Fall Detection Algorithm Based on Inertial Sensor and Hierarchical Decision

Liang Zheng, Jie Zhao, Fangjie Dong, Zhiyong Huang, Daidi ZhongSensors 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel hierarchical fall detection system using inertial sensors and an XGBoost model. By combining feature importance-based dimensionality reduction with a three-level decision-making process, the system achieves high accuracy in detecting falls and determining their direction, offering a promising solution for elderly safety.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing global population of elderly individuals presents a significant challenge, as falls are a leading cause of injury-related death and disability in this demographic. The sudden and unpredictable nature of falls makes timely detection crucial for providing prompt medical assistance and mitigating severe consequences. Existing fall detection methods, particularly those relying solely on threshold-based approaches, often suffer from high false alarm rates and struggle to differentiate between falls and other high-acceleration activities. This paper aims to address these limitations by developing a more robust and accurate fall detection system that can also identify the direction of the fall.

Methods

The proposed fall detection algorithm is built upon a hierarchical decision-making framework and incorporates several key techniques:

  • Feature Importance Analysis (FIA) for Dimensionality Reduction: Before classification, the system employs FIA to optimize the feature space. This approach identifies and selects features that are most important for predicting falls, significantly reducing the dimensionality of the data. This not only speeds up the training process but also helps to preserve essential information.
  • Hierarchical Decision-Making: The algorithm operates in three distinct levels:
  • Level 1 (Threshold-Based Preliminary Assessment): This initial stage uses a simple threshold method to quickly filter out a large portion of non-fall activities (ADLs). Only data suspected of being a fall is passed to the next level, reducing computational load.
  • Level 2 (XGBoost Classification): For the data that passes the initial threshold, a powerful XGBoost classifier is used to make a more precise determination of whether a fall has occurred.
  • Level 3 (Direction Determination): If a fall is confirmed, a comparison-based method is used to determine the direction of the fall (forward, backward, left, or right).
  • XGBoost Algorithm: The paper leverages the XGBoost algorithm for its robust classification capabilities, known for its efficiency and accuracy in handling complex datasets.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is the Sisfall dataset. This dataset contains data from inertial sensors (accelerometer and gyroscope) capturing various activities of daily living (ADL) and different types of falls. The dataset includes data from young adults, older adults, and a participant aged 60 years. The paper also mentions using a self-made dataset for validation, which reportedly yielded even higher performance metrics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • FIA Outperforms PCA for Dimensionality Reduction: The study found that their proposed FIA method for dimensionality reduction was superior to Principal Component Analysis (PCA) in terms of maintaining accuracy while reducing feature dimensions. FIA preserves the original meaning of features, unlike PCA, which can lead to a loss of interpretability.
  • Hierarchical Approach Balances Efficiency and Accuracy: The three-level hierarchical structure is a clever way to manage computational resources. By using a fast, low-complexity threshold method first, the computationally intensive XGBoost model is only applied to a smaller subset of potentially fall-related data.
  • Feature Importance is Key to Efficient Feature Selection: The paper highlights that a significant portion of the initial 44 features had low importance. Identifying and discarding these low-importance features not only reduced dimensionality but also improved model accuracy and training speed.
  • Directional Fall Detection Adds Crucial Information: Beyond simply detecting a fall, determining the direction of the fall provides valuable context that could inform rescue efforts or rehabilitation strategies.

Key Results

The proposed fall detection algorithm demonstrated impressive performance:

  • Overall Accuracy: 98.19%
  • Sensitivity: 97.50%
  • Specificity: 98.63%
  • Fall Direction Classification Accuracy: 93.44%
  • Lead Time: The system could detect falls with an average lead time of 107.8 ms before impact, allowing for potential pre-impact intervention.

The dimensionality reduction process using FIA reduced the feature space from 44 to 16 dimensions, with the accuracy on the validation set reaching 96.78%. Training time was also reduced from 0.47s to 0.3s after dimensionality reduction.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:

  • Dataset Bias: The fall data collected primarily involved young individuals performing motivated falls, with safety precautions in place. This differs from real-world scenarios where elderly individuals may experience unmotivated falls, potentially leading to different sensor readings. Future work should expand the dataset to include more diverse and realistic fall scenarios, especially data from actual elderly individuals.
  • Physiological Data Integration: The paper suggests incorporating physiological parameters like blood pressure and blood oxygen levels to further enhance decision-making and improve fall detection accuracy.
  • Lead Time for Airbag Deployment: While the lead time of 107.8 ms is promising, it may still be too short for effective airbag deployment. Future research will focus on extending this lead time and developing integrated airbag safety protection devices to create a comprehensive fall detection and protection system.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the aging of the human body and the reduction in its physiological capacities, falls have become a huge threat to individuals' physical and mental health, leading to serious bodily damage to the elderly and financial pressure on their families. As a result, it is vital to design a fall detection algorithm that monitors the state of human activity. This work designs a human fall detection algorithm based on hierarchical decision making. First, this work proposes a dimensionality reduction approach based on feature importance analysis (FIA), which optimizes the feature space via feature importance. This procedure reduces the dimension of features greatly and reduces the time spent by the model in the training phase. Second, this work proposes a hierarchical decision-making algorithm with an XGBoost model. The algorithm is divided into three levels. The first level uses the threshold approach to make a preliminary assessment of the data and only transfers the fall type data to the next level. The second level is an XGBoost-based classification algorithm to analyze again the type of data which remained from the first level. The third level employs a comparison method to determine the direction of the falling. Finally, the fall detection algorithm proposed in this paper has an accuracy of 98.19%, a sensitivity of 97.50%, and a specificity of 98.63%. The classification accuracy of the fall direction reaches 93.44%, and the algorithm can efficiently determine the fall direction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zheng2022fall,
  author = {Liang Zheng and Jie Zhao and Fangjie Dong and Zhiyong Huang and Daidi Zhong},
  title = {{Fall Detection Algorithm Based on Inertial Sensor and Hierarchical Decision}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s23010107},
}
Figure