Uncovering the Hidden Ferroaxial Density Wave as the Origin of the Axial Higgs Mode in RTe$_3$

Birender Singh, Grant McNamara, Kyung-Mo Kim, Saif Siddique, Stephen D. Funni, Weizhe Zhang, Xiangpeng Luo, Piyush Sakrikar, Eric M. Kenny, Ratnadwip Singha, С. Г. Алексеев, Sayed Ali Akbar Ghorashi, T. J. Hicken, C. Baines, H. Luetkens, Yiping Wang, Vincent Plisson, Michael Geiwitz, Connor A. Occhialini, Riccardo Comin, M. J. Graf, Liuyan Zhao, Jennifer Cano, Rafael M. Fernandes, Judy Cha, Leslie M. Schoop, Kenneth S. Burch

TL;DR

Researchers have identified a "hidden" ferroaxial order as the source of the mysterious axial Higgs mode in rare-earth tritellurides ($RTe_3$). By combining four distinct experimental probes, the team demonstrated that this unconventional state arises from a complex coupling of charge and orbital textures, establishing a new standard for detecting hidden orders in quantum materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In condensed matter physics, a Charge Density Wave (CDW) is a spontaneous, periodic modulation of electron density in a crystal. Like superconductors, CDWs have a "Higgs mode"—a collective excitation representing the oscillation of the order parameter's amplitude.

Standard theory predicts the Higgs mode should be a "scalar," meaning it shares the same symmetry as the underlying crystal. However, recent experiments in $RTe_3$ materials discovered an axial Higgs mode, which rotates the polarization of light. This anomaly suggested a "hidden order"—a secondary symmetry-breaking event that wasn't captured by standard CDW models. The challenge was to prove what this hidden order was and how it coupled to the electrons and the lattice.

Methods

The authors employed a "multi-messenger" approach to fingerprint the symmetries of $ErTe_3$, $HoTe_3$, and $LaTe_3$:

  • Polarized Raman Spectroscopy: Used to observe the Higgs modes. By rotating the sample and measuring the "Rotational Anisotropy" (RA), they could determine the exact symmetry (scalar vs. axial) of the excitations.
  • Large-Angle Convergent Beam Electron Diffraction (LACBED): An advanced Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) technique. Unlike standard diffraction, LACBED is incredibly sensitive to minute changes in crystal symmetry, allowing the team to detect "monoclinic" distortions that are otherwise invisible.
  • Rotational Anisotropy Second-Harmonic Generation (RA-SHG): A nonlinear optical probe used to detect if the material breaks inversion symmetry (becoming polar) or mirror symmetries.
  • Muon-Spin Relaxation ($\mu$SR): A highly sensitive probe for local magnetic fields, used here to confirm that the hidden order does not break time-reversal symmetry (i.e., it isn't magnetic).

Datasets

As an experimental physics paper, the "datasets" consist of high-resolution physical measurements rather than large-scale databases:

  • Materials: High-quality single crystals of $ErTe_3$, $HoTe_3$, and $LaTe_3$ grown via a self-flux technique.
  • Spectroscopic Data: Temperature-dependent Raman spectra and SHG polar plots.
  • Structural Data: LACBED patterns and atomic-resolution STEM images.
  • Magnetic Data: Zero-field $\mu$SR time spectra.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Ferroaxial Smoking Gun: The high-temperature CDW (CDW1) breaks all vertical and diagonal mirror symmetries but preserves inversion and time-reversal. This specific combination defines a ferroaxial state—a circulating pattern of electric dipoles.
  • A Built-in Control Experiment: $ErTe_3$ and $HoTe_3$ undergo two CDW transitions. The authors found that the first transition (CDW1) produces an axial Higgs mode, while the second (CDW2) produces a standard scalar Higgs mode. This proves that the axial nature is a unique property of the specific electronic texture in CDW1, not a general feature of the material class.
  • Orbital-Charge Coupling: The ferroaxial order isn't just a lattice shift; it's driven by "orbital texture." The $p$-orbitals of the Tellurium atoms are occupied in a way that creates a hidden electronic rotation, which then weakly distorts the lattice into a monoclinic structure.

