Federated Gaussian Process: Convergence, Automatic Personalization and Multi-fidelity Modeling

Xubo Yue, Raed Al Kontar

TL;DR

This paper introduces FGPR, a novel federated learning framework for Gaussian Processes (GPs) that enables personalized modeling across devices without sharing raw data. FGPR theoretically guarantees convergence and empirically demonstrates superior performance in multi-fidelity modeling and other applications, highlighting its ability to automatically personalize models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of applying federated learning (FL) to Gaussian Processes (GPs). While FL has seen success in deep learning, its application to GPs is hindered by the inherent correlations in GP data, which make standard FL aggregation techniques (like averaging) problematic. These correlations mean that the loss function doesn't simply sum over individual data points, and mini-batch gradients become biased. Furthermore, many real-world applications, such as multi-fidelity modeling, involve complex, correlated data where GPs excel but traditional FL struggles. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a theoretically sound and empirically effective federated GP framework.

Methods

The core of the proposed method, FGPR (Federated Gaussian Process Regression), combines two key ideas:

  • Federated Averaging (FedAvg) for Model Aggregation: Similar to standard FL, FGPR uses an averaging strategy to aggregate model parameters from participating clients.
  • Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD) for Local Computations: Each client uses SGD to update its local GP model parameters based on its own data.

What's novel is how FGPR leverages the GP's inherent structure. Instead of just averaging model parameters, FGPR learns a shared global GP prior across all clients. This prior is then combined with each client's local data to produce a personalized posterior predictive distribution. This approach allows for automatic personalization without explicit meta-learning steps. The theoretical analysis focuses on proving convergence to a critical point of the full log-likelihood function, considering both homogeneous and heterogeneous data distributions, and for kernels with exponential or polynomial eigendecay.

Datasets

The paper evaluates FGPR on various simulated datasets and real-world benchmarks across different applications:

  • Simulated Datasets: Used to validate theoretical convergence properties and demonstrate FGPR's ability to recover true parameters.
  • Multi-fidelity Modeling Benchmarks:
    • CURRIN
    • PARK
    • BRANIN
    • Hartmann-3D
    • Borehole Model
  • NASA Aircraft Gas Turbine Engines Dataset: Used for predicting degradation signals.
  • SARCOS Anthropomorphic Robot Arm Dataset: Used for learning inverse dynamics in robotics.

The paper does not introduce new datasets but uses established benchmarks to demonstrate FGPR's effectiveness.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Automatic Personalization: FGPR's ability to learn a shared global GP prior and then condition on local data for personalized predictions is a significant insight. This means FGPR can tailor models to individual clients without explicit personalization steps, a key advantage over traditional FL methods that might require separate personalization phases.
  • GP Prior as a Foundation for Personalization: The paper highlights that in GPs, learning a model is equivalent to learning a prior. FGPR leverages this by learning a strong global prior that can then be adapted to local data, enabling effective personalization even with limited local data.
  • Bridging FL Theory and Correlated Data: The theoretical convergence guarantees for FGPR are crucial because they extend FL theory beyond independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) data to correlated settings, which is common in GP models. This opens doors for applying FL to a wider range of complex statistical models.
  • Multi-fidelity Modeling Advantage: FGPR proves to be a strong candidate for multi-fidelity modeling, outperforming existing methods by effectively borrowing strength from lower-fidelity datasets to improve predictions on high-fidelity data, all while preserving data privacy.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Convergence: FGPR is theoretically shown to converge to a critical point of the full log-likelihood function, with convergence rates dependent on iteration count, batch size, and kernel properties.
  • Superior Performance in Multi-fidelity Modeling: FGPR consistently achieved lower RMSE than benchmark models (Separate, AR, Deep) across various multi-fidelity problems, demonstrating its ability to effectively fuse information from different fidelity levels. For instance, in the CURRIN example, FGPR achieved an RMSE of 0.148±0.056, significantly better than the next best (Deep) at 0.252±0.064.
  • Accurate Prediction on Untrained Devices: FGPR showed good transferability, providing accurate predictions on devices with data patterns not seen during training.
  • Robustness to Initialization: FGPR demonstrated robustness to poor parameter initialization, effectively correcting initial errors over communication rounds.
  • Privacy Preservation: The federated nature of FGPR ensures that raw data remains on local devices, preserving privacy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Convergence of Length Parameter: The theoretical analysis provides convergence bounds for signal variance and noise parameters but not explicitly for the length parameter of the GP kernel, which remains an open problem even in centralized settings.
  • Extension to Multi-output GPs: The current framework is for single-output GPs. Extending it to multi-output GPs, which involves capturing correlations across outputs in a federated setting, is a challenging but interesting future direction.
  • Adaptive Weight Assignment: The paper uses fixed weights for clients based on their data size. Investigating adaptive assignment of these weights could further improve performance.
  • Theoretical Guarantees for Matérn Kernels: While empirical results are shown for Matérn kernels, the theoretical analysis for the length parameter's convergence is more challenging compared to RBF kernels.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we propose \texttt{FGPR}: a Federated Gaussian process ($\mathcal{GP}$) regression framework that uses an averaging strategy for model aggregation and stochastic gradient descent for local client computations. Notably, the resulting global model excels in personalization as \texttt{FGPR} jointly learns a global $\mathcal{GP}$ prior across all clients. The predictive posterior then is obtained by exploiting this prior and conditioning on local data which encodes personalized features from a specific client. Theoretically, we show that \texttt{FGPR} converges to a critical point of the full log-likelihood function, subject to statistical error. Through extensive case studies we show that \texttt{FGPR} excels in a wide range of applications and is a promising approach for privacy-preserving multi-fidelity data modeling.
BibTeX
@article{yue2021federated,
  author = {Xubo Yue and Raed Al Kontar},
  title = {{Federated Gaussian Process: Convergence, Automatic Personalization and Multi-fidelity Modeling}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Pattern Anal. Mach. Intell.},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1109/tpami.2024.3355289},
}
Figure