First measurement of the CKM angle $ϕ3$ with $B^±→ D( {K}_{\mathrm{S}}^0 $$ π^+π^−π^0) K^{±}$ decays

P. K. Resmi, J. Libby, K. Trabelsi, I. Adachi, H. Aihara, S. Al Said, D. M. Asner, V. Aulchenko, T. Aushev, V. Babu, I. Badhrees, A. M. Bakich, C. Beleño, J. V. Bennett, V. Bhardwaj, B. Bhuyan, T. Bilka, J. P. Biswal, A. Bożek, M. Bračko, M. Campajola, D. Červenkov, K. F. Chen, B. G. Cheon, H. E. Cho, K. Cho, Y. Choi, S. Choudhury, D. Cinabro, S. Cunliffe, N. Dash, G. De Nardo, F. Di Capua, S. Di Carlo, Z. Doležal, T. V. Dong, S. Eidelman, D. Epifanov, J. Fast, T. Ferber, B. G. Fulsom, R. B. Garg, V. Gaur, N. Gabyshev, A. Garmash, A. Giri, P. Goldenzweig, B. Golob, Y. Guan, K. Hayasaka, H. Hayashii, W.-s. Hou, K. Huang, T. Iijima, K. Inami, G. Inguglia, A. Ishikawa, R. Itoh, M. Iwasaki, W. W. Jacobs, H. B. Jeon, Y. Jin, D. Joffe, A. B. Kaliyar, K. H. Kang, G. Karyan, T. Kawasaki, C. Kiesling, D. Y. Kim, K. T. Kim, S. H. Kim, K. Kinoshita, P. Kodyš, D. Kotchetkov, P. Križan, R. Kroeger, P. Krokovny, T. Kuhr, R. Kumar, A. Kuzmin, Y.-j. Kwon, S. C. Lee, Yao Li, K. Lieret, D. Liventsev, P.-c. Lu, T. Luo, C. MacQueen, M. Masuda, T. Matsuda, D. Matvienko, M. Merola, K. Miyabayashi, R. Mizuk, G. B. Mohanty, H. K. Moon, T. Nakano, M. Nakao, K. J. NathDESY 2019 · DOI

Abstract

We present the first model-independent measurement of the CKM unitarity triangle angle $\phi_3$ using $B^\pm \to D(K^0_S \pi^+ \pi^- \pi^0) K^\pm$ decays, where $D$ indicates either a $D^0$ or $\bar{D}^0$ meson. Measurements of the strong-phase difference of the $D \to K^0_S \pi^+ \pi^- \pi^0$ amplitude obtained from CLEO-c data are used as input. This analysis is based on the full Belle data set of $772 \times 10^6$ $B\bar{B}$ events collected at the $\Upsilon(4S)$ resonance. We obtain $\phi_3 = (5.7^{+10.2}_{-8.8} \pm 3.5 \pm 5.7)^\circ$ and the suppressed amplitude ratio $r_B = 0.323 \pm 0.147 \pm 0.023 \pm 0.051$. Here the first uncertainty is statistical, the second is the experimental systematic, and the third is due to the precision of the strong-phase parameters measured from CLEO-c data. The 95% confidence interval on $\phi_3$ is $(-29.7, 109.5)^\circ$, which is consistent with the current world average.

Introduction

In the Standard Model of particle physics, the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix describes how quarks change flavor. A central goal of flavor physics is to measure the "angles" of the Unitarity Triangle associated with this matrix. One of these, $\phi_3$ (also known as $\gamma$), is particularly important because it can be measured using "tree-level" decays. These decays are theoretically clean and less likely to be obscured by unknown "New Physics," making them an ideal laboratory for testing the Standard Model.

However, measuring $\phi_3$ is challenging because it requires observing the interference between two distinct decay paths of a $B$ meson. This is typically done using $B \to DK$ decays where the $D$ meson decays into a final state accessible to both $D^0$ and $\bar{D}^0$. While 2-body and 3-body $D$ decays have been studied extensively, 4-body decays like $D \to K^0_S \pi^+ \pi^- \pi^0$ offer a high branching fraction (5.2%) but present a significant hurdle: the "strong-phase" difference between the $D^0$ and $\bar{D}^0$ amplitudes varies across a complex, five-dimensional phase space.

Methodology

The Belle Collaboration employed a model-independent approach to extract $\phi_3$ without the systematic uncertainties inherent in complex amplitude models.

Phase Space Binning

The 5D phase space of the $D \to K^0_S \pi^+ \pi^- \pi^0$ decay was divided into nine exclusive bins. These bins were chosen based on known intermediate resonances—such as the $\omega, K^*,$ and $\rho$ mesons—to minimize phase variation within each bin and maximize sensitivity to $\phi_3$.

External Inputs and Signal Extraction

To solve for $\phi_3$, the average cosine ($c_i$) and sine ($s_i$) of the strong-phase difference in each bin are required. The authors utilized values previously measured by the CLEO-c experiment, which studied quantum-correlated $D\bar{D}$ pairs at the $\psi(3770)$ resonance.

