Finite-momentum Cooper pairing in proximitized altermagnets

Song-Bo Zhang, Lun‐Hui Hu, Titus Neupert

Superconductivity typically involves electrons pairing with opposite spins and momenta, resulting in a zero center-of-mass momentum. Inducing "finite-momentum" Cooper pairing—where pairs possess a net momentum—usually requires breaking time-reversal symmetry via external magnetic fields or ferromagnetic materials. However, these methods introduce stray magnetic fields that complicate device integration. A recent study published in Nature Communications proposes a paradigm shift: using altermagnets to achieve finite-momentum pairing without any net magnetization.

The Challenge of Finite-Momentum Pairing

In conventional superconductors, the formation of Cooper pairs is symmetric. To create a state with finite center-of-mass momentum (such as the elusive Fulde-Ferrell-Larkin-Ovchinnikov or FFLO state), physicists traditionally rely on Zeeman splitting. By applying a magnetic field, the energy levels of spin-up and spin-down electrons are shifted, forcing them to have mismatched momenta to satisfy the pairing condition.

While effective, ferromagnetism is "messy" for quantum technology due to stray fields. Altermagnets offer a cleaner alternative. These materials have zero macroscopic magnetization but possess highly anisotropic, direction-dependent spin splitting in their electronic bands due to unique internal magnetic symmetries.

Altermagnets: A New Platform for Superconductivity

The researchers investigated a planar junction between a conventional s-wave superconductor and a metallic altermagnet (modeling materials like $RuO_2$ and $KRu_4O_8$). Unlike ferromagnets, where spin-splitting is uniform, altermagnets exhibit splitting that changes sign depending on the electron's propagation direction.

Comparison of ferromagnetic (left) and altermagnetic (right) systems. Panels (a, b) show band structures, (c, d) illustrate the momentum distribution of induced Cooper pairs, and (e, f) show the periodicity of superconducting oscillations.

As shown in the figure above, the altermagnetic band structure (b) leads to a highly anisotropic momentum distribution (d). While a ferromagnet produces a uniform circular distribution (c), the altermagnet induces a "clover-leaf" pattern where the Cooper-pair momentum vanishes along main crystalline axes but peaks at $45^\circ$ angles. This directional dependence allows the crystal orientation itself to serve as a primary control knob for superconducting properties.

Key Insights and Experimental Signatures

The study reveals several unique phenomena arising from this proximitized state:

  • Oscillating Order Parameter: The superconducting order parameter does not simply decay into the altermagnet; it oscillates with a period determined by the chemical potential (doping). For $RuO_2$, this period is predicted to be approximately 16–20 nm, a scale accessible to modern scanning tunneling microscopy (STM).
  • Field-Free $0-\pi$ Transitions: Josephson junctions (SC-AM-SC) can be tuned between "0" and "$\pi$" states—where the superconducting phase shifts by 180 degrees—simply by adjusting the junction length or orientation, without requiring external magnetic fields.
  • Oblique Trajectories: In specific orientations, Cooper pairs prefer to move at large oblique angles across the interface, a signature entirely absent in traditional magnetic systems.
  • Anomalous Fraunhofer Patterns: Under an applied magnetic field, the interference patterns of the supercurrent exhibit distinct symmetries that depend on the junction's alignment with the altermagnet's crystal axes.

Future Outlook

This work opens new avenues for non-reciprocal superconducting electronics. By ignoring spin-orbit coupling (SOC), which is typically small in these materials, the authors established a baseline for altermagnetic superconductivity. Future research may explore the role of SOC in inducing "triplet" pairing or investigate the superconducting diode effect, which could lead to more efficient, directional superconducting circuits and qubits.

Summary updated

Abstract

Finite-momentum Cooper pairing is an unconventional form of superconductivity that is widely believed to require finite magnetization. Altermagnetism is an emerging magnetic phase with highly anisotropic spin-splitting of specific symmetries, but zero net magnetization. Here, we study Cooper pairing in metallic altermagnets connected to conventional s-wave superconductors. Remarkably, we find that the Cooper pairs induced in the altermagnets acquire a finite center-of-mass momentum, despite the zero net magnetization in the system. This anomalous Cooper-pair momentum strongly depends on the propagation direction and exhibits unusual symmetric patterns. Furthermore, it yields several unique features: (i) highly orientation-dependent oscillations in the order parameter, (ii) controllable 0-π transitions in the Josephson supercurrent, (iii) large-oblique-angle Cooper-pair transfer trajectories in junctions parallel with the direction where spin splitting vanishes, and (iv) distinct Fraunhofer patterns in junctions oriented along different directions. Finally, we discuss the implementation of our predictions in candidate materials such as RuO<sub>2</sub> and KRu<sub>4</sub>O<sub>8</sub>.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024finite,
  author = {Song-Bo Zhang and Lun‐Hui Hu and Titus Neupert},
  title = {{Finite-momentum Cooper pairing in proximitized altermagnets}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-024-45951-3},
}
Figure