Field Comprehensive Testing and Study on New Subgrade Structure of High-Speed Railway in Diatomaceous Earth Region

Huiqin Guo, Qian Su, Taifeng Li, Qianli Zhang, Mahantesh M. Nadakatti, Hongye Yan, Chen FengSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel Waterproof and Drainage Subgrade (WDS) structure featuring a capillary waterproof and drainage layer (WDL) to address the challenges of building high-speed railways on highly compressible and water-sensitive diatomaceous earth. Field tests demonstrate that the WDS effectively prevents water infiltration, maintains subgrade stability, and enhances vibration damping, making it suitable for these challenging geological conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

High-speed railways are increasingly being built in diverse geological terrains. The Hang-Tai High-speed Railway in China presents a unique challenge as it traverses a significant diatomaceous earth region, a first for Chinese high-speed rail construction. Diatomaceous earth is problematic due to its high compressibility, tendency to swell and disintegrate, and a drastic reduction in strength when exposed to water. These properties, combined with high precipitation levels in the region, pose a serious threat to the long-term stability and safety of the railway subgrade, especially for ballastless track systems which have strict settlement tolerances. Existing research and construction experience for high-speed railways in such environments are limited, necessitating the development of specialized subgrade structures.

Methods

The researchers proposed a new subgrade structure, the Waterproof and Drainage Subgrade (WDS), incorporating a flexible Waterproof and Drainage Layer (WDL). This WDL is composed of capillary waterproof and drainage plates (CWDPs) interspersed with medium-coarse sand. To validate its effectiveness, a comprehensive field testing program was conducted on a test section. This program included:

  • Immersion Tests: These tests simulated rainfall conditions to evaluate the waterproof performance of the WDS, specifically focusing on the lap joints of the CWDPs and the overall water infiltration prevention. Soil moisture meters were used to monitor moisture content at various depths.
  • Excitation Tests: These tests simulated dynamic train loads using eccentric blocks to assess the dynamic characteristics and vibration damping capabilities of the WDS. Both natural and immersed conditions were tested, with a traditional subgrade (TS) serving as a control group. Dynamic stresses and accelerations were measured at different depths and across the cross-section.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on field testing data collected from a dedicated test section.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The WDL is a game-changer for diatomaceous earth: The core innovation is the WDL, which acts as a crucial barrier against water ingress, a primary cause of instability in diatomaceous earth.
  • Lap joint integrity is paramount: The effectiveness of the WDL hinges on proper installation, particularly the lap joints between CWDPs. The study confirms that a 15 cm lap width is sufficient to ensure waterproof performance.
  • Vibration damping is enhanced: The flexible nature of the WDL provides a significant energy dissipation effect, leading to improved vibration damping compared to traditional subgrade fillers.
  • Subgrade behavior is influenced by moisture: While the WDS effectively isolates the foundation from water, the subgrade above the WDL does show increased dynamic stress and acceleration under immersed conditions, highlighting the importance of the WDL's protective role.
  • Dynamic characteristics are preserved: Crucially, the introduction of the WDL does not fundamentally alter the way dynamic loads are transferred through the subgrade, ensuring compatibility with high-speed railway requirements.

Key Results

  • Waterproof Performance: The immersion tests showed no significant increase in soil moisture content below the WDL in the WDS, indicating effective isolation from water infiltration. In contrast, the traditional subgrade (TS) showed substantial moisture increase at lower levels.
  • Dynamic Stress Attenuation: The WDS demonstrated a higher dynamic stress attenuation coefficient compared to the TS, particularly in the depth range of the WDL. The reduction in attenuation coefficients for WDS was 23.09% (natural) and 30.12% (immersed), which were higher than for TS.
  • Acceleration Attenuation: Similarly, the WDS showed better acceleration attenuation along the depth, with coefficients of 26.24% (natural) and 25.72% (immersed), compared to TS.
  • Energy Dissipation: The WDL was found to have a more significant energy dissipation effect, contributing to the attenuation of dynamic response in both downward and cross-sectional directions.
  • Service Condition Impact: Dynamic stresses and accelerations were generally higher in immersed conditions compared to natural conditions, with dynamic stress being more sensitive to these changes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Structure Types: The study focused on only one type of waterproof and drainage structure (WDS with CWDP). Future work could explore other types of WDS for diatomaceous earth areas.
  • Simulated vs. Real Train Loads: The dynamic tests used simulated train loads. Future research should involve dynamic tests under actual moving train loads once the railway is operational to provide a more realistic assessment.
  • Construction Disturbance: The paper acknowledges that construction activities like excavation and filling can disturb soil structure. While the WDS aims to mitigate moisture-related issues, further research could investigate the combined effects of construction disturbance and moisture on subgrade stability.
  • Specialized Soil Applications: The findings suggest the WDL's applicability to other special soil types beyond diatomaceous earth, warranting further investigation into its performance in different challenging geological conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Part of the Hang-Tai High-speed Railway (Hangzhou via Shaoxing to Taizhou in Zhejiang Provence) in China passes through the diatomaceous earth area, which is the first time in the history of Chinese high-speed railway construction. This type of soil has significant compressibility, swelling and disintegration. Diatomaceous earth also shows a sharp reduction in strength when exposed to water, which severely impacts the safety of the project. However, no studies have been carried out on the engineering practice of building a high-speed railway in the diatomaceous earth area in China. Moreover, there is limited experience in the construction of ballastless track through the diatomaceous earth area. In order to ensure the stability of the high-speed railway subgrade in diatomaceous earth area, and considering the high level of precipitation in the location of this railway, a kind of waterproof and drainage subgrade (WDS) is proposed to reduce the influence of precipitation on the strength of the diatomaceous earth foundation. The subgrade has a flexible waterproof and drainage layer (WDL) inside, which consists of capillary waterproof and drainage plates and medium-coarse sand. In the present study, field tests including immersion tests and excitation test are carried out on a subgrade test section to verify the subgrade structure. The tests mainly focus on construction technology, waterproof performance and dynamic characteristics. The studies show that the subgrade bed with the WDL can effectively avoid the diatomaceous earth foundation from rainfall interference and maintain the long-term stability of the subgrade. The flexible WDL in WDS has a significant energy dissipation effect in comparison with the traditional subgrade (TS) filler and can play a key role in vibration damping, promoting the attenuation of dynamic response in the downward and cross-sectional directions within the subgrade. The dynamic response of the WDS attenuates along the depth. In comparison with the existing high-speed railway subgrade measured data, its dynamic response attenuation coefficient is within acceptable limits. The laying of the WDL does not change the subgrade dynamic characteristics transfer law. The proposed structure meets the requirements of ballastless track construction for high-speed railways, and the WDL can be used in the design of high-speed railways for enhanced drainage protection in diatomaceous soil areas or other special soil areas.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2023field,
  author = {Huiqin Guo and Qian Su and Taifeng Li and Qianli Zhang and Mahantesh M. Nadakatti and Hongye Yan and Chen Feng},
  title = {{Field Comprehensive Testing and Study on New Subgrade Structure of High-Speed Railway in Diatomaceous Earth Region}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15086912},
}
Figure