Key Results

  • Symmetry Identification: The team confirmed the high-temperature CDW state belongs to the $C_{2h}$ point group (monoclinic), while the normal state is effectively tetragonal ($D_{4h}$).
  • Higgs Mode Characterization: Raman data showed the CDW1 Higgs mode has a two-fold angular response (axial), whereas the CDW2 mode has a four-fold response (scalar).
  • Lattice vs. Electronic Sector: While LACBED confirmed a monoclinic lattice distortion, the effect was much more pronounced in the Raman and SHG data, suggesting the ferroaxial order has a "much stronger imprint on the electronic sector."
  • Non-Magnetic Origin: $\mu$SR results showed no increase in relaxation rates at low temperatures, definitively ruling out time-reversal symmetry breaking (TRSB).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Weak Lattice Coupling: The structural distortion associated with the ferroaxial order is extremely small, making it difficult to probe with standard X-ray or electron diffraction. This highlights the need for specialized tools like LACBED.
  • Microscopic Mechanism: While the paper aligns with theories involving orbital-driven order, the exact extent to which "quantum geometry" (the shape of the electron wavefunctions) plays a role remains an open question.
  • Broader Application: The authors suggest that searching for axial Higgs modes could reveal hidden ferroaxial orders in other high-profile materials, such as Kagome metals ($CsV_3Sb_5$) and transition metal dichalcogenides ($TiSe_2$).

Summary updated

Abstract

The recent discovery of an axial amplitude (Higgs) mode in the long-studied charge density wave (CDW) systems GdTe$_3$ and LaTe$_3$ suggests a heretofore unidentified hidden order. A theoretical study proposed that the axial Higgs results from a hidden ferroaxial component of the CDW, which could arise from non-trivial orbital texture. Here, we report extensive experimental studies on ErTe$_3$ and HoTe$_3$ that possess a high-temperature CDW similar to other RTe$_3$ (R = rare earth), along with an additional low-temperature CDW with an orthogonal ordering vector. Combining Raman spectroscopy with large-angle convergent beam electron diffraction (LACBED), rotational anisotropy second-harmonic generation (RA-SHG), and muon-spin relaxation ($μ$SR), we provide unambiguous evidence that the high-temperature CDW breaks translation, rotation, and all vertical and diagonal mirror symmetries, but not time-reversal or inversion. In contrast, the low-temperature CDW only additionally breaks translation symmetry. Simultaneously, Raman scattering shows the high-temperature CDW produces an axial Higgs mode while the low-temperature mode is scalar. The weak monoclinic structural distortion and clear axial response in Raman and SHG are consistent with a ferroaxial phase in RTe$_3$ driven by coupled orbital and charge orders. Thus, our study provides a new standard for uncovering unconventional orders and confirms the power of Higgs modes to reveal them.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{singh2025uncovering,
  author = {Birender Singh and Grant McNamara and Kyung-Mo Kim and Saif Siddique and Stephen D. Funni and Weizhe Zhang and Xiangpeng Luo and Piyush Sakrikar and Eric M. Kenny and Ratnadwip Singha and С. Г. Алексеев and Sayed Ali Akbar Ghorashi and T. J. Hicken and C. Baines and H. Luetkens and Yiping Wang and Vincent Plisson and Michael Geiwitz and Connor A. Occhialini and Riccardo Comin and M. J. Graf and Liuyan Zhao and Jennifer Cano and Rafael M. Fernandes and Judy Cha and Leslie M. Schoop and Kenneth S. Burch},
  title = {{Uncovering the Hidden Ferroaxial Density Wave as the Origin of the Axial Higgs Mode in RTe$\_3$}},
  booktitle = {Nature Physics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s41567-025-03008-2},
}

Loading related content...

Figure