Extended Formulations for Polytopes of Regular Matroids

Rohit Gurjar, Nisheeth K. Vishnoi

TL;DR

This paper provides a simpler proof that the "base polytope" of a regular matroid can be represented by a "simpler" polytope (an extended formulation) with a number of facets that grows linearly with the number of elements and the rank of the matroid. This is significant because it offers a more efficient way to describe these geometric objects, which have applications in combinatorial optimization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In combinatorics and optimization, we often study geometric objects called polytopes that represent sets of solutions to problems. For matroids (mathematical structures that generalize concepts like linear independence), these are the "independence polytope" and the "base polytope." A key question is how complex these polytopes are to describe. Specifically, researchers are interested in their "extension complexity," which measures how many "extra" dimensions and facets are needed to represent the polytope in a simpler form. While it's known that some matroids lead to polytopes with exponentially complex descriptions, it was recently shown that regular matroids have a polynomial extension complexity. This paper aims to provide a simpler proof of this polynomial bound, specifically for the base polytope of regular matroids.

Methods

The authors construct an "extended formulation" for the base polytope of a regular matroid. This involves introducing new variables and constraints to define a larger polytope whose projection onto a subset of its dimensions is the original base polytope. The core of their method relies on a characterization of regular matroids using totally unimodular matrices. They build a new polytope $Q$ in $\mathbb{R}^{m \times n} \times \mathbb{R}^{m \times n} \times \mathbb{R}^m$ (representing matrices $Y$, $Z$, and vector $x$) defined by a system of linear inequalities and equalities. The key steps involve:

  1. Defining a base polytope $P$: This polytope is defined using variables $Y$ and $Z$ and a matrix equation involving the totally unimodular matrix $A$ representing the matroid.
  2. Introducing new variables and constraints: New variables $x_i$ are introduced, constrained by $x_i \ge y_{i,j} + z_{i,j}$. This forms the larger polytope $Q$.
  3. Showing integral vertices: They prove that the vertices of $P$ and $Q$ are integral (all coordinates are integers), which is crucial for their combinatorial interpretation.
  4. Connecting to base sets: They demonstrate that specific vertices of $Q$ correspond to the base sets of the matroid.
  5. Defining a face of $Q$: By adding the constraint $\sum x_i = n$, they define a face of $Q$. The projection of this face onto the $x$ coordinates is shown to be exactly the base polytope $P(B)$.

The proof is inspired by a construction for spanning tree polytopes and avoids using a complex decomposition theorem by Seymour.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Simplicity is key: The paper's main contribution is a simpler proof for a known result about the extension complexity of regular matroids. This suggests that elegant constructions can sometimes replace more involved theoretical machinery.
  • Totally unimodular matrices are powerful: The proof heavily leverages the properties of totally unimodular matrices, highlighting their fundamental role in representing regular matroids and enabling efficient polytope descriptions.
  • Extended formulations as a tool: The paper showcases the utility of extended formulations for reducing the complexity of describing combinatorial objects. By adding variables and constraints, they create a larger, more manageable structure.
  • Connection between matrix properties and polytope structure: The relationship between the entries of the inverse of submatrices of $A$ and the coordinates of the vertices of the constructed polytope is a key insight.

Key Results

The paper proves the following theorem: For a regular matroid $M$ with $m$ elements and rank $n$, there exists a polytope $Q_M$ in $\mathbb{R}^{m \times n} \times \mathbb{R}^{m \times n} \times \mathbb{R}^m$ such that:

  1. The number of facets in $Q_M$'s description is at most $2mn + m$.
  2. The number of equality constraints is $n^2 + 1$.
  3. The projection of $Q_M$ onto the first $m$ coordinates is exactly the base polytope $P(B)$.

This implies that the extension complexity of the base polytope $P(B)$ is $O(mn)$. The paper also states that this result extends to the independence polytope $P(I)$ of a regular matroid.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Regular Matroids Only: The result is specifically for regular matroids. A natural question is whether similar polynomial bounds can be achieved for other classes of matroids.
  • Focus on Base Polytope: While the paper mentions the result extends to independence polytopes, the primary construction and proof are detailed for the base polytope.
  • "Simple Proof" is Subjective: While the authors present a simpler proof, the underlying concepts of matroids, totally unimodular matrices, and extended formulations still require a solid mathematical background.

Future work could explore:

  • Generalizing these results to broader classes of matroids.
  • Investigating tighter bounds or alternative extended formulations.
  • Applying these findings to specific combinatorial optimization problems where regular matroids arise.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a simple proof of the fact that the base (and independence) polytope of a rank $n$ regular matroid over $m$ elements has an extension complexity $O(mn)$.
BibTeX
@misc{gurjar2016extended,
  author = {Rohit Gurjar and Nisheeth K. Vishnoi},
  title = {{Extended Formulations for Polytopes of Regular Matroids}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1701.00538},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1701.00538},
}
Figure