The primary dataset consists of $772 \times 10^6$ $B\bar{B}$ pairs collected at the $\Upsilon(4S)$ resonance by the Belle detector at the KEKB asymmetric-energy $e^+e^-$ collider. Using this data, the team performed a simultaneous maximum likelihood fit across all bins for both $B^+$ and $B^-$ decays to extract the Cartesian parameters $(x_\pm, y_\pm)$, which are directly related to $\phi_3$, the ratio of amplitudes $r_B$, and the strong-phase difference $\delta_B$. Extensive Monte Carlo simulations (EvtGen, GEANT3) were used to optimize event selection and model background shapes.

Key Results and Insights

The measurement yielded the following values for the physical parameters:

  • $\phi_3 = (5.7^{+10.2}_{-8.8} \text{ (stat)} \pm 3.5 \text{ (syst)} \pm 5.7 \text{ (ext)})^\circ$
  • $r_B = 0.323 \pm 0.147 \pm 0.023 \pm 0.051$

The "ext" uncertainty refers to the precision of the strong-phase parameters from CLEO-c. While the statistical error is currently the dominant factor, the result is entirely consistent with the world average. When combined with other Belle measurements of $\phi_3$, the global Belle value shifts slightly to $\phi_3 = (74^{+13}_{-14})^\circ$.

This work proves that 4-body $D$ decays are a powerful tool for CKM measurements. Despite the complexity of a 5D phase space, the model-independent binning approach makes the analysis robust. By using CLEO-c data as an anchor, the researchers avoided the $\pm 8-9^\circ$ systematic error typically associated with amplitude models.

Conclusion and Future Work

This study marks a successful "proof of concept" for a new category of decays that will be vital for the next generation of high-precision flavor physics. Currently, the measurement is dominated by statistical uncertainty. However, the upcoming Belle II experiment expects to collect 50 times more data, which will drastically reduce these error bars.

Furthermore, future data from BESIII will provide more precise measurements of the $c_i$ and $s_i$ parameters, reducing the external systematic error. Once a complete amplitude model for this specific 4-body decay is developed, the phase space can be binned more "intelligently" to further increase sensitivity. These advancements will allow for even more stringent tests of the Standard Model in the coming years.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present the first model-independent measurement of the CKM unitarity triangle angle ϕ3 using B±→ D(K0Sπ+π−π0) K± decays, where D indicates either a D0 or D¯¯¯¯0 meson. Measurements of the strong-phase difference of the D →K0Sπ+π−π0 amplitude obtained from CLEO-c data are used as input. This analysis is based on the full Belle data set of 772 × 106BB¯¯¯¯ events collected at the Υ(4S) resonance. We obtain ϕ3 = (5.7+10.2−8.8±3.5±5.7)° and the suppressed amplitude ratio rB = 0.323±0.147±0.023±0.051. Here the first uncertainty is statistical, the second is the experimental systematic, and the third is due to the precision of the strong-phase parameters measured from CLEO-c data. The 95% confidence interval on ϕ3 is (−29.7, 109.5)°, which is consistent with the current world average.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{resmi2019first,
  author = {P. K. Resmi and J. Libby and K. Trabelsi and I. Adachi and H. Aihara and S. Al Said and D. M. Asner and V. Aulchenko and T. Aushev and V. Babu and I. Badhrees and A. M. Bakich and C. Beleño and J. V. Bennett and V. Bhardwaj and B. Bhuyan and T. Bilka and J. P. Biswal and A. Bożek and M. Bračko and M. Campajola and D. Červenkov and K. F. Chen and B. G. Cheon and H. E. Cho and K. Cho and Y. Choi and S. Choudhury and D. Cinabro and S. Cunliffe and N. Dash and G. De Nardo and F. Di Capua and S. Di Carlo and Z. Doležal and T. V. Dong and S. Eidelman and D. Epifanov and J. Fast and T. Ferber and B. G. Fulsom and R. B. Garg and V. Gaur and N. Gabyshev and A. Garmash and A. Giri and P. Goldenzweig and B. Golob and Y. Guan and K. Hayasaka and H. Hayashii and W.-S. Hou and K. Huang and T. Iijima and K. Inami and G. Inguglia and A. Ishikawa and R. Itoh and M. Iwasaki and M. Iwasaki and W. W. Jacobs and H. B. Jeon and Y. Jin and D. Joffe and A. B. Kaliyar and K. H. Kang and G. Karyan and T. Kawasaki and C. Kiesling and D. Y. Kim and K. T. Kim and S. H. Kim and K. Kinoshita and P. Kodyš and D. Kotchetkov and P. Križan and R. Kroeger and P. Krokovny and T. Kuhr and R. Kumar and A. Kuzmin and Y.-J. Kwon and S. C. Lee and Yao Li and K. Lieret and D. Liventsev and P.-C. Lu and T. Luo and C. MacQueen and M. Masuda and T. Matsuda and D. Matvienko and M. Merola and K. Miyabayashi and R. Mizuk and G. B. Mohanty and H. K. Moon and T. Nakano and M. Nakao and K. J. Nath},
  title = {{First measurement of the CKM angle $ϕ3$ with $B^±→ D( \{K\}\_\{\textbackslash\{\}mathrm\{S\}\}^0 $$ π^+π^−π^0) K^\{±\}$ decays}},
  booktitle = {DESY},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3204/pubdb-2019-04552},
}
Figure