Facebook and Privacy: The Balancing Act of Personality, Gender, and Relationship Currency

Daniele Quercia, Diego Las Casas, João Paulo Pesce, David Stillwell, Michał Kosiński, Virgı́lio Almeida, Jon Crowcroft

TL;DR

This paper applies Item Response Theory (IRT) to quantify how 1,313 Facebook users balance disclosure and concealment. The researchers discovered that privacy behavior is bimodal—splitting users into a "privacy-conscious" minority and a "pragmatic" majority—and identified that work-related information acts as "relationship currency," selectively shared with friends but hidden from the public.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While we all use social media, we don't all share the same way. Some users are open books, while others are digital hermits. Previous research attempted to link these differences to personality traits (like the "Big Five"), but results were often inconsistent or based on small samples of college students.

The authors address two main gaps:

  1. Measurement: Most studies simply count how many profile fields a user fills out. This is flawed because sharing your "religious views" is qualitatively different from sharing your "current employer."
  2. Scale and Diversity: They move beyond small undergrad samples to a larger, more diverse group of US Facebook users to see if personality truly predicts privacy behavior.

Methods

The researchers employed a mix of traditional psychometrics and novel modeling:

  • Personality Assessment: Users took the "Big Five" test (Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, Neuroticism) and a "Self-Monitoring" test (which measures how much people adapt their behavior to fit social situations).
  • Item Response Theory (IRT): This is the paper's methodological "secret sauce." Usually used in standardized testing to determine question difficulty, the authors adapted IRT to calculate a Disclosure Score. This allowed them to weight profile fields based on their "sensitivity" (how likely people are to hide them) and "discrimination power" (how well a field distinguishes a private person from an open one).
  • Two Privacy Models: They looked at what users share with the Community (the public) versus their Social Circle (friends).

Datasets

The study utilized data from the myPersonality Facebook application.

  • Sample: 1,313 Facebook users living in the United States.
  • Demographics: Median age of 24 (range 18–60); 58% women and 42% men.
  • Data Points: Personality scores, number of social contacts, and the visibility status of specific profile fields (e.g., hometown, political views, employer, relationship goals).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Privacy Divide is Bimodal: Unlike many human traits that follow a bell curve, disclosure scores showed two distinct peaks. Users tend to fall into either a small, highly privacy-conscious group or a much larger "pragmatic" group that is relatively open.
  • Information as "Relationship Currency": The authors found that work-related information (position and employer) and geographic data (hometown) are treated as high-value currency. Users selectively "spend" this information on their friends to maintain relationships but rarely "give it away" to the public.
  • The "Openness" Factor: Of the Big Five traits, Openness to Experience was the most consistent predictor of disclosure. People who are naturally curious and unconventional are more likely to have public-facing profiles.
  • Gender and the Public Stage: Interestingly, men and women share roughly the same amount of information with their friends. However, men are significantly more likely to make that sensitive information available to the general public.

Key Results

  • Sensitivity Rankings: Using IRT, the authors quantified field sensitivity ($\beta$). Employer ($\beta=9.9$) and Position ($\beta=8.4$) were the most sensitive/private fields, while Looking for (a partner) ($\beta=1.4$) was the most widely disclosed.
  • Correlation: Openness showed a significant positive correlation with public disclosure ($r=0.14$).
  • Predictive Power: A Naive Bayes classifier could correctly categorize 62% of users into their respective privacy groups (conscious vs. pragmatic) based on personality, though the authors note this only slightly outperforms a baseline that assumes everyone is "pragmatic."
  • Age and Popularity: Older users and those with fewer social contacts tend to be more private, disclosing fewer sensitive fields.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Self-Selection Bias: The dataset comes from users who chose to install a personality testing app, meaning they might already be more inclined toward self-disclosure than the average person.
  • Platform Specificity: The findings are specific to Facebook. The authors acknowledge that "privacy" looks different on LinkedIn (where work info is public) or Twitter.
  • Static Data: The study looked at profile fields but did not analyze more dynamic content like photos, wall posts, or "likes," which are major components of a modern digital footprint.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that social networks could use these insights to design better "default" privacy settings based on simple demographics like age and gender, helping users protect themselves without needing high levels of technical literacy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Social media profiles are telling examples of the everyday need for disclosure and concealment. The balance between concealment and disclosure varies across individuals, and personality traits might partly explain this variability. Experimental findings on the relationship between information disclosure and personality have been so far inconsistent. We thus study this relationship anew with 1,313 Facebook users in the United States using two personality tests: the big five personality test and the self-monitoring test. We model the process of information disclosure in a principled way using Item Response Theory and correlate the resulting user disclosure scores with personality traits. We find a correlation with the trait of Openness and observe gender effects, in that, men and women share equal amount of private information, but men tend to make it more publicly available, well beyond their social circles. Interestingly, geographic (e.g., residence, hometown) and work-related information is used as relationship currency, in that, it is selectively shared with social contacts and is rarely shared with the Facebook community at large.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{quercia2021facebook,
  author = {Daniele Quercia and Diego Las Casas and João Paulo Pesce and David Stillwell and Michał Kosiński and Virgı́lio Almeida and Jon Crowcroft},
  title = {{Facebook and Privacy: The Balancing Act of Personality, Gender, and Relationship Currency}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1609/icwsm.v6i1.14255},
}
Figure