) and Viscerosomatic Index (VSI). * Biochemical Assays: Analyzed enzyme activities in the liver, spleen, and head kidney, including markers for liver damage (AST, ALT) and oxidative stress (T-AOC, LDH).

Key Insights and Results

Survival and Growth Performance

One of the most critical safety metrics is the survival rate. The study found no significant differences across groups, with survival rates remaining consistently high (96.25% to 98.75%). Growth performance metrics, including weight gain and specific growth rates (SGR), were also consistent across the board.

Survival rates of juvenile channel catfish across different soybean diet groups.

Metabolic Resilience and Organ Health

The lack of significant change in enzyme activity indexes is a strong indicator of safety. Enzymes like AST and ALT typically leak into the bloodstream or change activity levels when hepatocytes (liver cells) are damaged by toxins. Their stability, along with LDH and T-AOC levels, suggests the transgenic proteins are not toxic to fish metabolism.

Enzyme activities (LDH, T-AOC, AST, ALT) in various tissues showing no significant metabolic distress across treatments.

While the Viscerosomatic Index (VSI) for DBN9004 (12.35%) was slightly higher than the JACK control (11.11%), it remained comparable to the conventional Dongsheng7 variety (12.50%), placing it within the expected biological range for standard soybeans.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Duration: This was a "subchronic" study (8 weeks). While sufficient for juvenile growth, it does not address long-term, multi-generational, or full-life-cycle effects.
  • Environmental Leaching: The paper acknowledges that GM DNA and proteins can enter the water via uneaten feed or feces. Future research could focus on the impact on aquatic microflora in natural pond settings.

The Bottom Line: For aquaculture engineers and feed formulators, this research provides evidence that DBN9004 and DBN8002 soybeans are nutritionally equivalent and physiologically safe for channel catfish, clearing a major hurdle for their commercial use in fish meal replacement.

Summary updated

Abstract

Transgenic soybean is one of the most planted crops for human food and animal feed. The channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus) is an important aquatic organism cultured worldwide. In this study, the effect of six different soybean diets containing: two transgenic soybeans expressing different types of cp4-epsps, Vip3Aa and pat genes (DBN9004 and DBN8002), their non-transgenic parent JACK, and three conventional soybean varieties (Dongsheng3, Dongsheng7, and Dongsheng9) was investigated in juvenile channel catfish for eight weeks, and a safety assessment was performed. During the experiment, no difference in survival rate was observed in six groups. The hepatosomatic index (HSI) and condition factor (CF) showed no significant difference. Moreover, comparable feed conversion (FC), feeding rate (FR), and feed conversion ratio (FCR) were found between transgenic soybean and JACK groups. Assessment of growth performance showed that the weight gain rate (WGR) and specific growth rate (SGR) of channel catfish were consistent. In addition, there were no changes in enzyme activity indexes (lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), total antioxidant capacity (T-AOC), aspartate aminotransferase (AST) and alanine aminotransferase (ALT)) in channel catfish among treatments. The research provided an experimental basis for the aquaculture feed industry to employ transgenic soybean DBN9004 and DBN8002 for commercial purposes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xiang2023safety,
  author = {Dan Xiang and Mingzhong Luo and Fukun Jiang and Zhengrong Wen and Xiaoyun Chen and Xiaofu Wang and Xiaoli Xu and Wei Wei and Junfeng Xu},
  title = {{Safety assessment of subchronic feeding of insect-resistant and herbicide-resistant transgenic soybeans to juvenile channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus)}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-023-31072-2},
}
Figure