Feasibility of Direct Disposal of Salt Waste from Electochemical\n Processing of Spent Nuclear Fuel

R.p. Rechard, Teklu Hadgu, Yifeng Wang, Larry C. Sanchez, Patrick McDaniel, Corey Skinner, Nima Fathi, Steven A. Frank, Michael PattersonarXiv 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The US Department of Energy decided in 2000 to treat its sodium-bonded spent nuclear fuel, produced for experiments on breeder reactors, with an electrochemical process. The metallic waste produced is to be cast into ingots and the salt waste further processed to form a ceramic waste form for disposal in a mined repository. However, alternative disposal pathways for metallic and salt waste streams are being investigated that may reduce the processing complexity. As summarized here, performance assessments analyzing the direct disposal the salt waste demonstrate that both mined repositories in salt and deep boreholes in basement crystalline rock can easily accommodate the salt waste. Also summarized here is an analysis of the feasibility of transporting the salt waste in a proposed vessel. The vessel is viable for transport to and disposal in a generic mined repository in salt or deep borehole but a portion of the salt waste would need to be diluted for disposal in the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant. The generally positive results continue to demonstrate the feasibility of direct disposal of salt waste after electrochemical processing of spent nuclear fuel.

Introduction: The Challenge of Sodium-Bonded Fuel

The US Department of Energy (DOE) is responsible for managing "sodium-bonded" spent nuclear fuel (SNF) from legacy breeder reactor experiments, such as EBR-II and FFTF. Because metallic sodium reacts energetically with water, this fuel cannot be sent directly to a repository. To stabilize it, an electrochemical process is used to separate the fuel into metallic waste and a radioactive salt waste stream.

The current baseline plan involves converting this salt into a glass-bonded ceramic waste form (CWF). However, this process significantly increases waste volume—turning 1.72 metric tons of waste into approximately 51 tons of ceramic—and requires extensive "hot cell" space. This research investigates the feasibility of bypassing the CWF step and disposing of the salt waste directly.

Comparison of the baseline Ceramic Waste Form treatment versus the proposed Direct Disposal Option.

Methodology

The study utilized a multi-disciplinary modeling approach to evaluate direct disposal across three pathways: deep boreholes, mined salt repositories (e.g., the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant or WIPP), and commercial mined repositories.

  • Thermal-Hydrology: Researchers used PFLOTRAN, a 3D numerical code, to simulate how heat from the waste affects groundwater and contaminant plume migration.
  • Criticality and Shielding: The SCALE software suite was employed to ensure subcriticality during transport and disposal. Shielding requirements for transport casks were calculated using MAVRIC-MONACO.
  • Thermal Analysis: Heat decay profiles of salt waste were compared against standard high-level waste (HLW) to ensure repository temperature limits were respected.

Key Insights

Volume and Logistics

Avoiding the ceramic waste form drastically reduces the number of required canisters, simplifying long-term storage logistics and freeing up facility space.

Thermal Manageability

Thermal analysis indicates that while salt waste is warmer than typical transuranic waste, it is significantly cooler than standard spent fuel assemblies. The total added heat load to a repository like WIPP would be approximately 2%, which is manageable within structural integrity limits.

Heat output decay profiles for salt waste compared to standard spent nuclear fuel (SNF) and high-level waste (HLW).

Gravity as a Natural Barrier

In deep borehole simulations, the high salinity of the waste plume increases its density relative to surrounding groundwater. This causes the plume to move downward, further isolating contaminants from the accessible environment.

Criticality Safety

Despite higher plutonium concentrations than typical commercial waste, the chloride salts in the waste act as natural neutron absorbers. Modeling shows the multiplication factor ($k_{eff}$) remains well below 1.0, indicating negligible criticality risk.

Key Results and Regulatory Considerations

  • Shielding: Transporting the waste in an RH-TRU 72-B cask would require minimal additional shielding—roughly 0.5 to 1.0 cm of lead or 0.35 to 0.65 cm of depleted uranium.
  • WIPP Compliance: Mark IV salt waste exceeds WIPP’s statutory activity concentration limits. To comply, the waste would require either smaller containers or dilution by a factor of three.
  • Borehole Isolation: Modeling predicts that after 50,000 years in a deep borehole, a potential contaminant plume would travel only about 100 meters downward.

Conclusion

The technical analysis supports the feasibility of direct salt waste disposal. However, the primary remaining hurdles are regulatory. Implementing these findings would require amending transportation cask Certificates of Compliance and potentially updating repository Waste Acceptance Criteria. Future efforts will focus on the operational mechanics of loading these vessels within existing facilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

The US Department of Energy decided in 2000 to treat its sodium-bonded spent\nnuclear fuel, produced for experiments on breeder reactors, with an\nelectrochemical process. The metallic waste produced is to be cast into ingots\nand the salt waste further processed to form a ceramic waste form for disposal\nin a mined repository. However, alternative disposal pathways for metallic and\nsalt waste streams are being investigated that may reduce the processing\ncomplexity. As summarized here, performance assessments analyzing the direct\ndisposal the salt waste demonstrate that both mined repositories in salt and\ndeep boreholes in basement crystalline rock can easily accommodate the salt\nwaste. Also summarized here is an analysis of the feasibility of transporting\nthe salt waste in a proposed vessel. The vessel is viable for transport to and\ndisposal in a generic mined repository in salt or deep borehole but a portion\nof the salt waste would need to be diluted for disposal in the Waste Isolation\nPilot Plant. The generally positive results continue to demonstrate the\nfeasibility of direct disposal of salt waste after electrochemical processing\nof spent nuclear fuel.\n
BibTeX
@misc{rechard2017feasibility,
  author = {R.P. Rechard and Teklu Hadgu and Yifeng Wang and Larry C. Sanchez and Patrick McDaniel and Corey Skinner and Nima Fathi and Steven A. Frank and Michael Patterson},
  title = {{Feasibility of Direct Disposal of Salt Waste from Electochemical\textbackslash\{\}n Processing of Spent Nuclear Fuel}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1710.00855},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1710.00855},
}
Figure