Extended Graph Assessment Metrics for Regression and Weighted Graphs

Tamara T. Mueller, Sophie Starck, Leonhard F. Feiner, Kyriaki-Margarita Bintsi, Daniel Rueckert, Georgios Kaissis

TL;DR

This paper introduces new metrics to evaluate the quality of graph structures used in Graph Neural Networks (GNNs), specifically extending existing metrics to handle regression tasks and weighted graphs. This is crucial because the way a graph is constructed significantly impacts GNN performance, especially in medical applications where graphs are often learned end-to-end.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are powerful tools for learning from graph-structured data. However, their performance is highly sensitive to the underlying graph structure. When this structure isn't readily available (e.g., in "population graphs" built from medical data), researchers often need to construct it. This construction process is challenging, and existing metrics for evaluating graph quality (Graph Assessment Metrics or GAMs) are limited. They primarily focus on classification tasks and assume discrete, unweighted graphs, failing to address the growing need for GNNs in regression settings and with learned, continuous graph structures. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing more versatile GAMs.

Methods

The authors extend two key GAMs:

  • Homophily: Traditionally, homophily measures how likely neighboring nodes are to share the same label. The paper extends this to:
  • Regression tasks: Adapting the metric to quantify how similar the values of neighboring nodes are, rather than just their discrete labels.
  • Continuous adjacency matrices: Allowing evaluation of graphs where edge weights are learned and continuous, not just binary.
  • k-hop neighborhoods: Extending the metric to consider relationships beyond immediate neighbors, up to 'k' hops away.
  • Cross-Class Neighbourhood Similarity (CCNS): This metric assesses how similar the neighborhoods of nodes within the same class are, compared to nodes in different classes. The paper introduces:
  • CCNS distance: A single scalar value derived from the CCNS matrix, making it easier to interpret.
  • Continuous adjacency matrices: Adapting CCNS to work with weighted graphs.

Datasets

The paper evaluates their proposed metrics on a variety of datasets:

  • Benchmark Classification Datasets: Cora, CiteSeer, PubMed, Computers, Photo, and Coauthor CS. These are standard datasets for node classification tasks.
  • Medical Population Graphs:
    • TADPOLE: A neuroimaging dataset for Alzheimer's disease classification.
  • UK BioBank (UKBB): A dataset used for brain age prediction (regression task).
  • Synthetic Datasets: Generated for both classification and regression to provide a controlled environment for metric evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • GAMs are crucial for learned graphs: When graph structures are learned end-to-end (like with dDGM and cDGM), GAMs become essential for quality control and understanding model behavior, especially on validation/test sets.
  • Homophily correlates with performance: The paper consistently shows that as homophily increases (for classification) or regression homophily increases (for regression), model performance (accuracy or reduced MAE) generally improves.
  • k-hop metrics offer deeper insights: Evaluating metrics at different hop levels can reveal nuanced structural properties of the graph that might not be apparent from 1-hop analysis alone.
  • Overfitting detection: Differences in GAM values between training and test sets can indicate graph structure overfitting to the training data.
  • CCNS distance is a useful summary: The proposed CCNS distance provides a concise metric for evaluating the distinctiveness of class neighborhoods.

Key Results

  • The proposed extended GAMs (regression homophily, continuous homophily, CCNS distance for continuous matrices) show strong correlations with GNN model performance across various datasets and tasks.
  • For example, on the TADPOLE dataset, as training progresses, homophily increases with accuracy, and CCNS distance decreases, indicating better model performance and graph structure.
  • On the UKBB regression task, homophily increases as Mean Absolute Error (MAE) decreases, reinforcing the correlation between homophily and predictive performance.
  • The paper demonstrates that k-hop metrics can provide more informative insights than 1-hop metrics, even when GNN performance doesn't perfectly align with them, suggesting further research into their interplay.

Limitations and Future Work

  • CCNS for Regression: The paper explicitly states that CCNS is not defined for regression tasks as it requires class labels.
  • Norm Choice for DCCNS: While the L1 norm was used for DCCNS, the authors acknowledge that other norms could be explored.
  • Future Directions:
    • Extending weighted graph metrics to multiple hops.
  • Investigating other existing GAMs (e.g., normalized total variation, neighborhood entropy) for regression and weighted graphs.
  • Integrating these differentiable GAMs directly into the GNN learning pipeline as loss components to optimize for specific graph properties.

Summary updated

Abstract

When re-structuring patient cohorts into so-called population graphs, initially independent data points can be incorporated into one interconnected graph structure. This population graph can then be used for medical downstream tasks using graph neural networks (GNNs). The construction of a suitable graph structure is a challenging step in the learning pipeline that can have severe impact on model performance. To this end, different graph assessment metrics have been introduced to evaluate graph structures. However, these metrics are limited to classification tasks and discrete adjacency matrices, only covering a small subset of real-world applications. In this work, we introduce extended graph assessment metrics (GAMs) for regression tasks and continuous adjacency matrices. We focus on two GAMs in specific: \textit{homophily} and \textit{cross-class neighbourhood similarity} (CCNS). We extend the notion of GAMs to more than one hop, define homophily for regression tasks, as well as continuous adjacency matrices, and propose a light-weight CCNS distance for discrete and continuous adjacency matrices. We show the correlation of these metrics with model performance on different medical population graphs and under different learning settings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mueller2023extended,
  author = {Tamara T. Mueller and Sophie Starck and Leonhard F. Feiner and Kyriaki-Margarita Bintsi and Daniel Rueckert and Georgios Kaissis},
  title = {{Extended Graph Assessment Metrics for Regression and Weighted Graphs}},
  booktitle = {GRAIL/OCELOT @ MICCAI},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-031-55088-1\_2},
}
Figure