Fine-Mapping and Selective Sweep Analysis of QTL for Cold Tolerance inDrosophila melanogaster

Ricardo Wilches, Susanne Voigt, Pablo Duchen, Stefan Laurent, Wolfgang StephanG3 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study fine-maps quantitative trait loci (QTL) for cold tolerance in Drosophila melanogaster and integrates this with population genetics to identify genes under selection. They pinpointed a strong selective sweep in European populations that, surprisingly, did not overlap with candidate genes for cold tolerance, but identified brinker, a gene just outside the sweep, as a new candidate for cold tolerance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the genetic basis of complex, quantitative traits like cold tolerance is a major challenge. While quantitative genetics identifies regions (QTLs) associated with these traits, and population genetics identifies regions showing signatures of natural selection (selective sweeps), linking these two approaches to pinpoint specific genes has been difficult. This paper addresses the question of whether genes under strong recent selection (indicated by selective sweeps) are the primary drivers of adaptation in quantitative traits, or if adaptation relies more on subtle allele frequency shifts in standing variation. Specifically, they investigate the relationship between genes underlying variation in chill coma recovery time (CCRT), a proxy for cold tolerance, and regions showing evidence of selective sweeps in Drosophila melanogaster populations from temperate (European) and tropical (African) regions.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Quantitative Complementation Mapping: They used a set of X-linked chromosomal deficiencies in Drosophila to precisely narrow down the genomic region containing QTL for CCRT. This involves crossing flies carrying a deficiency with flies carrying different X-chromosome alleles and observing if the resulting offspring exhibit altered CCRT, indicating a failure to complement and thus the presence of a relevant gene within the deficiency's span.
  • Population Genetics Analysis:
    • Selective Sweep Detection: They used the Composite Likelihood Ratio (CLR) test, implemented in the SweeD software, to identify regions of the genome showing strong evidence of recent positive selection (selective sweeps) in European populations. This method compares the observed site frequency spectrum (SFS) to what is expected under neutral evolution.
  • Genetic Differentiation (FST Scan): To identify genes under selection across a broader geographic range, they calculated FST values between multiple African and European populations. SNPs with high FST values are indicative of significant allele frequency differences, potentially driven by local adaptation.
  • Gene Expression Analysis (RT-qPCR): They measured the expression levels of candidate genes in both temperate and tropical Drosophila populations under control and cold-stress conditions. This helps to identify genes whose expression is altered by cold and might therefore be involved in cold tolerance.
  • P-element Insertion Lines: For candidate genes within or near the sweep region, they used lines with P-element insertions to perform further quantitative complementation tests, aiming to functionally validate their role in CCRT.

Datasets

  • Drosophila melanogaster Populations: The study utilized whole-genome sequence data from multiple D. melanogaster populations, including:
  • European populations: Netherlands (NL) and France (FR).
  • African populations: Rwanda (RG), Southeast Africa (SEA), Ethiopia (ED), Cameroon (CO), South Africa (SP).
  • D. simulans was used as an outgroup for divergence estimates.
  • Deficiency Lines: A collection of 24 overlapping X-linked chromosomal deficiency lines from the Bloomington stock center were used for fine-mapping.
  • P-element Insertion Lines: Lines with P-element insertions in candidate genes were used for functional validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Selective Sweeps Don't Always Target the Obvious: The most striking finding is that the region showing the strongest signature of a selective sweep in European populations did not contain the genes directly responsible for the observed variation in cold tolerance. This challenges the assumption that strong recent selection primarily acts on genes directly involved in the adaptive trait.
  • Candidate Genes Outside Sweeps: The study successfully identified brinker as a new candidate gene for cold tolerance. Crucially, brinker is located just outside the strong selective sweep region, suggesting that adaptation to cold might involve genes that are not under intense recent directional selection, or that selection on brinker is more subtle.
  • Differential Gene Expression as a Clue: The finding that brinker is induced by cold stress in a population-specific manner (higher expression in temperate vs. tropical populations) provides strong functional evidence for its role in cold tolerance.
  • Complexities of Quantitative Trait Adaptation: The results highlight that adaptation of quantitative traits might involve a combination of subtle allele frequency shifts in standing variation (affecting genes like brinker) and potentially other selective pressures acting on genes within strong sweeps, but not necessarily for the same trait.

Key Results

  • Quantitative complementation mapping narrowed down a 6.2 Mb QTL interval to two smaller regions: 131 kb and 124 kb.
  • The 124 kb region co-localized with a very strong selective sweep in European populations, showing CLR values in the top 1% of the X-chromosome.
  • None of the genes within this strong sweep region showed direct evidence of involvement in CCRT through gene expression analysis or P-element complementation tests.
  • The gene brinker, located just outside the sweep region, was found to be significantly induced by cold stress, particularly in the temperate (Netherlands) population, making it a strong candidate for CCRT variation.
  • Analysis of highly differentiated SNPs revealed potential targets of selection in the gene CG1677, but these were not directly linked to cold tolerance in their functional assays.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Distinguishing Allelic vs. Epistatic Interactions: The authors acknowledge that quantitative complementation mapping can be challenging to distinguish between true allelic failures to complement and epistatic interactions with other loci. However, they argue that their combined approach mitigates this limitation.
  • Functional Validation of Sweep Genes: While they tested some genes within the sweep, the lack of P-element lines for all candidate genes means that the functional role of all genes within the sweep remains uncharacterized.
  • Mechanism of brinker Adaptation: The exact mechanism by which brinker contributes to cold tolerance and how its allele frequencies have diverged between temperate and tropical populations remains an open question, though they suggest weak selection on polygenic traits might be involved.
  • Broader Implications for Quantitative Trait Evolution: The study raises important questions about the relative roles of strong selective sweeps versus subtle allele frequency changes in driving adaptation of complex traits, suggesting that adaptation might not always be driven by the most obvious signatures of selection. Future work could explore the specific selective pressures that shaped the sweep region and further investigate the role of brinker in cold tolerance across a wider range of environmental conditions and populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

There is a growing interest in investigating the relationship between genes with signatures of natural selection and genes identified in QTL mapping studies using combined population and quantitative genetics approaches. We dissected an X-linked interval of 6.2 Mb, which contains two QTL underlying variation in chill coma recovery time (CCRT) in Drosophila melanogaster from temperate (European) and tropical (African) regions. This resulted in two relatively small regions of 131 kb and 124 kb. The latter one co-localizes with a very strong selective sweep in the European population. We examined the genes within and near the sweep region individually using gene expression analysis and P-element insertion lines. Of the genes overlapping with the sweep, none appears to be related to CCRT. However, we have identified a new candidate gene of CCRT, brinker, which is located just outside the sweep region and is inducible by cold stress. We discuss these results in light of recent population genetics theories on quantitative traits.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wilches2014fine,
  author = {Ricardo Wilches and Susanne Voigt and Pablo Duchen and Stefan Laurent and Wolfgang Stephan},
  title = {{Fine-Mapping and Selective Sweep Analysis of QTL for Cold Tolerance in<i>Drosophila melanogaster</i>}},
  booktitle = {G3},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1534/g3.114.012757},
}
Figure