Eye Tracking Data Collection Protocol for VR for Remotely Located Subjects using Blockchain and Smart Contracts

Efe Bozkir, Shahram Eivazi, Mete Akgün, Enkelejda Kasneci

Abstract

Eye tracking data collection in the virtual reality context is typically carried out in laboratory settings, which usually limits the number of participants or consumes at least several months of research time. In addition, under laboratory settings, subjects may not behave naturally due to being recorded in an uncomfortable environment. In this work, we propose a proof-of-concept eye tracking data collection protocol and its implementation to collect eye tracking data from remotely located subjects, particularly for virtual reality using Ethereum blockchain and smart contracts. With the proposed protocol, data collectors can collect high quality eye tracking data from a large number of human subjects with heterogeneous socio-demographic characteristics. The quality and the amount of data can be helpful for various tasks in data-driven human-computer interaction and artificial intelligence.

Introduction

Traditionally, eye-tracking research in Virtual Reality (VR) has been confined to controlled laboratory settings. While these environments offer precision, they create significant bottlenecks: the process is slow, expensive, and often results in a "WEIRD" (Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic) participant pool that lacks diversity. Furthermore, the "Hawthorne effect" suggests that participants may behave unnaturally when they are aware they are being monitored in a clinical lab setting.

Transitioning these studies to a remote crowdsourcing model (similar to platforms like Amazon Mechanical Turk) introduces two major hurdles. First, there is the issue of Trust and Integrity: researchers have no inherent way to verify if a remote user provided genuine data or simply uploaded random noise. Second, Privacy and Mediation concerns arise when centralized platforms take significant service fees and store sensitive biometric data, creating security risks for participants.

The Proposed Protocol

To address these challenges, the authors developed a decentralized protocol built on the Ethereum blockchain using Solidity smart contracts. This protocol eliminates the need for untrustworthy third-party intermediaries while ensuring data integrity and fair compensation through a clever "escrow" logic.

Overview of the proposed eye-tracking data collection protocol workflow involving the Data Collector, Subject, VR Application, and Blockchain-based Smart Contract.

The workflow, as illustrated in the figure above, follows these key technical pillars:

  1. Local Validation: The participant runs a VR application that automatically performs quality checks (e.g., tracking frequency and confidence intervals) at the end of a session. If the data quality is insufficient—perhaps due to poor calibration—the app rejects the data locally before it ever reaches the blockchain.
  2. White-Box Cryptography: To prevent users from spoofing valid data hashes, the VR application utilizes white-box cryptography. By hiding hashing keys within the application's binary code, it becomes nearly impossible for a user to generate a valid cryptographic signature for altered or fabricated data.
  3. The Staking Mechanism: To ensure "skin in the game," both the Data Collector and the Subject must stake double the compensation amount (2X) into a smart contract. If the participant provides valid data matching the on-chain hash, the contract automatically releases their stake plus the reward (3X total). If the participant attempts to cheat, they forfeit their stake.
  4. Off-Chain Data Transfer: To minimize "gas" fees and protect privacy, the actual eye-tracking data is sent directly from the subject to the collector off-chain. Only the cryptographic hash is stored on the blockchain for notarization and verification.

Implementation and Results

As this is a protocol-focused study, the authors utilized synthetic eye-tracking data to demonstrate the proof-of-concept. The implementation was successfully deployed on the Ropsten Testnet (an Ethereum testing environment) to verify the smart contract logic and transaction flows.

The results demonstrated that the blockchain serves effectively as a notary rather than a database, keeping the system efficient. By requiring a stake that outweighs the potential gain of cheating, the protocol creates a mathematical incentive for honesty. Furthermore, the authors proved the financial viability of the flow; for instance, a subject receiving a 0.025 ETH reward successfully ended the process with a net gain after accounting for staking and transaction fees.

Discussion and Future Work

While the protocol successfully automates data validation and payout, several challenges remain for widespread adoption. The "crypto barrier" is significant, as participants must currently own Ether and manage digital wallets. Additionally, the protocol assumes a secure direct communication channel for the off-chain data transfer.

Future research may explore the integration of Zero-Knowledge Proofs (ZKP) or Differential Privacy to further enhance participant anonymity on public blockchains. Additionally, as Ethereum mainnet fees can be volatile, the authors suggest that Layer 2 scaling solutions will be necessary to make small-scale research studies economically feasible.

Summary updated

Abstract

Eye tracking data collection in the virtual reality context is typically carried out in laboratory settings, which usually limits the number of participants or consumes at least several months of research time. In addition, under laboratory settings, subjects may not behave naturally due to being recorded in an uncomfortable environment. In this work, we propose a proof-of-concept eye tracking data collection protocol and its implementation to collect eye tracking data from remotely located subjects, particularly for virtual reality using Ethereum blockchain and smart contracts. With the proposed protocol, data collectors can collect high quality eye tracking data from a large number of human subjects with heterogeneous socio-demographic characteristics. The quality and the amount of data can be helpful for various tasks in data-driven human-computer interaction and artificial intelligence.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bozkir2020eye,
  author = {Efe Bozkir and Shahram Eivazi and Mete Akgün and Enkelejda Kasneci},
  title = {{Eye Tracking Data Collection Protocol for VR for Remotely Located Subjects using Blockchain and Smart Contracts}},
  booktitle = {AIVR},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/aivr50618.2020.00083},
}
Figure