Fallout of Lead Over Paris From the 2019 Notre‐Dame Cathedral Fire

Alexander van Geen, Yuling Yao, Tyler Ellis, Andrew Gelman

TL;DR

The 2019 Notre-Dame fire released significant lead (Pb) into the atmosphere, with soil samples revealing elevated Pb concentrations concentrated downwind of the cathedral. This study used soil sampling and Gaussian process regression to map this fallout, estimating 1 ton of excess Pb within a 1 km radius, highlighting the importance of rapid environmental monitoring after such events.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The catastrophic fire at Notre-Dame Cathedral in April 2019 involved the combustion of approximately 460 tons of lead (Pb) from its roof and spire. While initial reports indicated increased airborne Pb concentrations and some deposition downwind, the extent and spatial distribution of this lead fallout, particularly in the immediate vicinity of the cathedral, remained poorly quantified. This lack of detailed information posed a challenge for assessing potential public health risks, especially for vulnerable populations like children. The study aims to address this gap by providing a more precise estimate of lead deposition in the soil around the cathedral and understanding its spatial patterns.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Soil Sampling and Analysis: They collected 100 surface soil samples from various locations (tree pits, parks, sidewalks, gardens) within a 1 km radius of the cathedral. These samples were analyzed for lead (Pb) concentration using a handheld X-ray fluorescence (XRF) analyzer. The fine fraction of the soil was used to ensure consistency.
  2. Gaussian Process Regression Modeling: To model the spatial distribution of Pb concentrations and account for various factors like soil type, distance, and direction from the cathedral, a Gaussian process regression model was utilized. This statistical approach allows for flexible modeling of spatial patterns and provides uncertainty estimates for predictions. The model incorporated soil type coefficients and a spatial term that considered distance and bearing from the cathedral, using a product kernel for flexibility.

Datasets

  • Soil Samples: 100 surface soil samples collected between December 2019 and February 2020 within a 1 km radius of Notre-Dame Cathedral.
  • Existing Environmental Data: The study references data from the Agence Régionale de la Santé (ARS) regarding Pb concentrations in indoor dust, surface wipes, and some soil measurements, as well as airborne Pb monitoring data from Airparif.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Concentrated Downwind Fallout: The most striking insight is that the lead fallout was not uniformly distributed but was significantly concentrated in the downwind direction (northwest) of the fire, aligning with prevailing wind patterns.
  • Soil as a Reliable Archive: Surface soil proved to be a valuable medium for capturing and preserving the signal of lead fallout, offering a more persistent record than hard surfaces that are subject to washing and sweeping.
  • Excess Lead Inventory: The study quantified an estimated 1 ton of excess lead deposited within a 1 km radius, which is notably higher than the amount estimated to have dispersed further afield (e.g., 50 km away).
  • Soil Type Matters: Different soil types exhibited varying lead concentrations, with cracks in sidewalks showing higher levels, potentially due to historical contamination from leaded gasoline, while park areas were generally lower.
  • Public Health Implications: While the total amount of lead deposited locally is a small fraction of the cathedral's original lead, it was significant enough to warrant concern for immediate exposure, especially for children.

Key Results

  • Elevated Soil Pb: Surface soil Pb concentrations ranged from 30 to 9,000 mg/kg.
  • Downwind vs. Other Areas: The average Pb concentration in surface soil downwind of the cathedral was estimated at 430 mg/kg (95% interval: 300-590 mg/kg), nearly double the average of 240 mg/kg (95% interval: 170-320 mg/kg) in other directions.
  • Excess Pb Inventory: An estimated 1.0 ton (95% interval: 0.5-1.5 tons) of excess Pb was deposited within a 1 km radius of the cathedral.
  • Comparison to Further Fallout: This localized deposition (1 ton within 1 km) was over 6 times the estimated amount of Pb deposited further downwind (150 kg beyond 1 km).
  • Comparison to Historical Sources: The estimated fallout from the fire was dwarfed by historical lead emissions from automobile traffic in France, which reached thousands of tons annually in the past.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Immediate Data: A significant limitation is the lack of immediate post-fire soil, dust, and blood samples, making it difficult to definitively assess the peak human exposure levels and the effectiveness of the initial public health response.
  • Extrapolation Beyond 1 km: The study did not collect data within 100 meters of the cathedral, and inferences beyond 1 km are based on extrapolation, leading to larger uncertainty.
  • Soil Type Variability: While soil type was modeled, some variability within categories (e.g., gardens) and potential localized sources (e.g., lead paint) could not be entirely ruled out.
  • Future Work Suggestions: The authors strongly advocate for the establishment of large, readily deployable environmental investigation teams in major cities to conduct immediate measurements after toxic events. They also emphasize the need for better communication of environmental data to the public and proactive door-to-door health assessments for at-risk populations, particularly children.

Summary updated

Abstract

The roof and spire of Notre-Dame cathedral in Paris that caught fire and collapsed on 15 April 2019 were covered with 460 t of lead (Pb). Government reports documented Pb deposition immediately downwind of the cathedral and a twentyfold increase in airborne Pb concentrations at a distance of 50 km in the aftermath. For this study, we collected 100 samples of surface soil from tree pits, parks, and other sites in all directions within 1 km of the cathedral. Concentrations of Pb measured by X-ray fluorescence range from 30 to 9,000 mg/kg across the area, with a higher proportion of elevated concentrations to the northwest of the cathedral, in the direction of the wind prevailing during the fire. By integrating these observations with a Gaussian process regression model, we estimate that the average concentration of Pb in surface soil downwind of the cathedral is 430 (95% interval, 300-590) mg/kg, nearly double the average Pb concentration in the other directions of 240 (95% interval, 170-320) mg/kg. The difference corresponds to an integrated excess Pb inventory within a 1 km radius of 1.0 (95% interval, 0.5-1.5) t, about 0.2% of all the Pb covering the roof and spire. This is over 6 times the estimated amount of Pb deposited downwind 1-50 km from the cathedral. To what extent the concentrated fallout within 1 km documented here temporarily exposed the downwind population to Pb is difficult to confirm independently because too few soil, dust, and blood samples were collected immediately after the fire.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{geen2020fallout,
  author = {Alexander van Geen and Yuling Yao and Tyler Ellis and Andrew Gelman},
  title = {{Fallout of Lead Over Paris From the 2019 Notre‐Dame Cathedral Fire}},
  booktitle = {GeoHealth},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1029/2020gh000279},
}
Figure