Factors influencing sensitivity of a rapid influenza diagnostic test in a community‐based population of kindergarten through 12th‐grade students: Wisconsin 2015–2020

Cristalyne Bell, Jennifer Birstler, Maureen Goss, Emily Temte, Shari Barlow, Guanhua Chen, Amra Uzicanin, Jonathan L. Temte

TL;DR

This study investigated factors influencing the accuracy of rapid influenza diagnostic tests (RIDTs) in K-12 students, finding that while specificity is high, sensitivity can be affected by symptoms like runny nose and nasal congestion, as well as patient age and time since symptom onset. Understanding these influences is crucial for correctly interpreting RIDT results in community settings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rapid influenza diagnostic tests (RIDTs) are widely used to quickly identify influenza infections. However, their performance, particularly sensitivity, can be unreliable, leading to a significant number of false negatives. While specificity is generally high (over 90%), sensitivity can vary dramatically, sometimes as low as 17.8%. This variability poses a challenge for accurate diagnosis and public health interventions, especially in community settings like schools. The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the potential for widespread use of rapid testing in non-clinical environments, but formal evaluations of factors affecting performance in these settings are still needed. This paper aims to address this gap by identifying specific factors that influence the sensitivity and specificity of a common RIDT (Sofia® influenza A + B FIA) in a large, community-based population of K-12 students.

Methods

The researchers utilized data from the Oregon CHild Absenteeism due to Respiratory Disease Study (ORCHARDS), a prospective study tracking respiratory illnesses in K-12 students in Southcentral Wisconsin. They analyzed paired results from the Quidel Sofia® influenza A + B fluorescent immunoassay (FIA) and a gold-standard RT-PCR test for influenza.

The core analytical approach involved binomial logistic regression models to assess associations between various factors and RIDT performance (sensitivity and specificity). Adjusted models were used to account for potential confounders. Key factors examined included:

  • Demographics: Age, sex.
  • Illness Characteristics: Influenza-like illness (ILI) definition, severity (mild, moderate, severe), vaccination status.
  • Symptoms: Presence or absence of specific symptoms like fever, cough, sore throat, chills, malaise, myalgia, runny nose, and nasal congestion.
  • Temporal Factors: Days from symptom onset.
  • Co-infections: Detection of other respiratory viruses.
  • Seasonality: Early, peak, or late influenza season.

The study specifically focused on identifying factors that could improve or decrease the sensitivity of the RIDT.

Datasets

The study used a dataset comprising 2368 paired results from Sofia® influenza A + B fluorescent immunoassay and RT-PCR tests collected during six sequential influenza seasons (2014-2015 through 2019-2020) from K-12 students in Wisconsin. This dataset represents a community-based sample, distinct from many previous studies that focused on clinical or hospitalized populations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Symptom-Driven Sensitivity: The presence of specific symptoms, particularly a runny nose and nasal congestion, significantly improves RIDT sensitivity. This suggests that these symptoms might correlate with a higher viral load, making detection easier.
  • Time is of the Essence: The longer the time since symptom onset, the lower the sensitivity of the RIDT. This highlights the critical window for accurate testing.
  • Age Matters: Older students tend to have lower RIDT sensitivity. This could be due to differences in immune response or viral shedding patterns compared to younger children.
  • Co-infections Reduce Sensitivity: The detection of other respiratory viruses alongside influenza is associated with lower RIDT sensitivity, suggesting potential interference or a more complex illness presentation.
  • Myalgia as a Negative Indicator: The presence of myalgia (muscle aches) is associated with lower sensitivity, which is counterintuitive and warrants further investigation.
  • Specificity Remains Robust: Despite variability in sensitivity, the specificity of the Sofia® test remained high across the board, meaning false positives were rare.

Key Results

  • Overall Performance: The Sofia® RIDT demonstrated an overall sensitivity of 76.1% (95% CI: 72.8-79.1) and a specificity of 97.2% (96.2-97.9).
  • Factors Influencing Sensitivity:
    • Runny nose: Increased sensitivity (OR = 3.0, p < 0.001).
  • Nasal congestion: Increased sensitivity (OR = 1.59, p = 0.045).
  • Days from symptom onset: Each additional day decreased sensitivity (OR = 0.75, p < 0.001).
  • Myalgia: Decreased sensitivity (OR = 0.60, p = 0.014).
  • Age: Each 5-year increase in age decreased sensitivity (OR = 0.55, p = 0.001).
  • Detection of another virus: Decreased sensitivity (OR = 0.50, p = 0.043).
  • No significant factors for specificity: None of the explored factors were significantly associated with the specificity of the test.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge two primary limitations:

  1. Single Test Type: The analysis is based on only one type of RIDT (Sofia®). Results may differ for other rapid tests.
  2. Geographic Specificity: The study was conducted in southcentral Wisconsin. Local influenza seasonality and prevalence might influence test performance, and findings may not be universally generalizable.

Future work could explore the feasibility of using RIDTs in school settings for early detection and intervention to reduce virus transmission and disruptions. Further research is also needed to investigate the mechanisms behind why certain symptoms (like myalgia) are associated with lower sensitivity and to explore the performance of other RIDTs in similar community-based populations. The study also suggests the need for future studies to explore the feasibility of RIDT-supported prevention programs in various congregate settings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rapid influenza diagnostic tests (RIDTs) have variable sensitivity. In a community-based population of kindergarten through 12th-grade (K-12) students, we assessed factors that may influence RIDT performance using 2368 paired results from Sofia® influenza A + B fluorescent immunoassay and reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). RIDT sensitivity and specificity were 76.1% (95% CI: 72.8-79.1) and 97.2% (96.2-97.9), respectively. Factors associated with sensitivity included runny nose (OR = 3.0, p < 0.001), nasal congestion (1.59, p = 0.045), days from symptom onset (per day; 0.75; p < 0.001), myalgia (0.61; p = 0.014), age (per 5 years; 0.55; p = 0.001), and detection of another virus (0.50; p = 0.043). Understanding these factors can aid in interpreting negative results.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bell2022factors,
  author = {Cristalyne Bell and Jennifer Birstler and Maureen Goss and Emily Temte and Shari Barlow and Guanhua Chen and Amra Uzicanin and Jonathan L. Temte},
  title = {{Factors influencing sensitivity of a rapid influenza diagnostic test in a community‐based population of kindergarten through 12th‐grade students: Wisconsin 2015–2020}},
  booktitle = {Influenza},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1111/irv.13064},
}

Loading related content...

Figure