Feasibility study of ultrasound imaging for stereotactic body radiation therapy with active breathing coordinator in pancreatic cancer

Lin Su, Iulian Iordachita, Yin Zhang⋆, Junghoon Lee, Sook Kien Ng, Juan Jackson, T. Hooker, John Wong, Joseph M. Herman, H. Tutkun Şen, Peter Kazanzides, Muyinatu A. Lediju Bell, Chen Yang, Kai DingJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel arm-bridge system for real-time ultrasound monitoring during stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) for pancreatic cancer. The system demonstrates high accuracy in tracking phantom motion and feasibility in clinical workflows, offering a non-ionizing, cost-effective alternative for intrafraction motion management without compromising treatment planning quality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Pancreatic cancer treatment often involves stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT), which delivers high doses of radiation to tumors. A significant challenge in pancreatic SBRT is the respiratory motion of the pancreas, which introduces uncertainty in radiation delivery and can lead to toxicity. While various motion management techniques exist, such as respiratory gating and active breathing coordinator (ABC), intrafraction monitoring (tracking motion during treatment delivery) is crucial to further reduce uncertainty. Existing intrafraction monitoring methods often rely on ionizing radiation (e.g., X-ray based) or are limited in their application to specific sites. Ultrasound imaging offers a non-ionizing, real-time solution, but a practical setup for pancreatic SBRT, especially with an active breathing coordinator, was lacking. This paper addresses the need for a feasible and accurate ultrasound-based intrafraction monitoring system for pancreatic SBRT.

Methods

The core innovation is an arm-bridge system designed to hold an ultrasound probe in a fixed position relative to the patient during SBRT. This system consists of:

  • Couch top bridge: Attaches to various couch tops, providing a stable platform.
  • Articulated arms: Two passive arms (long for coarse adjustment, short for fine-tuning) allow for flexible positioning and orientation of the ultrasound probe.
  • Infrared tracker: Integrated with the probe case for precise tracking of its position.
  • Ultrasound probe case: Designed to accommodate the probe and the infrared tracker.

The system was integrated with a Clarity ultrasound acquisition system. The workflow involved:

  1. Virtual Simulation CT: The arm-bridge system was scanned and segmented from a CT image. This segmented model was then fused with previous patient CT scans to create a "virtual simulation CT" that included the probe's presence.
  2. Treatment Planning: Intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) and volumetric-modulated arc therapy (VMAT) plans were generated on these virtual simulation CTs, ensuring that radiation beams avoided the probe. These plans were compared to clinically treated plans.
  3. Phantom Study: An ultrasound phantom with simulated tumors was used to evaluate the tracking accuracy of the system. The ultrasound-tracked motion was compared against an infrared camera's ground truth.
  4. Volunteer Study: Three healthy volunteers underwent the patient setup for pancreatic SBRT with active breathing control (ABC). The reproducibility of the ABC breath-hold was assessed using the ultrasound monitoring system.

Datasets

  • Ten previously treated pancreatic SBRT patient CTs: Used for creating virtual simulation CTs and comparing treatment planning quality.
  • ABDFAN ultrasound phantom: Utilized for quantitative evaluation of ultrasound monitoring accuracy.
  • Three healthy volunteers: Recruited for assessing the feasibility and reproducibility of the system in a clinical workflow.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the gap for ultrasound in pancreatic SBRT: The arm-bridge system is a crucial development, enabling the practical application of ultrasound for intrafraction monitoring in a site where it was previously challenging to implement.
  • Non-ionizing monitoring is feasible: The study confirms that ultrasound, a non-ionizing modality, can provide real-time motion tracking without compromising treatment planning quality, offering a safer alternative to X-ray-based methods.
  • Integration into existing workflows: The system's design and the volunteer study suggest that it can be integrated into current clinical workflows, potentially with minimal disruption.
  • Phantom accuracy is high: The phantom study demonstrates sub-millimeter accuracy in tracking simulated motion, indicating the system's potential for precise monitoring.
  • Clinical reproducibility is promising: The volunteer study shows that the system can achieve reproducible breath-holds within a clinically acceptable margin.

Key Results

  • Phantom Monitoring Accuracy: The system achieved tracking accuracy of 0.14 ± 0.08 mm (left-right), 0.04 ± 0.1 mm (anterior-posterior), and 0.25 ± 0.09 mm (superior-inferior) on the phantom.
  • Volunteer Reproducibility: The reproducibility of ABC breath-hold in healthy volunteers was less than 2 mm.
  • Treatment Planning Quality: Virtual simulation plans generated with the arm-bridge system present passed institutional protocol criteria and showed comparable dosimetric results to clinically treated plans, with no significant differences in PTV coverage or OAR constraints.
  • Image Quality: Ultrasound images provided high contrast for the pancreas area, which was less apparent in CT or CBCT images.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Metal Artifacts: CT and CBCT images showed noticeable metal artifacts from the probe. The authors are exploring strategies like using a mock probe and investigating CT/CBCT reconstruction algorithms to mitigate this.
  • Image Quality Variability: Bowel or stomach gas can cause poor ultrasound image quality. Patient education on diet is suggested to improve this.
  • Soft Tissue Deformation: The impact of the probe's weight on soft tissue deformation and treatment planning was not fully assessed. Future studies with clinical patients will investigate this.
  • Mechanical Clearance and Stability: The design, mechanical clearance, imaging accessibility, and probe stability need more comprehensive evaluation in a pilot study on patients.
  • Clinical Trials: The authors plan future studies to concentrate on clinical trials with pancreas SBRT patients to optimize the workflow for real-time ultrasound monitoring.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our ultrasound system can be potentially used for real-time monitoring during pancreas SBRT without compromising planning quality. The phantom study showed high monitoring accuracy of the system, and the volunteer study showed feasibility of the clinical workflow.
BibTeX
@article{su2017feasibility,
  author = {Lin Su and Iulian Iordachita and Yin Zhang⋆ and Junghoon Lee and Sook Kien Ng and Juan Jackson and T. Hooker and John Wong and Joseph M. Herman and H. Tutkun Şen and Peter Kazanzides and Muyinatu A. Lediju Bell and Chen Yang and Kai Ding},
  title = {{Feasibility study of ultrasound imaging for stereotactic body radiation therapy with active breathing coordinator in pancreatic cancer}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1002/acm2.12100},
}
Figure